To the OP: not being a smart aleck in saying this, but IMO, the XD’s DID take off. I too am more of a 1911 guy, when you’re talking specifically .45 that is. But XD has its place. If you talk to most shops, they’ll tell you that XD’s have consistently been among their strongest sellers. At two local shops I frequent the most in the Puget Sound area, they tell me that XD sales outstrip Glock sales. Or M&P sales for that matter. I have owned XD’s, and liked them. They were more accurate for me than most plastic pistols, including Glocks, and were equally tough and reliable. And I have seen numerous gun reviews where their accuracy is quite strong, for a plastic pistol. But then, along came the M&P and personally, I liked it better than anything else in the plastic pistol world. If anyone I know is buying today, I’d recommend that they FIRST check the M&P, because I believe most will prefer it to the XD.
So, I think the XD’s are fine guns, but today, there are some better options available. Now, if you’re just wondering why the XD’s didn’t capture more market share in the LE arena, I don’t know. Some people definitely don’t like the grip safety. For me though, the grip safety never caused me a single problem, and it was actually a clever and appealing way to add an extra layer of safety to a pistol, without slowing down draw time. Another theory is that quite simply: Glock and Sig and Beretta were already there. It doesn’t seem like any other brand has made a lot of inroads into American LE yet, although I guess the M&P is starting to (which is a good thing, IMHO).
Overall I think the XD is a fine pistol, and think they will probably keep selling well in the non-LE markets. I too have heard RUMORS about poor reliability, but have never seen these substantiated with any published reports or anything I could actually look at, when I asked for such. If there are such reports, it would be really interesting to read them (does anyone know of any?). But even though I think the XD is good, I also think you can get better options today, the M&P foremost among them. One possible exception to that is, if you want a hi-cap .45 (non-1911), I still think the XD is a great contender for that. I prefer the M&P 45 to the XD, but in fact if I really needed a .45 with more than 10 rounds, I like the XD’s mag setup for a hi-cap .45 better than the M&P’s awkward extended mag, and better than ANY other hi-cap .45 for that matter. However, for my needs, 10+1 rounds of .45 would always be more than enough. In fact, currently I consider myself well armed with 8+1 rounds of .45 in my SA LW Operator!