Which H buffer for a 20" barrel with collapsible stock?

I’m converting a 20" length A2 stocked rifle to a carbine with an LMT sopmod collapsible stock. I was wondering which buffer would be best. I’m a slow shooting precision guy with my AR’s at the range, and so anything that tames it while still keeping it working reliable is preferred.

Bravo Company offers an H, H2 and H3. Spikes offers an ST-T2 4.3 oz buffer. Slash’s “Heavy Buffers” in Ohio offers an H2 in 4.6 or an H3 in 5.4

You need to get a carbine buffer tube and use the carbine buffer.

And spring.

Aloha, Mark

Any of the various (top 3 pics) carbine buffers should work (yes, it’s a stolen picture).

What works BEST?

That’s the $64,000 question.

Aloha, Mark

PS…I’d imagine that the weight of the bullet has a lot to do with it. Issac Newton and all that.

I already have the LMT carbine tube along with my LMT collapsible stock. But thanks for the input; now I know that I need a carbine buffer too.

Would somebody please elaborate which buffer mentioned in my opening post would work best?

I would imagine that using a 20" barrel has some kind of effect on the time and pressure with which the bullet passes over the gas port…and dictates the difference which would work best for my purposes.

I don’t mind choosing a buffer that provides less wear and tear on the rifle too…as long as it works reliably.

I think that most folks use too light a buffer - I have a 16" barrel with a MID-length gas system and use an H3 buffer which does not short cycle even with .223 ammo. Shoots so soft - like a .22 rifle.
Try an H3 buffer and IF it short cycles then go to an H2.

Without a doubt if I was running a rifle length gas system, I would use a Vltor A5 system. It duplicates the rifle buffer system, even using a rifle spring, but has a collapsable stock.

Less pressure in a rifle length system pushing the bolt back. A regular carbine buffer will be more reliable. If you want softer shooting you can gradually increase weight but I know for a fact that Tula will not cycle reliably with an H3 and a rifle length system. It seriously depends on ammo.

Edit: and no matter what happens, dont stick a rifle buffer in a carbine tube. -.-

The barrel is a 1-7 twist, firing stout loads of 77 grain Sierra hand loads.

I already have the LMT SOPMOD (complete with tube) and will not be switching to a Vltor or anything else.

That was my recommendation as well.

After alot of experimentation on my LMT carbine lower/tube, I am running my 20" rifle with an H buffer. Soft and reliable even with Wolf.

Beat me to it as well.

+A5

Soft shooting 20 inch with rifle gas…I should imagine a basic carbine buffer will be completely fine. As always, for optimal, YMMV due to differing factors with different barrels, such as gas port size etc.

Perhaps, I didn’t provide enough info? …like that it’s mostly a stock RR A4 NM rifle. or…I’m not sure if some folks just prefer to ignore that I said I already have the complete LMT SOPMOD collapsible stock, and I am shooting 77 grain bullets.

After reading all the input, it seems KSA464 and Sirpleasant seem to think an H or H2 will work for my purposes.

Thanks for the input gentlemen. My only decision now is between the H or H2 buffer.

H3… rifles barrels kick out a lot of gas, and were designed for use with a 5.5oz buffer. you’ll have best results with the heaviest buffer you can find.

i have no experience with the vltor A5 system, but from what i hear, and what i know about vltor products, it’s probably the best option for you.

It’s not an apples to apples comparison to just look at the weight. The spring cycle is different. A rifle springs at rest tension is lower than a carbine spring.

This is why a carbine that runs on an H buffer can also run great on a rifle buffer and spring.

its not apples to apples, but it’s pretty close. the carbine spring is a little stiffer, but that’s to compensate for being shorter. C7A2s use H3s, as i recall.

Perhaps the H3 is optimal, but the whole physics of the rifle buffer system are completely different. It’s not as simple as a little stiffer spring. It’s a completely different spring cycle.

Two completely different spring lengths are compressing the exact same amount. This is what makes the A5 such a game changer.

You get the rifle spring cycle on a sliding stock.

OP, are you also having the barrel cut down? you say you are making this a “carbine,” and you never clarified whether or not you were simply switching to a carbine stock or also cutting down the barrel.