What is the use of a shotgun?

I know that is a really dumb way to title a thread, but the shotgun urban myth thread got me thinking, what is the ideal use of a shotgun? I’ve seen the pictures of some of the setups guys have been using (870 with a red dot, collapsable stock, light, etc.) and I wouldn’t mind having something like that. However, at the same time I can’t figure out what the hell I’d do with it. I’ve already got a good carbine and don’t live in an urban area, so what use would a shotgun have? I’ve got an 870 that I got for hunting, but beyond that I’ve been a rifle guy. Am I missing something by not having some sort of fighting shotgun?

That’s really up to you. The nice thing about the 870 is that it is the most numerous shotgun (and I think also most numerous firearm) in North America so replacement parts are everywhere and are usually interchangeable.

I’d say your fine with your old hunting shotgun, maybe have a shorter barrel on hand to swap it out when needed.

Here’s my, possibly faulty, take on the Shotty:

The benefit of a “combat shotgun” is that you are afforded, at close ranges, the opportunity to deliver a lot of mass at a target for every shot fired. Obviously, “a lot of mass”, is dependent on what type of shells you are using, but, as stated, the opportunity is there.

My main gripe about a shotgun is the limited capacity, limited range, slow follow-up shot time, and large weapon profile.

Everything is a trade off.

I believe that a shotgun would be an excellent tool to have if one is working in a group or team, but in a HD role, I believe there are better tools in the toolbox.

YMMV.

Cost is the first thing that comes to my mind when I think of a shotgun. I love my carbine but not everybody can afford spending $800 or more on a gun.

I picked up a brand new 18" Benelli Nova with sights for $250 a few years back. I don’t shoot it a lot, probably 200 rounds, but every time I do it goes bang. It shares time between the closet, garage, and camper. It has similar controls to my Benelli M1S90 which I shoot more often.

Sure, you can go out and accessorize the crap out of the gun but why? It’s a shotgun, spend your money on learning how to use it and not so much on accessories. Be careful if you do add stuff to the gun, it can create reliability issues.

That’s my personal shotgun. Notice it has every trick on earth availible, but is kept nice and simple for everyday use. The other items have a place, but for the most part the basic shotgun does what you need for $150-$300 used.

Besides the obvious bird hunting and sporting clay use, as well as hunting in those states that require shotguns for deer, shotguns have quite a few uses:

– Close range defense against large animals using solid slugs like Brennekes
– Close range protection against charging threats like pit bulls when using buckshot
– Unparalleled high incapacitation potential against close range, unarmored targets
– Superb penetration through intermediate barriers that can defeat assault rifle projectiles
– Breaching by properly trained individuals
– Ability to use less lethal projectile options
– Inexpensive, readily available, easily serviced, durable, reliable, with plentiful ammunition options for folks who cannot afford more expensive weapon choices
– Traditional, “accepted” weapon platform that does not tend to alarm bureaucrats and sheeple…

I’m going to have to disagree with you on that. Home defense is a general term for fighting off an intruder/intruders from the interior or immediate exterior of your home. The vast majority of the time this will be well within the effective range of buckshot, and the encounter will likely be occuring at night which also serves as a range limiter. At those ranges, and against human targets, the shotgun will be a superior weapon system given its ability to inflict multiple hits per shot…this will destroy more of the anatomy of the intruder, and will give you a better margin of shot placement error than using a carbine or pistol. Provided that you use quality 00-buck, copper plated if available, underpenetration should not be an issue as the pellets will limit their deformation…and nine .32 caliber holes with every shot is highly effective. Even non lethal hits can weaken or criple your attacker, and there is a higher level of ricochet which has a better chance of spraying your attacker’s face. Lots of advantages in getting a lot of lead on target in a hurry, even if the hits aren’t lethal.

As Doc very well put out, the shotgun can be used in a wide variety of situations more effectively than carbine in a common assault rifle caliber. However, like all tools it has its limits which are capacity, rate of fire, slow reload speed, and range. In an indoor environment, or on a night time vehicle stop, I would much prefer to use a 870 or 11-87. I think the biggest problem that police officers suffer is that they go back and forth between the shotgun and rifle and confuse their strengths/weakensses under stress. You have officers that deploy their shotguns when they should be using rifles, and rifles when they should be deploying the shotgun. Obviously, just using carbines would clear up this training confusion, but if you can deploy the shotgun at the right times it will give you a measurable advantage at close ranges and in most night time defensive situations.

Killing stuff and breaking things.

Get you a short bbl and white light for your 870!

Rabbits, quail and fun. Sorry, but I stopped considering my 18" 870 for HD when home invaders started coming in groups. Carbine all the way.

For putting big holes in things at close range.

I think you answered your own question. :wink:

If you have no use for any of the specialty applications of a fighting shotgun, and you already have a fighting rifle, I’d have to say that you’re not “missing” anything by not having a fighting shotgun. The debates begin when someone asserts that the fighting shotgun is useless or has been completely eclipsed by the rifle/carbine.

I did once the front door of the house was between my bedroom and childrens bedrooms.

it kicks serious arse on Halo

For me shotguns are really big bore rifles (I carry Breneke slugs no buck) that I use for dealing with wildlife threats at work and at home. I had to kill two black bear last summer. Lot of black bear encounters. I carry a patrol rifle for two legged threats.

my 14 inch Vang comped 870. Good gun.

Pat

A very big +1:eek:

I agree with the statement of a shotgun being a very broad platform. I carry a 870 Police on duty in the car. Great close combat firearm. We are required to carry slugs, so it will put big holes in things. I have always been very comfortable with a shotgun in a stress situation. Now, for those that remember the incident at Palm Bay, Fl. that is what the carbine is for.

Non service uses is small game, Turkeys, hunting deer and hogs in thick brush.

If you don’t mind my asking, what happened at Palm Bay, Fl?

There is a reason why my Remington 870 sits right beside one of my ARs (Suppressed SBR) in my bedroom linen closet. I recognize that while I would more readily go to my AR for home defense use, there might be a time when the 870 is more appropriate.

What use is a toolbox that only contain one tool? In the world of firearms (regardless of its use), there really is no such thing as a “Swiss Army Gun”. JM2CW.

Back in 1987, a man with a mini 14 went on a shooting spree killing 4 civilians and wounding 14 more. The guy took hostages at a store and killed 2 of the responding officers. The guy later surrendered and was sentenced to death for all the murders. When I say it was a big deal in the late 80’s i mean that kind of thing was not reported nationally as much as it is today.

God I feel old. :smiley:

Economic long arm.