It seems every single day someone posts that they have a basic, rack grade AR that shoots 1 MOA. I’ve always wondered how someone can claim their rifle is a 1 MOA gun when they’ve never taken it beyond 100 yards. I know for a fact those 6920s with FGMM aren’t shooting 2.9" ES’s at 300 yards so what gives?
Is a rifle that shot one five ground group one time at 100 yards in <1" really a “1 MOA” rifle? Surely in a literal sense, yes. But for the AR platform in .223 how many rounds, and at what distance, does one really need to shoot to be “sub MOA” - not according to bubba, but according to experts/pros and using that metric are there any real sub MOA chrome lined carbines?
If an MOA rifle at 100 will not shoot MOA at 300 is it still an MOA rifle?
While I have never been one to make these types of claims, or even pay to much attention to them on my end in my applications, I always wonder how many are being deceitful about these types of stats.
Grain of salt is always good with the online folk.
A true 1 MOA rifle would be capable of consistently placing the center every round fired in a 1" group at 100 yards, for multiple groups, with the same POA for all groups, with the only changes to POI being made by environmental factors.
Like I have said before: there aren’t too many of those rifles in the world.
Above cut from F2S’ first post in his “Let’s talk accuracy” thread stickied in the tech forum. Not my words.
A rifle that can consistently shoot 1 MOA in most environmental conditions must be in the hands of one capable marksman; the rifle has absolutely nothing to do with it.
How many 6920’s have you tested at 300 yards? I seem to remember Molon had some chrome-lined Colts that shot quite well in documented and fairly rigorous testing.
I don’t think there is a commonly shared definition of “1 moa rifle”. For starters, do you mean the mean radius of a group or the extreme spread? Groups of 5, 10, 30, or averaging 5 groups of 5 shots each?
How many ammo types will you try? Are customized handloads OK? What if they require seating the bullets unreasonably long and can only be made in tiny batches before accuracy suffers? What if they have to be single loaded in a sled? Would you adjust case neck size like a benchrest shooter would?
How is shooter skill factored in? Are we using a ransom rest, bench rest, bipod, what? Is a better than GI trigger allowed? Are we going to wait 5 minutes between shots for the barrel to cool to ambient? Do the shooting in a tunnel or enclosure so wind is no factor at all?
I like F2S’s definition cited above, but some of the uncertainties I list have to be factored in as well.
I would bet that you can get some examples of the 6920 upper to shoot 1 MOA mean radius at 300 yards, even in decent group sizes, if you play with every possible accuracy trick. But that doesn’t mean much for practical accuracy.
I think a lot of it is lack of sophistication or failing to think things through, not intentional lying.
You’re thinking too much. Any ammo is allowed, any trigger, any shooter. This is less about those factors and more about the gun.
As far as I know, Molon has never tested anything beyond 100 yards. I have, in fact, tested a 6920 to 300 and beyond and never saw anything less than 2 MOA (I didn’t pull that number out of a hat). Additionally, I have tested a free floated 12.5" BCM out to 565 and saw ~20" ES’s. These results are in threads made by me and are all searchable on M4C.
Something interesting that maybe did not come across in my OP is that it seems 100 yards is the benchmark for 1 MOA.
Is it only at 100 yards? What about rifles that can shoot 1 MOA at 100 but can’t at 400? Are they “1 MOA rifles”? After all, 1 MOA is an angular measurement not dependent upon distance.
Damn near any weekend in the United States there is either a CMP or NRA Highpower Rifle match fired using military style service rifles or equivalents (the M1, M14, M16, and M4).
Anyone in good legal standing can shoot the matches.
Any service rifle (or clone), this year any sight (up to 4-power magnification), any safe trigger (capable of picking up a 4 pound weight) and any safe ammunition.
An expert score is 89 through 93.99% fired on standard military/NRA bullseye targets at 200, 300, and 600 yards (or at shorter ranges using scaled targets – you could shoot a match entirely at 100 yards!) from standing, sitting, and prone. The X-ring and 10-ring serving as your “Bullseye” are nominally 2-MOA across – fricking HUGE, right?!
While you can shoot it with a GI chrome-lined barrel (and do well), most of the winners and champions will opt for a match barrel.
In a word, once bullets start straying away from an expected MOA to MOA-and-a-half mean radius grouping from aiming point (due to wind, hold, pressure spread, eyesight, etc.) frustration builds until you find a solution to fix it. Typically a 68-to-77 grain bullet will maintain expectations for a trained junior (14-to-20 year old) marksman to 300 yards on a round bullseye (500 if on a big E-type silhouette) while most will use a 75 A-MAX or 80-grain HPBT at 600.
