Are you also considering IonBond or FailZero EXO coatings? I know FZ hasnt been taking orders for custom EXO coatings for a while, but Im pretty sure you can still get one of their BCGs. And they’re supposed to start taking orders again soon.
I hate to derail a thread… but are you absolutely hell-bent on using one of those coatings?
I ask because I do not think any of them offer any quantifiable advantage to the end-user.
I have used Ion Bond, Teflon-Nickel, Nickel-Boron (Exo) and NP3 on many different gun parts (including AR BCGs). While they certainly look nice and (sometimes) wipe off easy, they don’t offer me a quantifiable upgrade for the amount of money invested.
I still have to use acquire and use lube, clean BCG parts and generally maintain my rifle just like I did before. The BCG and affected parts still wear.
In fact, I found many of the above coatings to be inferior to the 'ol tried and true parkerizing. I’ve had several of the above coatings chip, peel or—in the case of a moderately abused M60 bolt—flake off. That never happens with park.
I like new technology and all, but I’m not sold on the new push to “super coatings” fad just yet. There are too many panaceas being peddled right now and I think we should let the dust settle before wasting more money on miracle cures.
Manganese phosphate has been kicking ass on AR BCGs since the 1960s.
The first M16s I was issued were HC. They dated from the 1960s. They shat all over parkerizing, which the Army switched to for largely cosmetic reasons. I carried some that were 20+ years old with no signs of flaking. A most durable “fad.”
Park doesn’t flake off, but it does wear off very rapidly. It also causes hydrogen embrittlement, which is relevant to small, treated metal parts such as bolt lugs and extractors.
I have used HC successfully in my ARs for 20 years. I took my own HC BCG downrange and swapped out for the issue garbage.
So, yes, I’m sure.
I will gladly spend another $100 on a critical internal component before wasting money on real fads, such as 6 angles of rail gewgaw, flipping things or 19 point slings that do nothing to improve the mechanical function of the weapon.
Pax: Failzero’s one contender, though it looks like Spike’s offers the same finish cheaper, with less hype, and lists the metallurgy of their BCG, which causes me to put them a little higher on the list.
I’m sold on electroless nickel (NiB) as a little more durable than chrome for a little more money, and several reliable shops can do it. TiN I’m of mixed feelings about. It’s never made a difference on the durability of twist drills for me, but that’s a different application. Melonite is proven, but a bitch to apply.
I’m curious what you found “better” about the hard chrome BCGs over the manganese phosphated ones. When you say they “shat” on them, can you quantify why? What makes them “issue garbage” so bad that you had to replace them? (This is the first I’m hearing someone actually complaining about manganese phosphate BCGs strictly related to the finish itself.; I’m actually interested.)
Good luck in your search for info. Just be careful as there is a lot of snake oil out there with the new coatings.
I can always stick with the hard chrome I have. There have been no issues. But if something better is cost effective, I’ll upgrade as I go. Coal Creek can do me electroless nickel on an existing BCG.
I’m interested in different coating technologies and I’ve been wanting to do some research on each, but I just haven’t gotten started. It’s a lot of information to go through and it’s hard to find independent objective reviews.
I think a good place to start would be a spreadsheet similar to “The Chart”. List all the characteristics of each process. Things like whether it’s electroplating or electroless, whether heat treating is required and what temp, hardness, lubricity (is that the word?), thickness of coating, durability, etc. I don’t know if some of those, like lubricity, are quantifiable.
I would tend to favor an electroless process because it should produce a more even thickness than electroplating. In electroplating, because of the interaction between the anode and cathode, you get different thicknesses on areas like edges or where there is no direct path between the anode and cathode. Though, the difference may be so minuscule that it doesn’t matter. We’re talking microns here.
So far, from my limited research, I like Nickel Boron best. But I haven’t looked into DLC, TiN, or melonite.
FZ touts their NiB because they are only one of 3 shops in the world that can do “level 5” NiB coating - all others are the inferior level 3 or lower. There’s lots of info all over the place on this. What they do isn’t readily available for customer owned parts anywhere at the moment. Do some research.
I’ve got Spikes NiB BCGs in every 556 AR I own. Less friction, easier to clean - that was worth the cost to me. The things slide in my uppers like there’s a coating of butter in there - pretty crazy. The upper wears less as a result - that’s a fact I’ve verified on various new builds. I still use some lube, but it’s nice knowing if I didn’t, the rifle would still function.
But as always, with many, this may be an unjustified luxury for some folks who will resort to calling them “fads.”
Just remember, in a hot, dirty, metal on metal movement situation, like the upper rec, less friction is a good thing for many reasons.
I’m always amazed at people who’ll hang a grand of rails and gadgets on the outside but don’t want to “Waste money” on internals without which the weapon is a very pretty ornament.
[0008]There are three types of alkaline electroless nickel boron coatings. The Type-1 is taught in U.S. Pat. No. 3,674,447 to Bellis filed Jul. 4, 1972, which is incorporated by reference. Metal elements such as thallium and lead are used to stabilize the electroless plating. These metal elements form a poly alloy with the nickel boron coating. A typical Type-1 electroless coating has about 1-3% thallium, 2-4% boron and 97-92% nickel by weight.
[0009]The Type-2 is taught in U.S. Pat. No. 6,066,406 to McComas which is incorporated by reference. A typical Type-2 electroless coating has 1-6% boron, 99-94% nickel,
[0010]The Type-3 is taught in U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/903,687 filed Aug. 2, 2004 entitled Electroless Coating with Nanometer Particles to Ed McComas. A typical Type-3 electroless coating has Nickel Boron plus nanometer DLC particles. 1-6% boron, 99-94% nickel plus co-deposition of solid DSLC particles.
I have about 1200 rds through my spike’s Exo BCG. It is, indeed, coated by FailZero. I verified this by calling Fail Zero and they stated that they coat Spike’s NiB BCG with their EXO coating. I spoke with Felipe Jose at FZ, FTR (in case this turns into a shitstorm and bs starts flying).
I’m VERY happy with mine. I am running an 8.3oz custom buffer (carbine stock) and Tubbs CS flatwire spring with mine. It’s the smoothest shooting setup to date on my BCM 14.5" middy. The cleanup is easy and the added lubricity inside the upper cannot be a bad thing. I’ll buy another…and it was worth every penny to upgrade it. I like that, after shooting 1100 rds without cleaning (only lube added), the BCG doesn’t slow down despite copious amounts of fouling building up.
I’m not gonna get into a this-vs-that debate in the ‘coating wars’. Taking a quality Mil Spec BCG and having it coated with a treatment that greatly reduces friction seems like a win-win for me.
The coating is so slick, all lube (I use Slip 2k EWL) drips right off after about a week of storage. I mean bone dry. With lube, the BCG glides inside the upper like greased marbles on a buttered glass floor.
Chrome plating is electro-plating. Though I do wonder how this is accomplished. Is the anode placed inside the barrel? I think it would have to be, but I’d like to see how that is done.
The buffer is for my duty carbine. It was custom fabricated by Slash at Heavy Buffers dot net.
I’m sure you could find somebody to coat a quality Barrel extension. It seems that an Ionbond barrel extension would play nice with a FZ BCG. Even HC would be an improvement. However, I don’t really see the BE as a huge contributor to smoothness. My BCM has a normal mil spec BE and it works great for me (and for me most).