Will soft body armor stop an arrow?

Aramid based ballistic armor is designed to stop bullets, not cutting or stabbing attacks. Still, bullet resistant vests are pretty tough. What do you think? Can a Level IIA vest stop an arrow fired from a 55 lb compound bow? Don’t cheat. Make your prediction before you watch the test.

Link for phones

[video=youtube_share;4itldinl-s0]http://youtu.be/4itldinl-s0[/video]

We fired a 55lb compound bow with a 290 gr carbon fiber arrow tipped with four different arrow heads (listed below) at Level IIA body armor. The body armor is backed by clay, to simulate a body and approximate back face deformation.

4 blade 150 gr broad head
Muzzy 3 blade 100 gr broad head
90 & 100 gr field points

What was the backing material? It looked like clay or something and like it was solid enough to stop the arrows on its own, but I could be wrong.

The manufacturer has to use cutting instruments during production, so one would think any blade type projectile would cut Kevlar.

Prediction:
No, lower level vests are not stab resistant enough to stop a double edge weapon, much less one traveling at 300+ fps.

ETA: Do you hear banjos…?

I can’t see the video at work. But I’m guessing it’ll do a fair job… I’d rather have the vest than not.

The vest is supposed to distribute and disburse the energy behind the arrow.

Only a vest with stab protection might stop an arrow… or a rifle plate.

It all depends. A field point or less efficient broadhead design may very well get stopped. Those points are going to try and push the material out of the way, where the layered woven Kevlar excels in dissipating the energy.

I remember a test years ago on an elk hide where a field point and “pointed” broadhead couldn’t be pushed through, while a “cutting tip” broadhead went through like a knife through butter.

One of those should go through with ease out of a 55# bow.

BTW, I didn’t have time to watch the video. Was I close? :confused:

There’s no fukkin way. I’m not watching the video. But I’d bet that ONLY a steel armor plate will stop an arrow.

It’s clay. Very soft. You could push your fingers right through it.

How much would you bet? :wink:

I do not believe it will stop a broadhead doing 350fps. No idea what speed their arrows are going though.

I’ll chronograph the bow tomorrow.

So did it stop it? Not watching the 6+ minute video.

Someone could do well by producing YouTube videos that last 90 seconds or less and are all “meat and potatoes.” You already told me what the video is about in text, no need to talk about what you are going to do/did do at the beginning and end of the video…

Interesting topic though

Dude, it’s six and a half minutes. Several types of arrowhead are tested. If you are interested, watch the video. If not, no big deal. Alternatively, you could set up your own tests and cut them to whatever length you wish. That said, I have a 100% money back guarantee so watch your mailbox in about a week for a refund check.

I didn’t know this was your personal content, but if you are going to do this sort of thing, and open it up for discussion on an open forum, I’d suggest going to the milsurp store and buying some thicker skin, ASAP.

Lol. He didn’t hurt my feelings, it’s just always funny to me when people complain that their own attention deficit issues prevent then from accessing information they claim to want. It’s also funny when people complain about free stuff.

It’s always funny to me that guys post up free content and then complain when people complain. It’s what people do…

Lol. So, you’re saying that people discuss stuff on a discussion forum.

I, for one, appreciate all the time & effort Andrew puts into his tests and posting them here. He has only made this forum better and could easily choose to post elsewhere. It’s disappointing to see members, especially staff members, ride his ass about anything.

Keep up the good work Andrew.

I, for one, appreciate all the time and effort staff and moderators and owners put towards this site, so that Andrew has a place to use to post up his content. That someone would ride any staff or moderators ass about some levity posted in an open thread, is disappointing.

For the record, the “shame the staff” schtick doesn’t work too well with me. I cut a fair deal, and call them like I see them.