Upgrade M1A or go to new platform?

I’ve been thinking about building some sort of DMR rifle and I thought that I’d go with a 7.62x51 rifle for this one. Currently I have an SA Inc. standard M1A. What I was thinking of doing was adding a Troy m14 MCS(I want a pistolgrip stock) and some low power variable scope. The only problem is that the gun is still something from SA Inc. and I’d have a pretty heavy gun. So I’m wondering if I should just sell my M1A(or save some more money) and go to a different weapon platform. What do you guys think? Is there something out there better for my purpose or would upgrading my M1A be the way to go?

ETA I was looking at the SAGE m14 stock since it sounds like they are lighter. Is that true and is there any other reason to get a SAGE?

Sage EBR and have Smith Enterprises Inc.

SEI, Crazyhorse etc…

Have you taken a look at the J. Allen Enterprises JAE-100 stock?

I went down this road before. Here’s my story.

First off, new SI M1As are not as high quality as old GI parts rifles. That being the case, I picked up two rifles with TRW parts and Fulton receivers. Great start. To make a long story short, I tried 2 McMillan stocks, professionally bedded by a bad ass M14 smith, and a Troy MCS system, but I could not get them to shoot better than an inch-well, more than that really. I consider 1 moa or better as a minimum on my DMR guns, hence that was the standard.

I was going to buy a Sage stock to build on, but the wait was stupidly long, and stories abounded of Sage taking peoples’ money and taking forever to deliver. During that time, I took a course at a school that has a good number of students through it, and the owner of the school recounted that he had several brand new accurized factory SI M1As come through there with an active duty Army unit. NONE of the guns would make the 1MOA requirements. From what he’d seen, the only M14s that would run were “real deal” Crane rifles, fielded by Air Force PJs. They used high quality parts, assembled by great 'smiths, and were built on the Sage stock. But those were the ONLY M14s that have made it through the course, which involves stalking and engaging known and unknown targets out to 1200 yards.

While I was there, an SF group was breaking in some SR25s, and they were making the grade just fine. Only thing is, Knights didn’t mount the scope rings on an elevated base, so they didn’t have the elevation to get past 800 yards, so they had to shim in about 20 moa and then they were good to 1000. Anywho, the SRs shot pretty well, but not as well as a humble (cheap) bolt gun-I guess you just have to accept that, generally speaking.

So, at this point, I threw up my hands and sold off my various custom stocks and put my M1As in standard fiberglass GI stocks. One is plane jane and the other is decked out, end to end, in Smith Ent gear, and looks bad ass. The guns are so much more fun to shoot in their natural state, I won’t mess with them again.

SO, in the end, I went with a rifle that a guy from Snipers Hide had built by Noveske. It is a Noveske 18inch N6 upper, over a DPMS lower with Magpull PRS and a smooth breaking 2 stage trigger. First time out, it grouped .91inch with BH 175 grain OTM. That was with a shitty initial setup and a half ass rest. I hope to shoot it again soon and see what I can do with some Federal 168.

Now, you are thinking-you still have a gun that shot no better than 1 inch? Yes, but I got this rifle with a pile of mags, bipod, etc, for 2grand-not including scope, of course. I was going to spend WAY more than that with the cost of parts and labor from Smith Enterprises.

The point is, it seems that you have to spend alot of money and have access to a talented M14 'smith (not many around) in order to get a very accurate M1A. BTW, opinions on how to accurize the M1As abound as well: modular chassis stock systems, bedded stocks, unbedded stocks, unitized or un-unitized gas systems, welded versus screwed systems, the list goes on and on. You have to be aware of all these things and instruct your smith as to what you want, or just go with whatever they think you should do. I guess it depends on how much you trust your builder.

Oh, I’ve spoken to several folks who swear that SR 25s on the civilian market don’t get the quality of components that the military gets. (The military paid 10grand each for the case full of rifle and goodies I was looking at!) That being the case, I went with the Noveske, which I feel is the highest quality production company out there.

I love Noveskes, but I have heard lots of good things about semi auto 308 rifles built by GA precision, as well.

Sorry for being verbose, but there it is. Good luck with whatever you end up with. You can probably find a bad ass M1A set up just like you want, on M14 Firing Line Forums. There’s a great PX, as well as a wealth of M14 knowledge over there.

Regards.

The above post by USBP379 needs to be stickied as a ready response to those who can’t get over their emotional attachment to an outdated platform.

Thanks for sharing.

I resemble that remark. You’re just jealous. :smiley:

The same should be said for the 1911. I never went throught the M1A quest. But I through money down the “I can make a 1911 reliable” hole. :frowning:

Same here and agreed.

Thanks for the advice USBP379. That covered a lot of my concerns about the whole project and why I shouldn’t do it. I don’t really have any attachment to this gun(other than it was one of my first rifles) and to be honest, I don’t get why some people think they are so great. This was more or less one of those “I want a DMR and I have this M1A, maybe I could use it” kind of deals. I’ll have to look at a Noveske or maybe the Larue OSR will come out one of these days.

