Well I dumped my BlackBerry Curve II(good solid phone BTW) for an iPhone 3gs because I am a geek who needed to try it out. I am now on the search for cases other than the OtterBox. I do love OtterBoxes as all of my phones have had them, but again looking to try something different. What are you guys running? How has it held up? Would you buy it again? Pics are a plus. My biggest concern is keeping dirt out as I am a mechanic and come laundry day I can empty quite a bit of dirt/rust/crud out of my pockets where my phone rides all day. As far as looks are concerned I like utilitarian hunk of steel looks.
I’ve been through a lot of personal and work phones and the Otterbox Defender has protected my IPhone very well. I know you’re looking for something different but I haven’t seen anything as heavy duty yet.
I’ve used both an Otterbox and a cheap silicone one. But at the mo i have a FDE Magpul one. Its a good case once you’ve removed the sections for the charging jack and headphone socket. Only down side is that mine has started to come loose on the phone.
GO with the Otter Box. it’s big and bulky but worth the size. I bet I have dropped mine a dozen times from heights of 3-6 feet with no breakage or issues with the phone. Know I got the insurance on the phone as well so not to worries.
While I dont have an Iphone. I have had the Otter box commuter on my blackberry and now on my samsung omnea II and I swear by them. They can handle some abuse and still fit in your pocket. The defender series is very rugged, but it feels like you are carrying a UPS scanner.