http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOyaJ2UI7Ss&feature=player_embedded
Discussion:
Is this a fair argument and valid comparison? Why or why not?
Well, technically that’s a logical fallacy called equivocation, No true Scotsman… It’s those same sort of idiotic tactics that make anti gun people so unbelievable.
Also, most higher level courses are graded on a curve, so the entire crappy argument they are using is flawed from the gate.
It saved my bacon in one particularly horrendous graduate level course. 
GPA, pshaw. In high school redistribute hot girl friends and cool cars. 
That was great 
Yeah dont touch what I worked for
Actually it isn’t a bad analogy. Taxable income changes through various tax code provisions, government subsidies, etc.
“It’s different man.”
“How is it different?”
“It just is, because if it isn’t I look like a hypocrite. So it is.”
“Uh… OK.”
:sarcastic:
Redistributing your tuition/debt based on career prospects would be effective without the bad equivocation.