Need a little help, BCM or DD upper?

I have been using the search button for hours now and it has led me to some questions. I wan’t to get me a 16" upper AR with two uses in mind. First it will serve as a truck gun for coyotes and other ranch vermin, second it will serve as a match gun for 2 gun matches (in that order). Thank god I was pointed to this site and away from the RR I was looking at, I now see that I wouldn’t have been happy going in that direction.

I am looking at uppers now and will put togather a lower in a month or two. What I am looking at is the 16" BCM mid length with DD 12’’ rail. Or the DD 16" upper with the same rail. Can some one tell me why the BCM is 200 bucks more? I haven’t read anything bad about eathier of them.

I am tossed up about the battlecomp, I have never been a fan of brakes on anything smaller than the 338-378 but I have heard and read so much good stuff about them that now I want one. Am I in danger of breaking windows in my truck with the battle comp when smoking down dogs from the drivers seat? I only ask cause my 375 HnH cost me a jeep windshield with no brake on it.

My current AR is a LBC super varmint .204, it has been great for what its meant for but is pretty much the opposite of what I want in my next AR. I have alot of time with the M16 A2 as that is what I carried on both of my deployments, I had limited time with the M4. I trust you all will shoot me stright.

I am looking at uppers now and will put togather a lower in a month or two. What I am looking at is the 16" BCM mid length with DD 12’’ rail. Or the DD 16" upper with the same rail. Can some one tell me why the BCM is 200 bucks more? I haven’t read anything bad about eathier of them.

What websites are you looking at? I assume bravocompany for the BCM, but what about the DD?

edit: links to each page would be helpful.

I would throw a link to “The Chart” in right here but it’s currently being revised. I can’t list the differences between the two off the top of my head but I can say that I’m getting a 16" BCM middy and 10" DD Lite rail. I’m sure there are plenty here that can lend some info to help inform you better.
Semper

.375 H&H? That’s one hell of a lot more cartridge than a 5.56mm.

Links would help with the upper thing. $200 sounds about the price for a BCG so check to see if one includes it and one doesnt.

I wasn’t sure if one came with a bcg and one did not, thats what I was hoping some one here would know off the top of their head. Here is the links to the two uppers in question:

http://www.bravocompanyusa.com/BCM-16-BFH-Mid-Length-Upper-Receiver-Daniel-p/bcm-urg-mid-16%20bfh%20ddl12.htm

http://www.smartgunner.com/DanielDefenseLiteURG.aspx

I see that I can pick up bcm BCG for about 160$ wich seems pretty reasonable. If there is a cheaper place to get the BCM upper than shoping at the BCM website I would love to know about it.

As far as the battlecomp goes I want to shoot one before I spend the money on one. I know that for match use it will prop kick ass I just don’t want to deal with the extra noise and blast the rest of the time it it isn’t needed, I personaly don’t “need” a brake on a 5.56 for wayward coyotes.

Well right now DD gives you cold hammer forged about $90 less than BCM. And smartgunner has good prices which would get you to about a $200 savings overall. I bought a DD from them over their end of year sale and other than the understandable waiting period all went well. Nothing to fear from DD or SG. (Except SG will ding your CC immediately even if you have to wait a month for assembly/delivery.)

ETA:
Neither would have a BCG or charging handle included unless you add them to your order. SG sells a DD BCG for $157.

I have one of each and like them both equally.

If you decide to go the DD route, I had a good experience dealing with Kevin @ Johnson Tactical. He does a lot of work w/ DD -

https://www.johnsontactical.com/toc/

FWIW, the DD is going to have a CFH barrel; BCM offers some hammer forged barrels as a ($100) option.

Another source for a “custom built” DD upper is Smartgunner.com

I’ve been eyeing the Smartgunner DD uppers, has anyone ordered one recently, if so how long did it take to get it, I see they are out of stock. With a price like that, its worth waiting.

It all depends on what you order and if it’s in stock or hopelessly backordered. Right now there’s a run on LW midlength barrels and other parts. Seems like even BCGs are hard to get, anywhere - DD or BCM. That’s what happened last time SG had a sale and orders could go out in a week or two - or two months, it just depended on what was in stock. Like you I felt like it was worth waiting and in the end it was.

I got a 16 mid 12"lite rail DD. At 50 yrds 80 rnds in a 1" circle.Was quite happy.

I’m looking at the bare gov’t profile mid length upper. I plan on putting the MOE handguards on it. I’m building on a budget, so the price on the DD CHF barreled upper is the best I’ve seen. I’ll probably order one and wait and see how long it takes. In the meantime, I have other guns to shoot, just no AR’s, this will be my first.

Just about everything DD is running behind in production right now and has been for a few months. But, a good deal of folks are ordering now and waiting things out.

I doubt that it will take longer than a month for DD to get caught back up, but that is an assumption on my part. Sometimes we get lucky and catch a wholesaler who’s DD order arrives before our direct order, which is a pretty happy day :slight_smile: Last I was looking, 14.5 DD barrels stripped we’re still available, so if you could wrap a build around that, it might speed things up. Also BCM’s inventory comes in and out a pretty regular intervals.

–KJ

I am droping an order to SG for the 16" mid govt profile with 12" lite rail. I ain’t in a huge hurry so if it takes a couple weeks thats fine, gives me time to get a lower orderd up. The DD saves me a couple hundred over the BCM which will get me a good trigger. I am looking foward to buying 5.56 rounds instead of .204 since they are about half the price.

Thanks all for the info.

I saved over $250 by ordering from SG over buying locally and I would guess about $200 over other online sources for a DD upper. I waited two months for mine which was worth it to me. Just remember to call when you have questions for SG, he answers the phone more reliably than answering emails in my experience.

eta: And you won’t be disappointed with your DD upper, you can feel the quality and it shoots like a dream :slight_smile:

I ordered my upper from SG the last day of the sale and it took about 2 1/2 months to get here. It was worth the wait though. I just wish they were still producing their stripped lowers.

Sent from my SGH-T959 using Tapatalk

It might take a little longer than two weeks. The DD upper I ordered from SG came directly from DD in about 5 weeks. It was well worth the wait. Didn’t have a hat or decals in the box but saving a couple hundred, no complaints. I went with the 16" LW instead of govt profile and have been real happy with it.

I ordered a DD upper from Smartgunner back in December and after a 3 month wait with no end in sight, I canceled the order.Then, I turned to BCM … ordered the upper on a Monday and it was at my front door on Thursday.

I ordered from SG on 12/26 and still have yet to recieve my order or even have the build start. And be advised they charge your credit card immediately. Not complaining, but the extended wait has definitely sucked the excitement out of the purchase.

If BCM has what you want, in stock I’d highly suggest that option. Its a few bucks more to go that way, but atleast you will have it in a few days. Going the SG custom order route you might just end up waiting as long as I have, or even longer. Seems like quite a few of the major AR makers (BCM, DD, ST) are having problems keeping things in stock.