I can’t say enough about the FAL platform as it’s my first military rifle love. I’ve tinkered and played with it enough to find it utterly reliable even if I’ve never tried to make it a precision rifle piece. This however is a purely subjective choice, but I think for the money you’re hard-pressed to find a rifle that performs as well for its price-point.

I’ll be taking a DSArms FAL (with 3x30 ACOG) to a DMR class this weekend. It performs well within 200 yards, we’ll see how it does at distance.

Thanks to LRI for giving me a chance to stretch its legs.

That was great… M14 clones can get expensive really, really fast when using good smiths…

Spooky

The PJ’s, et al, who are getting confirmed kills reapeatedly past 600 yards sure seem not to mind the outdated platform. Perhaps that should be stickied.

EXACTLY!
Outdated my ASS.
Navy SEALS using the MK14MOD0 have nearly 300 confirmed kills.

2ND Infantry Division use the Crazy Horse M14, Rifle has over 500
confirmed kills in theater.

True stuff. Just remember that I have an SA Inc. M1A(nothing great) and don’t really have the budget or knowhow to build something equal to waht Smith Ent. can do. More or less the plan was to put the M1A in a Troy or Sage stock and scope it. Nothing else since it would probably be a waste of time due to my less than stellar skills and my ammo. I really don’t want this to turn into a fight like these threads sometimes become. All I wanted to know was if upgrading the gun I have would be worth it, or if I should look elsewhere.

Gutshot John, I’ll be interested to here how you do with your FAL. I have handled one(and shoot it soon) and i was impressed by how it handled and felt. The only real reservation I had with them was accuracy, which may or may not be an issue.

As covered in previous posts, the first rifle I shot expert on after getting commissioned in 1986 was an M14. Back when I shot Hi-Power, I had a lot of match grade McMillan stocked M1A’s, both iron sighted and with optics (they were heavy beasts)–I have sold all of them and only kept two lightweight 18" SA M1A’s (with GI parts) in simple GI brown stocks. The only reason I continue to own M1A’s is that they are still “legal” and not restricted as “assault weapons” under CA’s asinine laws (unlike AR’s, AK’s, FAL’s, etc…). M1A’s work OK as simple, rugged iron sighted rifles of limited long term accuracy potential. For mounting optics or any other precision role, there are far better choices. The only justification for my last couple of M1A’s continued existence is to reside in the trunk of my POV’s. For every other situation, I am reaching for a rifle with superior ergonomics, like an AR15. FWIW, most of the guys I know who have been issued Mk14’s, have gotten rid of them as soon as possible–there are a couple of threads at LF on this topic…

You will never win an argument debating how the M14/M1A is a superior weapon. It was a great weapon as was the M1 Garand.

It will never be in the league of the SR25. I happen to love the M14. I also love the M1 and (shielding myself from bricks being thrown) the Mini-14.

Because I love them does not mean they are a better system. They are what they are.

I enjoy them in their true form. Standard stock, nothing tactical. To me they are great guns. Not “battle rifles”, not go-to guns. Just fun.

The Mini-14 is like big 10/22, a truck gun and much more enjoyable to pack around than an M4 when messing around in the mountains.

When funds permit, an 18" M1A will be my new deer rifle. Why not? “It may malfuction” and the deer could kill me. Come on. Who cares. .308 Win is a great deer round and I love the M14. Why Not?

If it is tactical you want, choose another platform. If you like the the M14, have at it. It is what it is. Just remember, you can put lip stick on a pig…

I can kill someone with a sharp stick but that doesn’t mean it’s not outdated.

Could I see the citable data on the above kills?

I’ll go ahead and beat a dead horse - the SEALs and US Army have access to full-time armorers and parts bins full of original USGI spec material.

Civilians, cops and NG units don’t.

M_P

SoDak
I have a SA 18.5" Scout, it’s never been to any armorer.
1st I had it in a TROY MCS with a TAO1 ACOG, it shot 1 m.o.a.
with FED 168gr MATCH.
2nd My scout is now in a Sage MOD1, I don’t have it set up with a scope
I have an Aimpoint on it. With the iron sights it shoots 2 m.o.a.
Scoped it would easy shot 1 m.o.a.
So yes your upgrade would probably cover what you want. I say probably because only you can answer on your skill level with a rifle.
This platform is like any other and no different. You can sink all the money in the world into it or you can have good performance in stock form. The choice, as it should be, is yours

littlelebowski
Whats so outdated abot the M14? The original design still functions, Its one of the most reliable designs ever. Yes I know ther are better/newer weapons but that certainly does’nt automatically make the M1A/ M14 out dated.

Data you requested
http://crazyhorserifles.com/

I just spent 20 minutes looking around that site looking for the data you cited.

I couldn’t find it.

Could you provide a direct link to the kill data?

That said, you’re talking spending thousands of dollars on an M14 setup that could otherwise be spent on training and ammo. That’s a pretty big opportunity cost for what is still a non mil-spec rifle.

As for it being outdated, I’m sure the SeALs and Army agree at least in theory as I seem to remember that they’re switching over to the SR-25 platform and phasing out the M14.