How low is too low for a front sight post? Is it normal for it to be recessed a few clicks down into the FSB to zero?
As long as it’s not so low as to cause a zero to never occur, and it doesn’t look like this with the “F” Post controversy:

Should be all gravy. If you have a elevation adjustable rear, you can balance them out, too. (Granted, this is a controversy all in it’s own too.)
Either way, others may have more specific advice, I say if it works, and you can do your hold overs and trajectory predicitions still, that’s the important part.
What distance is the rifle zeroed for?
As herumew said, if it is zeroed and not falling out I wouldn’t be overly concerned.
I should also include:
Every rifle is different.
I can’t remember the exact ratio, but 1/16 of an inch off at the barrel correlates to inches down range.
That being said: one rifle may need their front post lower, or higher. Generally, you want to not have to change it at all, but the message here is:
Don’t worry to much about a few clicks either which way. When you’re so buried you have troubles, or so far out of the front post, you lose your sight guide bars, that’s where it’s an issue. ![]()
Zeroed at 50 yds.
Hell yeah, that’s very normal it may vary in one direction and other depending on ammo, barrel, and face of upper. Most 16" carbine length fsb barrel I have experince with zero like that and it change few clicks between hot- weak ammo plus weight difference plus if you zero almost 6 o clock or right on tip of post.
The notched skirt of post being being recessed on flat of the hole is more normal than one that’s even or above. It can go in much more deep too, deeper if you alternate the post by shortening the threaded section, shortening spring+detent.
What rear sight are you using? Ensure it’s on right setting. I have seen folks with front post being unusual deep or sitting too high because rear sight elevation was set wrong fir the zero. Or some with very far zero.
Ammo can be a factor too. Let us not forget that. Have one rifle that is zeroed at 100 meters. With one load it is POA/POI dead on and tight. With another loading, it is about six inches left and four inches high. Groups aren’t great either, but still. Might be ammo related.
The rear sight is a DD A1.5 so no elevation adjustment.
:big_boss: What Kain said too!
It’s a very good point, and as you’ve mentioned, ammo can make a world of difference.
Makes sense. In order to get that bullet up to POA in just 50 yards, I’d expect to bury the sight post at least a few click into the FSB. When I use a 50 yard target to check/confirm zero, I try to get the POI about 3/4" low so it’s on at 100 yards. I only do this when my target is too hard to see (cluttered) at 100.
I am no ammunition expert but I didn’t just fall off of the turnip truck either. I can understand a slight diff between different loads at 100 but 6 left and 4 high seems extreme! When sighting in irons or glass I shoot 5+ rounds before adjusting the group’s center to the POA. I laugh at the clog shooters shooting one shot and adjusting the sights. After chasing their ass for 10-15 rounds they decide in the general vicinity of where they are aiming is close enough.
Barrel didn’t like the ammo. Trust me I didn’t know if I just went to hell or what. First couple 5 shot groups, about inch total, pretty much spot on. All 55gr HPBT. Then grabbed some new 75gr HPBT. Both loads were Hornady by the way. Anyway, I shoot another group, and the center was about six inches left and four inches high. It was also a good bit larger than the 55gr stuff by about 3 times. Grab another 5 rounds of the 55gr stuff, and I am back to POA/POI. For what it is worth the rifle was a RRA 20inch heavy barrel allegedly 1/8 twist. Topped with a 3-9X Bushnell. The short was the rifle does not like that Hornady 75gr loading at all. So while it was extreme, that was the only change and going back to the previous load resulted in no issues.
Looks good to me
As long as you are getting a good sight picture and it holds zero it’s perfectly fine.