In my youth the magnum choices were primarily .357 or .44 and around 77/78 the 41 magnum became much more popular for a brief moment.
And at about that time I joined the Military and lost track of what kind of sidelined what I thought was actually a better caliber than the .44.
Can someone give me a brief history lesson and explain this to me?
Not sure how you knew i recently lost a bid on a .41 S&W 57…
But anyway, i think it came down to the guns being big / heavy and the duty ammo that came out with them was too hot for most to shoot well.
The original idea IIRC was a 200 gr bullet at 1000 fps. Remington instead made a 210 gr @1300 fps from a 4 in barrel, IIRC. And also a milder practice load, which many used for carry.
That’s kind of funny because it’s claiming to be 25% less recoil than the .44.
I was looking at cross sectional denisty tests showing the .41’s performance and was very impressed, more so than the .44.
41 is a prime number and Americans like their calibers to be divisible in different ways. Hence, 41 is an oddity.
Seriously though, the ability to shoot .44 Special as a subcaliber out of the .44 Mag might have had a lot to do with it. Ron mentioned a lighter .41 made for practice, but how common was it? This was back before the ease of ordering ammo online, and a lot of folks probably still picked up pistol ammo at retail stores. I doubt your local Gibsons or K-Mart was keeping .41 on the shelf due to low demand.
As of now, yes, it is probobly limited to a few choices and handloading.
I’m guessing this was buried under the rubble of wonber-nines coming out at about the same time.
Looking at the numbers and the Gel tests I’m thinking I would choose this over nearly everything else based on perfromance alone.
Now I need to find one to shoot.
Taurus (bleh) made a 5 shot .41 mag on a medium frame for a short while. I’d buy one today if it was a quality gun. (Made by another company) Something about 37 ounces.
Actually, some Google-Fu suggests the S & W Model 58 was introduced in 1964 and discontinued in 1977. You mentioned an increase in interest around 77-78. Maybe that was due to clearance sales?
Another reason for the decline might have been the adoption of the .41 by the San Francisco Police. This would naturally have branded the caliber as a “gay” cartridge, and lessened interest among us more manly types.
I read somewhere that Remington kind of screwed up and made the 210 grain jacketed bullet come out at too high of velocity resulting high recoil. Too much for your average law-enforcement officer to handle. If it would’ve come out at a lower velocity, probably would’ve had higher success. Of course, then again, all revolvers were on the Cliff of retirement with semi automatic pistols, just entering the market.
That’s a big part of it. There were originally two loads, a hot magnum for the M57 for hunting and a reduced power load for the M58 ’intended for LE/SD.
Steve Shields of High Desert Cartridge Company has been a proponent and driving force to resurrect the 41 magnum and special cartridges.
He has been making a name for himself among some people in the know. He and his company are the subject of.a recent article in the American Rifleman September issue I believe.
I had a partner when I worked in the street crime unit that carried a model 58 and some sort of 9mm as his second gun, but I can’t remember what it was.
I bought a model 57 to carry hiking in bear country and to be honest wished I had bought a 58. I think if I had bought a 58 it would have gone into my dads safe along with the Davis company Cougar I had built.
So poor ammo availabilty killed it during the last legs of a Revolver being a “Law Enforcement Gun” is what I understand
I understand Bill Jordan wanted in in an L frame.
Well as cool as that may be getting in to a Model 58 and buying reloading components for it may be out of a retiree’s economic Ball Park.
Bill Jordan (and Elmer Keith?) I believe invented the round as a better LEO round. Bill intended it to be in a K frame like the Model 19. S&W thought it needed to be in an N-Frame and built it that way. It was too heavy. Bill Jordan was 6’ 6” and recoil was not something that affected him much I think. The cartridge was really wonderful. I was issued a 41 mag Black Hawk once (Zimbabwe). I loved the round for handgun hunting. I would love to have seen one in a L-Frame.