I just traded a S&W Bodyguard .380 for a Ruger LCR with the XS front sight earlier today. I’m a S&W guy when it comes to snubbies and have several and carry a 642-1 daily. This is my first LCR and I realize I haven’t bothered reading much on them compared to J frames.
What’s everyone’s opinion of them?
So far I like the grip even though it is bulky. The trigger is light, but not as smooth, compared to a J frame. I have an Apex Tactical J frame duty kit in my Centennial, so I think that evens them up some. Absolutely love the XS front sight! I paid extra for this version but definitely wanted it over the standard sights.
Last year a bunch of us got together and bought one for a co-worker of ours who is a pretty established firearms instructor for his 50th birthday. He had carried the same model 60 for about 20 years, shortly after putting alot of rounds through his new LCR he retired the model 60. He put the XS big dot on the front and he loves the thing, it now resides in his cargo pocket every shift.
I have one with the XS sights, standard and boot grips. I find it easier to shoot accurately than my 340M&P or 642. Not so much b/c the trigger pull is lighter, it’s because the trigger reach is a little longer and the geometry of the trigger shape and trigger guard shape allows me to curl my finger around the trigger without it getting pinched so when it breaks the muzzle doesn’t twitch to the right. No more aim for the right shoulder to hit center of mass.
My thumb knuckle doesn’t get cut by the cylinder release latch anymore. Empties extract more easily than a J, sometimes they all fall out without even hitting the rod. Felt recoil is less than the J frames when both have the boot grips due to the cushion in the LCR boot grip.
On mine, the little screw holding in the cylinder release latch would come loose but I have lock tighted it now.
I like the XS sights for their tritium and visibility but the flip side to them is the round/square shape mismatch makes it harder to obtain a consistently accurate sight picture at longer distances though I have fired a 3.5" 5 shot group offhand @25yds with the Speer 135gr+P load which is better than I could ever do with my J.
Speed strips and HKS 36 speedloaders work for them. Most holster manufs have models for the LCR now.
I have a Nemesis pocket holster, High Noon Split Decision and Don Hume JIT for it.
I am very new to revolvers, but I opted for the 642 because of the aluminum frame vs. polymer on the LCR, and after recently trying out the trigger on an LCR, I prefer my 642’s trigger partially because I can stage it. On the LCR that I looked at, the trigger could not be staged and it was one constant pull until break. I guess it’s whatever you prefer. I’m no Ruger hater either, I have an LCP and my 10/22 was my very first firearm.
Does yours rattle alot? I’ve noticed the internals make a lot of noise when shaking it. If I hold the trigger back after dryfiring it it doesn’t rattle. Obviously its just the trigger mechanism and thats fine, just annoying is all. Oh well, just me being picky.
Any quirks besides the cylinder release latch screw loosening up?
I took my LCR on a hike up a mountain. It was riding in the cargo pocket of my shorts around my knee area. From that position you could clearly hear it click as it swung back and forth and bounced off my leg. This probably isn’t the best way to carry the gun though for a variety of reasons.
Whenever I keep it in a pant or jacket pocket close to my body the gun does not rattle. Keeping it holstered IWB/OWB or in a jacket pocket would be your best bet.
I really like the trigger and the way the grips tame recoil. The gun is easy and fun to shoot.
Yes, I pocket carry and can hear the internals jingling -if there are no other sounds-. No other people will hear it and think gun, they’ll think keys or change.
Haven’t noticed any other quirks yet. Something that I wouldn’t mind changed:
User removable cylinder and crane for cleaning
Original grips with hard sides just like on the boot grip. I think that the original grip shape is one of the best for small revolvers, still pocketable but hand filling. But the sticky sides slow down the draw and rub against my bare skin when I carry IWB without undershirt so I use the boot grip.
The more I carry, the more situations I find where the LCR would be perfect. Even though it may not be as sexy as other offerings, there is no disputing the utility of this weapon.
I carried a 340 PD which was being destroyed by dirt, sweat and occasional inundation and immersion. I retired it for an LCR which is much easier to thoroughly clean and is more corrosion resistant.
The .357 version is a few ounces heavier than the .38 and that makes the difference for me. The .38 version is too light. It feels like I’ve got a squirtgun in my hand. The .357 is better, although probably not good enough to make me trade in my j-frame.
I’m a long time carrying j-frame guy and I recently shot an LCR and the first thing I noticed after several rounds down range, not cut up and split thumb knuckle. That has peaked my interest in this gun. Due to this “user induced injury” I usually wear one glove on my primary hand when shooting the j-frame for extended periods, works ok, since it is a BUG. The one I shot was a range rental gun and it too had a screw starting to back out of it, but I asked regarding the history of the gun, it has been a rental gun since coming into the store and has been cleaned twice in about 2 year period. Definitely want to shoot a coworker’s new LCR before making any decisions.
I really like my LCR. Great little pistol that you can take pretty much anywhere dressed in basically any attire of your choosing. That is important for a CCW.
I’ll justify your purchase.
I bought one as a birthday present for the wife when they first came out. I’m at the point where I’ll be selling my SP101 and finding an LCR for myself.
The trigger is great, has a nice radius, but as mhanna mentioned it is impossible to stage.
In the past I think two years, I have not found a gunsmith who works on them, though at this point there’s not much to do. Aftermarket is limited to a few grips and front sight posts. Fairly limited. Never found a person selling a front post with a gold bead and the wife hates XS sights, but it hasn’t been an issue for its given role.
I want to try the .357 model out of curiosity, but I can’t imagine it’s pleasant.
I can EASILY stage the trigger any time I want for an incredibly precise shot. I can get cloverleaf 5 shot groups off hand at 30’ by doing it. Just sayin, it is possible, at least with my 2 LCR’s…
357 Maggies that are full house suck A$$. No way around it, horrible. Mid range stuff like 125gr DPX or Rem Golden Saber are not bad at all, actually quite controllable IMHO…
I have about 800 rounds through each example with ZERO issues. Great snubbie!
The rattling sound is likely the transfer bar. They are fit loose to assure reliability. Most Ruger revolver rattle a bit when shaken. It’s nothing to think twice about.