Mid-length tubular handguard with FSP cutout

The VTAC I was talking about is a one piece design as is the Lite rail.

After a little research it appears that a JP Vtac carbine tube with the tube extension would do the trick for you. https://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?t=78778

Wouldn’t take too much machining to cut a DD MFR for the sight and an access for the FSB pins. I have no clue how much strength you would lose, though.

Machine the DD to do what you want? why not?

Well, basically that’s going to take a lot of work to get on imho. It’s doable, but will take some problem solving.

The Vtac/JP does seem like the best bet though.