Primary Arms Advanced Micro Dot

Go on youtube. This is literally the first optic by PA that ive seen torture test after torture test on a newly released optic. Theres like 8 different third party torture tests on it. None of them seem to be extended though so youll have to wait for that.

I have a number or AK and ARs. A handful have PROs, EoTech, and T1 set ups. The rest get TRS and PA. I also have a couple with cheap 1-4 and 1-6 scopes which I decided I would prefer not to go to a more expensive variable.

The only issue I have had with a PA sight, one of their new advanced lifetime warranty ones, was I thought it would not hold zero. Came to be the real issue is the claw mount (it is on a PTR-91)

I ran an EoTech on my work gun, and was a turn on my sight when leaving on a mission guy. If you are a leave your aimpoint on all the time guy you are going to kill your batteries or hit auto shut off if you are running any thing but an aimpoint.

I am not going to put a 600$ optic on dozens of guns.

But for one or two carbines, with PROs often available for under 400$ delivered,
I think that is the best way to go.

I’ve done my best to figure out the round count for my Tantal, and the closest I can get is around 6000 rounds. I regularly run 100-round drills in it and I verify zero every time I go to the range. With all of that use, it’s never lost zero, which is more than I can say for some of my other guns/optics.

Ak-smoking.jpg

Like I said before, I’d bet my life on this rifle in a heartbeat.

Sounds like overall positives from everyone!

What’s a good but budget AR mount? Is QD needed if I only have one rifle?

Thanks!

Get the QD ADM mount that PA bundles with it. As I said previously I would not use this on my primary rifle.

I am just a petit civilian urbanite and have never been in combat or in gunfire, so please forgive my ignorance as I ask this. I hope this question so that I can be educated, learn from you guys, and hopefully not stir too much of a controversy…

Many have voiced something along the lines of “I would not use XYZ (usually other than Aimpoint or Eotech) on my primary/home defense/etc rifle.” While I totally understand wanting the best in an emergency, I can’t help but wonder:

  1. What is the lifetime risk that such a “SHTF” emergency would happen to most individuals?
  2. Even in such a situation, what is the likelihood these good budget optics would fail (like a Bushnell/Vortex/PA), and is it a significantly greater chance than an Aimpoint/Eotech? Is this proven?
  3. Even if someone broke into my home, the distances are so short that maybe a failed optic may not even matter?

The bottom line is that I wonder if the extra $$ for an Aimpoint/Eotech for most of us civilians is worth it for the very small possibility that a lesser optic will fail at the exact same time as a SHTF situation. After all, I don’t only buy a Volvo and wear a helmet when I drive to work every day just in case I get into a car accident… for 99.9% of the time, including car accidents :rolleyes: my current car works fine.

Looking forward to a constructive discussion.

Thanks,
Barbara

Well stated Barbara

There is a forum here for Preparation, Preparedness & Prevention so instead of rehashing years of Q&A, I would point you in that direction and ask you to use the search feature if you have questions about SHTFs viability or risk.

To answer your question, generally low. Knowing what I know about our current cyber risks I would say higher than people think. If you care about preparedness (I do, not saying you need to) I believe that preparedness should be based on a scale of probability. If things go bad, they will go really bad very fast. Things that need preparation are food, water, shelter, energy, sanitation/health, and security. I will attempt to have those bases covered to the best of my ability and budget. In my mind, under security, a good reliable rifle, with a reliable light, and an reliable rds is a priority. If these are not your priorities I understand.

3 commenters out of 15 in this thread have said that they had issue with one of these optics, that’s not awesome. Aimpoint’s return rate (to the best of my knowledge) for any problem is .02%. Since they are also issued and used by soldiers and police all over the world I think we can agree that there is a discrepancy in the numbers between Aimpoints in service vs the PA microdots. Good video on the topic of Aimpoint durability:
[video=youtube_share;89HEefl1KI4]http://youtu.be/89HEefl1KI4[/video]

This is correct (I would also highly recommend being proficient with your iron sights) but you would have a delay unless you are very well trained that could cost you your life. I personally think it’s worth the extra money.

IMO, Yes

Buy the best accessories that fit within your budget.

It is the difference of a couple of hundred bucks to go from range toy to combat tested optics and sights.

The difference in a top of the line car vs. budget transportation is a much greater financial impact.

I ordered an Advanced MD from PA, bad out of the box. It killed batteries after a day or two, even when turned off. When I returned it they were out of stock, so I took a refund instead, so I can’t comment on the performance of a good unit. That said, my brother ordered one at the same time, and while his worked fine in terms of the electronics for the few days he had it, you could not zero the rifle. The windage would not adjust far enough left to zero, and mechanical zero had it way over to the right. The farthest it would go still left the dot about half way between the front sight post and the right ‘wing’ of the FSB. We tried this on two different AR’s, tried dismounting and remounting it (on the mount as well as the rifles) a few times, to no avail. The iron sights on both rifles only needed slight adjustment from their mechanical zeros to be right on at 100yds, so I think we can rule out problems with the guns themselves.

