Interesting thread, as usual Rob.
Most of my formative years with the weapon system were at a time when full A1 and (somewhat later) A2 buttstocks were the norm. I purchased a Colt Sporter II carbine for my own use in the mid-80s, and in this capacity, I grew accustomed to what we later saw in service trim as the USGI M4 stock. In those days, aftermarket stocks pretty much were limited to variants of the USGI carbine stock (i.e aluminum versus composite), or whatever companies like Choate or Quality Parts Company (later BFI) were trying to peddle.
I stuck with the original Colt stock.
Since I was overseas when the AR aftermarket really took off, I came late to the VLTOR, LMT and Magpul party, and spent no little time experimenting with various designs to determine which met my definition of “best.” The ones that I still have around in some capacity are:
UBR
ACS
SOPMOD
EMOD
MOE
USGI M4
Of these, I admire the UBR for the sheer brilliance of its design, the quality of its construction and the way it balances out an SPR or bench gun. As stated, this isn’t the stock for a carbine that you’re going to be running and gunning with in an all-day class, but I very much like it for more static environments.
I’ve no special attachment to the ACS, though it strikes me as typical Magpul kit. Good design, decent construction. I haven’t yet figured out what it does better than a SOPMOD or VLTOR, but I’m glad Magpul went ahead with it.
The SOPMOD inspires loyalty, pure and simple. While somewhat expensive, it does pretty much everything well, and leaves nothing lacking. Good lockup, no play, great cheekweld. Whether we’re talking about an SBR or a lightweight 16" rifle, the SOPMOD is hard to best.
The EMOD is a more recent acquisition, and one that I’m finding a good substitute for the SOPMOD. I’m not (yet) using the A5 buffer arrangement, but have reason to believe that the EMOD would shine even more with it. Like the UBR, the EMOD is a bit on the long side, but not objectionably so. A keeper with real potential for a 16" gun.
MOE/CTR stocks are already benchmarks, so I don’t need to say much about them. If you’re building an SBR, and not planning to use a SOPMOD stock, this is your solution. I’m not as crazy about them on 16" guns, but that’s largely just because I dislike muzzle-heavy configurations.
The standard M4 stock needs no introduction, though I find it amusing how urgently we feel the need to discard them for just about anything else. You can get a better cheekweld from a SOPMOD or VLTOR, but the factory stock works well, is lightweight, cost-effective, and – lest we forget – has by far the most “go to war” time of any of these contenders. I keep one LE6920 in full OEM trim, and see no need to change it.
AC