But most of the precision AR builders use 1/7 for their 18-20 inch barrels. WHY the difference in twist philosophies? wouldn’t the users for the LTR run the heavier bullets just like the precision AR users?
From my own experience with bolt guns chambered in the .223 Rem I mainly used them for varmint hunting. To be more specific for the hunting of Furbearing creatures. To keep the hides in as pristine shape as possible it is desirable to use a lighter weight bullet that will enter the animal, expand and transfer all its energy inside the body cavity and not leave a large exit wound which would then have to be either sewn up or ruin the value of the hide. Lighter weight bullets in slower twist rate barrels.
On the other end of varminting…such as hunting Prarie dogs, crows or other nuisance animals that aren’t eatable or valuable as such. The lighter weight bullets with subsequent light weight jackets usually explode on impact with the animal or in the case of a miss will hopefully impact the ground and blow apart. That way we minimize the chance of a bullet richocheting and whizzing across the landscape in a dangerous manner.
I proved this theory one time to a farmer by shooting a 50gr Berger MEF bullet into a 16 ounce Pepsi bottle filled with water and resting against a board as a backstop. The bullet disintegrated as I hoped it would and didn’t pass through the bottle of water leaving the board untouched. I had been trying to get permission to hunt Coyotes on this mans land for almost two years, when he seen this for himself he realized that I wasn’t going to accidentally shoot one of his cows and he happily allowed me to hunt his 1600 acre pasture from that day on.
Light weight varmint bullet that are driven to max velocities in a faster twist weight barrel can blow up in mid air due to centrifical forces. I have had this happen with a .22-250 Ackley Improved (Bbl twist rate of 1:10) I once owned. This used to be a common issue with the .220 Swift. Keep in mind the velocities here were in excess of 3800 Fps.
sounds about right for varmints, but the rifle is marketed for LE use. and it’s in their LE catalog. wouldn’t they most likely be running something like the Hornady TAPS or similar?
I have an LTR and it’s a sub-MOA rifle with 75gr TAP and my 69gr handloads. I measured the twist and it’s actually closer to 1:8.5 than 1:9, so it handles the heavier bullets (up to 75gr) quite well. 77gr and 80gr loads are a different story, but you won’t find many LE agencies using anything heavier than 75gr ammo.
the above posts have sound reasoning, but do not take into account the pragmatic. Realistically the reasons for a 1/9 twist rate are:
Go into any “gun store” or big box store that carries ammo, look on the shelf (OK, OK, they are empty but pretend it is a year ago.) look at the 223 ammo on the shelf. Look at the bullet weight. This is what 99% of all shooters do, and subsequently so do the buyers of any particular rifle when they need some ammo. Therefore any gun sold to these folks must be able to handle the lighter weight bullets that proliferate our market. Otherwise you are asking for a nightmare customer service/ satisfaction problem.
I do know that you and I think any gun sold for this purpose should shoot 69-80gr SMK’s and not worry about much else, but we do not sell rifles, or buy this particular one.
^ok, i know what it’ll shoot, and i know what is available at the retail level. the 1/7 vs. 1/9 argument is pretty old.
I’m asking why there are two different philosophies for barrel construction for two different types of weapons, with very similar accuracy expectations.
First of all, the 1:7" twist rate was adopted to stabilize the very long 5.56x45 tracer bullets (M856, IIRC). Obviously, this isn’t necessary for a precision bolt gun. Most precision AR’s (match rifles) usually wear 1:8" barrels for the heavy bullets up to 77gr or 1:7.7" for the 80gr pills. Since the LTR works well with 75gr TAP and the LE world rarely uses anything heavier, Remington determined the ~1:9" twist is fine for that rifle. I’d prefer a 1:8" to give myself a few more options, but I’m happy with the way my LTR shoots as-is.
Also, the longer barrels on (most) bolt guns will result in higher velocities and often allow a slower twist to stabilize the heavier bullets a bit better than the same twist rate in a shorter barrel. This isn’t always true, but I’ve seen it work on more than one occasion.
Where the heavier AR bullets excel is at long range. They are the product of the competitive HP community in their effort to make the AR competitive against M1A’s at 600 yards and beyond. If you don’t need to reach out that far, then you can get by with lighter pills.
On average, FB bullets will be more accurate than BTs, at least out to most practical ranges. Most varmint bullets are FB and are intended to be used out to 300, 400 yards max. I’m not aware of any FB 75/77 grain pills, but at the 600 yard line and beyond, you need that BT for BC.
Within .224 caliber bullets, .223 Rem, while prevalent, is near the bottom of .22 caliber varmint cartridges. 22-250s are extremely popular, and if you have to have the ultimate in speed, go on up to the .220 Swift. At 300 and 400 yard ranges, those cartridges can shoot 55 grain pills pretty flat due to their higher velocity, and although they will drift some, the TOF to the target is so short that drift isn’t as significant an issue compared to .223 Rem. Because of bullet construction, you have to dial the twist back down to avoid in-flight disintegration.
I submit in the majority of conditions in which we shoot, a FB 52/53 grain match bullet out of a 1 in 10" or 1 in 12" will beat a 77 grain pill out of a 1 in 7" out to 200 yards. The BR community defines accuracy, and while their max range is 300 yards, most of the competitive bullets are FB shot out of “slowish” twist barrels.
While fast twists, BTs and 77 grains seems like a winning combo, just understand how and why it evolved to where it is today.
OK, so why would a 18" Noveske, or MK12 (which we all can agree are precision weapons), etc not utilize a 1/9 like the 20" bolt gun would? they have essentially the same length barrels. they probably have the same intended targets. they probably operate at the same distances. they’ll probably both never see a tracer round. for LE, they will probably be using the same TAPS ammo, and they probably will shoot pills less than 77gr too.
DRich, are you implying that the LTR is the weapon with the worse choice in twists? is it just because they offer a 26" barrel 700P, which i assume the 1/9 works well in?
i too had an LTR when they first came out, i got rid of it and kept my two PSS’s (308, 300WM). it shot well with the 77gr loads that i had at the time too
First off, an 18" barreled weapon will lose about 75-100fps over a 20" weapon, and another 75 fps over a 22" barreled weapon. Now you’re talking 150 fps delta between it and most BAs.
It’s probably fair to say that the performance degradation between a “less than optimum twist” vs “optimum twist” is less when going toward “too quick” vs “too slow”. What I mean is, while a 1 in 7" might not be optimum for most of the pills we shoot, there’ll be less accuracy fall off when shooting 55-60 grain stuff (e.g., TAP) out of a 1 in 7" than trying to over extend a 1 in 9" to shoot 77 grain stuff accurately, especially out of carbine-length barrels. Or in other words, over-stabilization is still more accurate than under-stabilization.
But I still submit, if you gave Noveske the task of starting with blanks of the same quality, anything he pumped out using a 1 in 9/10" would outshoot whatever he pumped out using a 1 in 7", if constrained to 60 grain and under pills and distances under 250-300 yards. Stretch the distance and/or bullet weight, and you need the 1 in 8" or quicker twist barrels.