This is a question that may well be impossible to answer. We are all “preppers” to one extent or another, or we wouldn’t be reading this sub-forum of M4C. But what are each of us prepping for? The answers fall into a few big and important categories that vary on geographic, demographic, and societal location each of us finds ourselves living in or working in. I think each of us has zeroed in on one or two scenarios that we feel individually is the most likely or important for us to be as prepared for as possible. The harsh fact that I know the majority of us have faced is that we just cannot know what may happen, how severe it may be, nor how long it may last. And especially none of us can know for surety when this may come. To this end I think the answer is just to do the best we can.
How many defensive rounds is that? Gosh I don’t know. My number one event I have chosen to focus on preparedness for is an earthquake that shuts down utilities and makes freeways more or less impassable, making grocery store resupply cut off. For my area this is not a far fetched idea, we live in a geologically prone basin and only have 2 interstates passing through that choke at some considerable geographic features. In this situation I see looting and rioting becoming an issue. But I also believe it to be a limited duration of time when things will be “hot.” Even though we should hope for the best and plan for the worst, in a 2-3 week scenario as described how likely am I do get into a true firefight to defend my home against multiple coordinated attackers with any skills, where I may actually burn through mag after mag? I say not likely, so would having 4 loaded mags of defensive ammo probably be enough for the M4? Odds are yes. 3 mags total per pistol, probably enough.
Does that mean that I’m comfortable with just that much? Hell no. I have outlined what I believe to be the most realistic scenario for me. With limited resources to use for prepping, I’ve had to focus my efforts as such. Of course, this doesn’t mean I’m not thinking of long term preparedness, with life just not getting back to the way it is. But you have to have focus on something specific in order to get anywhere, so pick something clear, accomplish it, and plot your next grid point so you can shoot the azmuth and get to ruckin’.
If we are considering true TEOTWAWKI (“Book of Eli” or “The Post-Man”) then there isn’t a number that is enough and for this reason I try not to focus on that possibility as its beyond reach at this point.
Ok, I’d like to diversify the question a bit if the OP allows it. What is “defensive” ammo? I am not ignorant, but rather curious what you and others have for personal criteria to qualify a round as a “defensive” round. Here’s the basis of my little question: In my EDC pistol I have 180 gr Fed Hydra-shocks. Clearly a defensive round, as its characteristics allow for maximum energy dump on target because it will rapidly expand, retain max mass, blah blah. A better choice than FMJ’s for SD. In pistols I think the line is easier to draw. HP of any kind is probably better than FMJ/TMJ for SD. With rifles, especially 5.56/.223, I don’t think the line is as clearly definable. When I’m shooting Uncle Sam’s M4 that he assigns me we are sending M855 down range for practice and for real alike. This is an FMJ for all real intents and purposes (I know it has the steel core and penetrates straighter/truer than a simple FMJ). While many have lamented its performance on the enemy it is still respected as a go-to round by MANY here at M4C. Then we have the m193, a 55 gr FMJ. As far as I know there isn’t much more to it than that, and again I’ve read many on this site say they would want to go to a 2-way range with either it or 855. Of course then there are plenty, and it seems to be the LE community the most, that love the Hornady TAP stuff. I have no experience with that stuff, so I don’t have any criticism or praise. Now, I’ll throw in a couple of other options, what about soft point ammo in .223/5.56? This is an in-between the aforementioned FMJ’s and deluxe HP’s. And then what about some of the premium hunting bullets, like the Nosler partition, Barnes TSX, or Fed Fusion? Sierra GameKings? Speer 70 gr semispitzer, (I personally have loaded both the last two for deer/large predator hunting and know they pentrate and expand very well)?
My question and point is, not only how do we decide how many is enough but what is qualified to be depended on? Do you guys see m193 as better for SD than PMC 55gr? Cost is a huge barrier to me. That is the real root of my curiosity. I have a number of total rounds right now that makes me feel settled, not satisfied but settled. I have 100-200 of the hunting stuff I mentioned, a couple of mags of xm855 and m193 each, a bunch of typical soft-points, and then a bunch of plain jane fmj’s. Basically, I have what I can afford a little at a time along the way and count it all as defensive ammo if there is a threat. I have factory loaded soft-points in the first 2 SD mags and then the mil stuff and then the hunting stuff and down the line I wouldn’t hesitate to use the “range” stuff as I figure no one wants to be shot by anything when it comes right down to it. I’d like to hear what order you’d go with in these options (SP, 855/193, hunting, “range” fmj’s).
I want feedback. I like the premise of this thread. I hope to hear what people consider enough. And I hope that my added twist is agreeable to PA Patriot.