Larry Vickers has a video of him at Gunsite shooting long distances. His spotter, Walt Wilkinson is a long distance instructor at Gunsite and when he was asked about MOA basically said the a rifle is a MOA rifle or it’s not. He said there was no such thing as sub MOA. He also said that a MOA rifle you shoot under and inch at 100 yards and the further you go the more your groups would open up and still be considered MOA accuracy ( 2" @ 200 and so on). LAV said the a fifteen inch group @1500 is MOA and Walt agreed and said that’s an excellent group for that range. I realize that they were using bolt guns in this video, I only included it because of the explanation of what MOA means.
Can you explain what would cause a rifle to shoot 1 MOA at 100y and not hold 1 MOA at 400y?
If the answer is wind/air mass, then is that the rifles fault? If you can control the variables the 1 MOA rifle should hold 1 MOA until something upsets the bullet, like maybe going transonic.
Thanks for the link, but I started that thread so I’m well aware of it.
There are lots of reasons that can cause a rifle to shoot MOA up close and not MOA further out that are entirely a result of the rifle without regard to environmental factors. One is the way button rifles barrels are constructed and can increase the range of velocity SDs causing excessive vertical dispersion at 400 yards that does not show up at close ranges.
That, however, is outside the scope of this thread. How many rack grade ARs are really MOA rifles? Reading the forum you’d think ARs are more often than not MOA shooters but when I try to hit 2/3 MOA targets at 600 yards people call me crazy.
If a 6920 is an MOA shooter at 100 then it should be a sure thing to get a 6" gong at 600 if wind is not a factor, right? Then why aren’t more people doing it?
The more distance, the more variables, and the more the shooter comes into play.
I don’t think there are many rifles that are capable (standard guns like you define). The colt socom barrels look to be very close though.
I have shot a sub 1" 5 shot group at 100 with my rifle, but haven’t gotten around to trying to repeat it, nor do I expect it to do it on demand. I think people use 3 shot groups too much as well.
Sinister, I hear what you’re saying and I’m with you. I rarely shoot under 300 yards and you can always catch my buddies and I shooting out 10.5/11.5 SBRs at 600 yards. People rarely shoot beyond 100 yards and that’s irritating because those same guys will be the first ones to tell you that SBR’s “don’t shoot that far” :rolleyes: It’s also part of the reason I made this thread. Sure, that PSA frankenbuild may shoot “3/4 MOA” 3 shot groups at 100 yards but when you’re putting 30 rounds on target at 500 don’t expect a 3.75" group - don’t even expect a 10" group.
To directly answer your question, now that you know where I’m coming from, my experience shows that a rack grade M4 would be very unlikely to sling 3" ES’s at 300 yards even with match grade handloaded ammo. My 20" Krieger with all the bells and whistles barely holds 2" groups at 300 yards with handloaded TMKs and I’m a decent shooter with some skills honed while wearing an eagle standing on top of a globe with a navy symbol behind it. However, I’m guessing because you asked the question you have a different answer
Variable wind aside, what would make a rifle capable of holding 1 inch groups at 100 yards not be capable of holding 3 inch groups at 300 yards? (Same ammunition, same shooter, etc.)
Since most people don’t know how to calculate mean radius, or don’t feel like doing that much math for a thirty round group, whenever someone mentions a 1 MOA rifle, unless otherwise noted, the image of a the extreme spread of the best three round group he shot that session, and anything else shot that day was “operator error”.
There is no single definition of a 1 minute of angle rifle. There is only this rifle shot within a minute of angle under these conditions and whether or not that rifle can consistently do so.
Rifles that can deliver 3 or 5 shot groups that are 1 MOA or less at 100 yards are 1 MOA rifles under these conditions. If the same rifles cannot deliver 10 shot groups at 100 yards then they are not MOA rifles under different conditions. But it does not change the fact they are MOA rifles when firing 3 or 5 shot groups.
Rifles can deliver groups in which the groups vary by range. Some rifle/ammo combinations deliver groups in which measure larger in MOA at 100 yard than they do at 300 because the bullets haven’t had a chance to settle in, or “go to sleep” at 100 yards. Some rifle/ammo combinations will stabilize the bullet out to maybe 300 yards so they’ll go to sleep sooner, but will not maintain enough RPM to keep them stable past that.
The real answer to “Is the AR an MOA rifle?” is “It depends under what conditions it must deliver 1 MOA precision and accuracy”
I don’t get to long range shoot much these days. But I had an M4, M16A2, and a DRMO M14 and different intervals over the years.
The M4 had a good mechanical zero at 100. I booked it at 2ish MOA. Sometimes better, sometimes not. It could take a chest on a steel target at 300 easy which is way more than one would need for popo work.
The M16A2(and briefly A1) were odd because they got 2.5 to 3 MOA at 100 but did better at 300. Iron Sights only.
I’m assuming ammo and barrel twist played a part.
Then there was the M14. I used mainly 147 gr ball and irons. It got 3 MOA, but a GOOD 3MOA. That sumbitch made a satisfying ‘DING’ at the 300 steel.
If I know my hold at 300, 100, and 25m; that’s all I’m really concerned with.