So the last part I need for my new 14.5 middy build is a new hand guard. If I wasn’t interested in trying MLOK on this project I would simply buy another BCM KMR Alpha rail, I have three of them and it’s, in my opinion, the best rail system on the market.
However I want to try MLOK.
So I’m looking for a slim seven sided MLOK rail that mimics the KMR as closely as possible. I like the octagonal shape of the KMR and not really interested in trying any round rails. I eliminated Geissele from the running because it has a larger outside diameter than I would like (and is heavier), eliminated the KAC URX 4 because after watching their installation video I wanted to shoot myself in the head, and I eliminated the Noveske NSR because they want you to drill your receiver to put in their anti-rotation pin.
I’ve got this narrowed down to either the SLR ION LITE 13.7 rail (their folks say this will work with suppressor I am going to run) or the MI 12.67 MLOK G3 rail. Neither require that the barrel nut be timed or have any other really weird installation shenanigans (aside from MI idiotic requirement for loctite which I get to in a second).
I’m leaning towards the SLR because I’d prefer the longest rail I can put on this build and I’m really uncomfortable with MI requiring me to use loctite to secure the barrel nut… however, I’m not seeing much information on the SLR ION or any feedback from users who have it, it looks like it doesn’t have any markings or engravings for the pic rail positions which is kind of disappointing considering the high cost of this rail. I also don’t know if any users have had issues with their basic bolt clamp design backing out or moving once installed.
SLR rails are high quality. MI rails are not. MI still recommends their rails to be glued to the barrel nut. Ridiculousness is what that is. Buy something of quality. MI rails are not quality.
Thanks for the feedback. The glue has been the sticking point (ha!) for me on this rail. If the rifle was a total beater I really wouldn’t care but since I’m going to use it in classes I want something that will be reliable.
I might just have to pony up for the SLR or wait for the next time it goes on sale… or get the Noveske and simply not drill my upper for the anti rotation pin.
I recently completed building a 11.5" upper with a SLR MLOK Ion hand guard. I also was curious about MLOK. It has a simple locking system that appears to be very solid. It uses a an anti rotation insert around the gas tube as part of system. Not sure how this will last over time. 300ish rounds at the range yesterday (including a couple of “bumps” to the handguard) testing out the uppers function went well. Hanguard is still tight. Will be curious to see how it does after a couple thousand rds and a training class in a couple of months. One thing I don’t like is the QD hole has no stops in it, so my sling got twisted a couple of times when changing hands. I have an Arisaka MLOK QD I will add, but this has to mount further down the handguard.
NC
Edit: I have a Solo, not an Ion hand guard…locking system appears to be the same though
I’ve got a G2 MI on my coyote rifle and an SLR Solo light on a 12.5 SBR. The MI has been solid thus far but it doesn’t really see hard use popping yotes off the back deck.
As for the SLR, it’s been good but hasn’t seen any hard use yet either. The wedge bolt attachment to the barrel nut is solid but they do rely on the gas tube for anti-rotation WRT the receiver. Not sure if that’s really an issue if your barrel nut is correctly torqued. Quick estimate you’d need somewhere in the neighborhood of 300-600lbs of force directed tangential to the OD of the tube to break the nut free…
The Midwest Industries Hand Guard requires adhesive to mount the hand guard to the barrel nut. Although some have not completed this step in the installation without issue, I do not recommend this hand guard, because that is a failure point.
The SLR Rifleworks handguard is slightly better in that the handguard uses a small wedge with a key that fits into a slot in the barrel nut to prevent it from sliding off. However, unlike the MI hand guard, the SLR hand guard does not have anti-rotation “tabs.” Rather, it uses a small machined “insert” that uses the gas tube to prevent the handguard from rotating.
They aren’t perfectly round, actually are octagonal with flats. Also meets your requirement for mounting on the 45* angle, since that’s how ALG does their m-lok cuts.
Fair enough. At this point though I think I’m going to get a KMR A in 13.5", it’s cheap, I already have a crap-ton of keymod stuff so I’ll finish the rifle and see what they show off at SHOT coming up. It’s kind of funny because several places I shop at have the ALG rail in stock, with a big bold note that you need to buy the wrench separately, but they are out of stock on the proprietary wrench. :jester:
Also looks like 13" ALG V3 weighs about 13 ounces installed, I think the KMR-A is about 9.
It sounds to me like you already made up your mind, rendering this thread pointless.
For the ALG EMR, it originally included the barrel nut wrench, but they’ve since excluded the wrench and discounted the hand guard, so folks that buy multiple EMR’s don’t end up with multiple barrel nut wrenches. Not all handguards include proprietary wrenches, and some of those get quite pricey. Regardless, the ALG EMR is a solid hand guard made by Geissele.
I have the 15" SLR Helix on my lightweight and it’s been great so far. I’ve got just over 1000 rounds thru it with no movement from the rail at all. SLR is one of the higher end companies up there with Battle arms development, VSeven, and 2a Armament so it’s not cheap but their machine work is second to none and fitment was spot on perfect. The Helix weighs in at right at 8.4 oz with the barrel nut so it’s stupid light but extremely strong. I don’t see the lack of anti rotation tabs being an issue at all because of the force that the wedge design puts on the barrel nut to hold the rail in place along with the tab around the gas tube (which will never come into play because the wedge system is strong). Unless you are going to use your rifle as an axe I wouldn’t put to much thought into being worried that the wedge system will fail and cause the rail to shift. Just buy the design you want and move on.
I also use other SLR products (Titanium Adjustable gas block, Titanium mini Comp) and all of their stuff is second to none. As for comparing it to Midwest I would say the only thing they have in common is that they are both a rail that fits on an AR15. Midwest isn’t close to the same league as SLR, although it would probably work just fine for most people.
Thanks for the first hand experience. I’ll hang out and see what they show/announce at SHOT. More than likely I can sell the KMR I am buying for not much less than I’m paying for it, or I can transplant it to a different rifle at some point if I find something new to go with.
No problem. I’m by no means even close to as knolegable as most here, but Ive built a few nice rifles and I did a ton of research before making the decision to go with SLR on this most recent build. Granted I was going for high end lightweight so the 8.4oz with the barrel nut helped in making my decision, but I’ve now used several of their products for a while and couldn’t be happier with the results.
One of my other rifles has a KMR and there isn’t anything bad I can say about it. I would’ve even been happy putting another one on this lightweight gun, but I wanted something a bit more exotic and something that everyone else wasn’t running, all while getting the best quality I could sparing no expense, and while the SLR was $250 in the end it was worth it for the quality of the product I received. I’ve been really getting into the higher end stuff lately and when you get into parts made by these companies like SLR, Battle Arms, and VSeven, you can very clearly see a big jump in the quality of the parts. They are really getting good at delivering products that are both strong enough to handle anything thrown at them, and extremely aesthetically pleasing. The machine work is just insane on some of these companies products.
So take my advice with a grain of salt. As I said I’m not as qualified as some here to give advice, but I’ve personally been very impressed and pleased with the items I’ve been using from these guys and I’m pretty sure anyone else would be as well.