In your opinion...Why didn;t the XD's take off?

I’m a die hard 1911 man, but I did have a Springfield XD in 9mm that I really like especially after i upgraded the recoil guide and spring.

I was just wondering why you think that the XD never really took off and the M&P did. Of course Glock still owns the plastic gun world, and if you’d like to compare the XD to the Glock as well as the M&P…have at it.

I tried one (at the range, not at the gun store) and did not like the way the pistol handled recoil. Its ergos do not agree with me, particularly when compared to a Glock (second best) and M&P (top).

Around here the XD is very popular. Quite a few people that I shoot with carry XD’s. I had an XD subcompact and it was a nice little gun but I am, like you, a 1911 guy and sold it.

I owned 4 and sold them all…not terribly accurate…

I tried to like them, but Glocks out perform them in every regard, IMHO…

I can’t warm up to the M&P either…

LE contracts. That’s pretty much the long and short of that. That being said the XD is a very popular handgun but lacks the marketing savvy to LE that Glock had and that S&W already had.
BTW - I’ve had two XD9’s, G19, and currently the M&P9. The XD’s come in behind the M&P and the G19 is last. but I started with a High Power so I am biased towards those ergonomics… good ones!:smiley:

I am aware of two of them with identical reliability issues. The channel that the extractor rides in is exposed on the bottom side. Both XDs that I have shot had the same problem with stuff getting under the extractor. This caused the extractor to loose tension on the case and fail to extract. These are the only two Xds that I have experience with. Could it be that they had issues with reliability? It certainly soured my opinion of them.

meh! XD’s have just as good a reliability record as any other handgun, Glock’s included. In fact an even more arduous “torture test” was done on them as the legendary Glock test. It’s like saying that Glock’s will blow up on you and shoot you in the butt.:wink:
http://springfield-armory.primediaoutdoors.com/SPstory11.php

The XD’s a ok pistol for most shooters, it’ll probably never give them a problem. I bought a M&P45 earlier this month and it does feel much better in the hands, but it could benefit from a trigger job… After a couple hundred rounds the trigger on my M&P has smoothed out, and it is useable…But, could be improved…I also picked up a HK USP last night, it has the LEM trigger installed, wow, This trigger set up is better than either the XD or the M&P, To me,it’s about a lightyear ahead of either. I do know, the XD is going to be put up for sale…I don’t feel I need it, or want it anymore… Between the M&P, and the HK how could I go wrong?? I feel the XD’s biggest weakness, is parts availbilty,(yeah I know HK’s not much better, but they are starting a facility to make pistols here in the U.S. so, that little problem may finally be solved) and another annoying problem is it’s possible to lock the pistol up from improper reassembly after cleaning, and can be very difficult to unlock once this happens…This never happend to me but check over at the XD forum and it comes up often…The XD is a good pistol for the price point, but there are better pistols out there for the same money or just a little more.

XDs…

My dislikes:

High bore axis.
Ambi and stiff mag catch.
Not consistently accurate (probably accurate enough for many) but accuracy isn’t consistent from one pistol to another.

I much prefer a M&P or Glock to a XD. However the XDM is a pretty big improvement. Still not quite the ease of a Glock or M&P to customize without spending a fortune but it’s better. Springfield Armory if you’re reading this and want the XD to succeed you need to get the bore axis lower. The ergos of the XD and XDM are great, but simple physics will tell you the lower the bore in your hand the better for control. More control = faster recoil recovery and more rounds on target faster. Rob Leatham (TGO aka The Great One) has probably already told you this.

That very well may be. One of the guns that I am talking about was a range rental so it may not be a fair sample. Still, two guns with two identical issues did turn me off to the platform.

We would need to define the parameters for best comparison, but it’s an uphill battle for the XD.

A colleague who burned through two of them would disagree with a “good as” declaration, as would several students circulating through a training venue. In addition to the various issues, the corrosion on his XD, and some others, was pretty impressive.

Ironically, the XD remains one of the better standard production, mass-produced, single-action autos available today.

I lost track… How many manfucturers instruct customers to hammer the slide off the receiver prior to returning the gun to the factory, given a certain recurring problem?

In the LE tests I’m aware of, they have performed poorly in terms of reliability and durability compared to most of the competing products. This has also been the report I’ve heard from many competitive shooters who’ve tried the platform … though at least one national title was won by an XD45 that I know of. I know someone will say “Mine has been perfect!” but across the board the guns have more problems than many other brands.

The fact that the gun is made in Croatia turns many people, both LE and non-LE, off.

The XD’s ergonomics are poor. They fit some people very well and those people may believe that makes them perfect for everyone, but the truth is quite a few people find them less shootable than many other competing products.

As others have mentioned, they are not well known for accuracy. Again, I am sure someone will tell stories about how his shoots sub-MOA at 600yd but in general the XD’s reputation is for mediocre-at-best accuracy. (why do you think Springfield makes such a big deal about the “match grade” barrels they’re putting in the XDM?)

In central Texas XD’S are popular with civilian consumers. I’ve owned three. My XD Tactical .45 was accurate and reliable. The 9 and 40 were reliable but not terribly accurate in my informal tests. I did not like the long trigger reset. I prefer them over Ruger or Taurus pistols and would feel comfortable keeping one for home defence.