PA was great on the returns process, and I will do business with them again. I’ve purchased other items from them before, they’ve always been excellent to deal with. (My brother, too. He has another scope from them that has been just fine for his use.) However, that was enough for me to go ahead and spring for the extra to buy another Aimpoint. I wasn’t planning on using the PA MD on my ‘go-to’ rifles, but I was hoping it would be sturdy enough for a constant use fun/chore gun around the yard.

I have a few high end optics, but the PA micro dot I’ve had on an AR for 5+ years is solid. Holds a zero, hasn’t fogged, great lens coating, mount holds tight… my only gripes (but to be expected at this price point) the glass has a tint to it, and the actual dot looks like a micro cluster of grapes verses a solid crisp dot. I got mine way back when for $50 bucks on a blem run. I’d buy another without hesitation. If I was kicking doors in a for a living, I’d toss on one of the battle proven brands, otherwise PA’s stuff is solid for me.

I’ve got a PA and a TRS-25 on a spare and a .22. The PA is one of the older models, not the Advanced. They work OK.

The PA in the YouTube fog video is an older model that turned out not to be sealed/waterproof if you removed the factory base and mounted it using a Micro mount or most AK mounts. It is NOT the Advanced model; it is in fact years from the Advanced. The fogger is so old I’m surprised the video was uploaded in 2014. I’m not saying the Advanced is ready for prime time, but don’t say the Advanced is crap because a few models ago PA had a totally different red dot that had an issue. None of the PA optics are hardcore go-to gear, and PA tells you that on their website. PA in fact tells you to buy an Aimpoint if that is your need, and sells them.

I also have a T-1 that I finally had to replace the battery on. Guess which rifle I would grab?

  1. What is the lifetime risk that such a “SHTF” emergency would happen to most individuals?

I understand your viewpoint, but I CC every day. Although the odds are not high, quality fire extinguishers are good things to have. SHTF does not mean some arbitrary zombie apocalypse to me. It is simply when law and/or order breaks down and I am there. Whether it be active shooter, robbery, violent protests, natural disasters, etc. I have seen this first hand a few times in my life, enough to where being prepared with quality preps has saved me and my neighbors some great heartache.

  1. Even in such a situation, what is the likelihood these good budget optics would fail (like a Bushnell/Vortex/PA), and is it a significantly greater chance than an Aimpoint/Eotech? Is this proven?

Yes, Aimpoint is very rugged. Even PA says they are the best choice. Eotech…better than some. I have never had a problem with my Aimpoints, I have with my PA, and Eotechs. True, some of my preps are cheaper, but I always have a first line that I know I can count on. As far as CCW, I carry a pistol that I know will work with a great track record, with defensive ammunition I have extensively vetted in my particular pistol. I may own a Kel-tec but the pistol I put in my holster every day is a Shield or Glock 19.

  1. Even if someone broke into my home, the distances are so short that maybe a failed optic may not even matter?

“Maybe” is uncertain. I do have some cheaper red dots, and WML for some of my firearms, but my primary has stuff I know will be reliable. If you do choose to put a budget optic on a primary defensive weapon, at least use it enough to assure it will run as you expect it. (rule out zeroing issues, fogging, malfs that you notice with use)

I’ve got optics from aimpoint, eotech, trijicon, and PA and the only one I’ve had fail was an aimpoint h1 that wouldn’t turn on till the brightness was increased to 8. aimpoint fixed it, but they took 3 months. all my optics have been used pretty evenly, but I just recently got the new PA advanced rds (the one with 50k hours). I’m putting it on my 5.45 AR that I use for classes to see how it will hold up

I am looking at getting an AK probably a 74 it will be a fun gun and a trunk gun. That being said it will be my sight in addition with improved sights and only until I can afford a T-1. I want this sight because I can get everything for the T-1 sight and still have something to practice with.

I don’t own a PA MD-ADS, and have never owned a PA product period, but it seems the MD-ADS has a pretty good size community of owners and feedback is well on the positive side of the fence.

There’s video of these things being dragged behind pick ups, frozen in ice, and being taken scuba diving and they are holding up. Provided all the manufacturing QC is on point, it seems like a good option.

Hi just wondering if anyone has had any more experiences (good or bad) with this optic?

I still love mine, both of them

Here’s a recent review:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJ_stU8lSZ8

I’ve been using the MD-ADS since February, and it’s been great; it’s been left on the whole time, and is always at the same brightness setting. Seems to hold a zero relatively well; last week it was maybe 1/2" off at 25yd, not sure if it’s the mounting or if it’s optics related…