Glocks’s wide-spread parts availability for me is the determining factor for having a couple Glocks. I also favor the HK P2000 and the FNP-45. With the HK I would be SOL if repair issues arose.

Well I have never had any issues with an XD. I have a XDm 9mm that is new to the stables so not a lot of time with it yet but it is very accurate. The XD 45 service has been 100% for me as well. That gun had over 6k rounds through it before I cleaned it and I could hit a 8" plate at 100 yards with wolf ammo 8 out of 10 times. I do not know how much more accurate you could ask for out of a handgun like this. I have not shot any of the standard XD 9 or 40’s or the tactical models. I do shoot with a lot of guys who shot XD’s for IDPA etc and I have not seen or heard of any of them having issues. One of the guys I shoot with is Scott B. who owns pistolgear.com and has a lot of time with the XD.

For the record I own several Glocks in 9mm as well as HK’s in 9mm and 45acp and I do prefer the HK’s especially the HK45 which is my favorite pistol now. I know a lot of people ding many guns about a high bore axis but I have never had any issues shooting any of them well. Maybe it is the Indian more then the arrow.

Here is a pic from this wed with my new XDm 9mm, this group is the first 19 rounds out of the gun at 25 feet. I did not clean it, just took it right out of the box and shot it. Ammo was wolf military classic 115 grain fmj. The group to the left was with my G17 with the same ammo and distance. The XDm shot better then my Glock which I have shot a lot with. I will admit I shot the Glock a bit faster but it never has put up groups like the XDm for me, I can also shoot my HK’s as well as the XDm groups. There are just as many who hate Glocks for their grip and other reasons. This is why we have a lot of choices. I would not say the XD has not taken off, I see a lot of them. Yes there are more Glock’s carried by cops etc but it is a lot of money to switch out guns and lets face it the XD in 40 was a bit of a turd with only a 12 round high cap mag. The XDm with 16 rounds I bet changes that.

Dave

Here is a pic from this wed with my new XDm 9mm, this group is the first 19 rounds out of the gun at 25 feet

No offense, but 25 feet is hardly a test of accuracy for any piece…

Well like I said I shot an XD 45 at 100 yards using wolf ammo and hit 8" steel plates with out a problem. Yes 25 feet is not a long way but this is not a gun for bullseye shooting but for defensive use. Don’t they say the average shooting is with in 10 feet? Well this is over twice as far and I would see no reason why this gun would shoot any different at 25 yards for that matter let alone with better quality ammo then wolf. Wolf has never been known to be the best and most accurate ammo out there.

what’s .45 bullet drop like at 100 yards from a handgun?

To the OP: not being a smart aleck in saying this, but IMO, the XD’s DID take off. I too am more of a 1911 guy, when you’re talking specifically .45 that is. But XD has its place. If you talk to most shops, they’ll tell you that XD’s have consistently been among their strongest sellers. At two local shops I frequent the most in the Puget Sound area, they tell me that XD sales outstrip Glock sales. Or M&P sales for that matter. I have owned XD’s, and liked them. They were more accurate for me than most plastic pistols, including Glocks, and were equally tough and reliable. And I have seen numerous gun reviews where their accuracy is quite strong, for a plastic pistol. But then, along came the M&P and personally, I liked it better than anything else in the plastic pistol world. If anyone I know is buying today, I’d recommend that they FIRST check the M&P, because I believe most will prefer it to the XD.

So, I think the XD’s are fine guns, but today, there are some better options available. Now, if you’re just wondering why the XD’s didn’t capture more market share in the LE arena, I don’t know. Some people definitely don’t like the grip safety. For me though, the grip safety never caused me a single problem, and it was actually a clever and appealing way to add an extra layer of safety to a pistol, without slowing down draw time. Another theory is that quite simply: Glock and Sig and Beretta were already there. It doesn’t seem like any other brand has made a lot of inroads into American LE yet, although I guess the M&P is starting to (which is a good thing, IMHO).

Overall I think the XD is a fine pistol, and think they will probably keep selling well in the non-LE markets. I too have heard RUMORS about poor reliability, but have never seen these substantiated with any published reports or anything I could actually look at, when I asked for such. If there are such reports, it would be really interesting to read them (does anyone know of any?). But even though I think the XD is good, I also think you can get better options today, the M&P foremost among them. One possible exception to that is, if you want a hi-cap .45 (non-1911), I still think the XD is a great contender for that. I prefer the M&P 45 to the XD, but in fact if I really needed a .45 with more than 10 rounds, I like the XD’s mag setup for a hi-cap .45 better than the M&P’s awkward extended mag, and better than ANY other hi-cap .45 for that matter. However, for my needs, 10+1 rounds of .45 would always be more than enough. In fact, currently I consider myself well armed with 8+1 rounds of .45 in my SA LW Operator!

A standard 230gr FMJ with 830 fps velocity drops something like 28" @ 100. Push up your velocity a bit, as with the DoubleTap FMJ load that has 1010 fps velocity at the muzzle, and your drop @ 100 is reduced to 18".

I’ve had several XDs, in 9mm and .45ACP. No issues from any of them. I really do like them, but I do shoot Glocks quite a bit better. I would have no issue being handed one and depending on it.