After a discussion with a friend on this topic I thought I might throw some things out for discussion to the forum.
There are distinctly different approaches to training. Some of these differences are personality driven, which can account for different approaches to identical problems, but the major differences are a result of the intended application of the techniques as intended by the instructor.
As I see it there are four major categories of firearms training.
1- Fundamental. The first steps. I also consider bulls-eye shooting/competitions to be fundamental in nature.
2- Competition. Training designed to elevate the shooter’s classification and competitiveness in games such as IDPA, USPSA, and 3-gun type comps.
3- Personal defense. Applicable to the CCW/armed individual.
4- Combat. Most applicable to heavily armed individuals that will be working in teams.
While all three share similar aspects, especially in the pure marksmanship category, there are parts where they diverge, and judicious selection of the training type/instructor will most benefit the shooter by introducing and/or honing the finer points of the needed skill-set. Ex- a soon to deploy reservist will probably benefit more from training with the likes of Magpul Dynamics than from Todd Jarrett. This is not to say that Todd won’t make you a better shooter, just that learning combat skills from those that have performed well in actual combat will probably have better insight to the skills needed to prevail in that domain with applicable gear. To reverse the coin, if one wants to become a GM USPSA shooter it would be better to seek out the tutelage of Todd Jarrett or other active GM trainer.
Major differences lie between all three types of training beyond fundamental training. One major concept that must be embraced and honed (in my opinion) is combat mindset. Appropriate mindset really boils down to the will and ability to fight until you win. While high-level competition shooters have a competition oriented mindset required to win competitions, most competition-only shooters are ill-equipped to enhance the mindset of their students for gunfights.
Competition oriented training, in my experience, tends to focus on specific techniques to win matches. Defensive training tends to focus on individual survival. Combat training should focus on domination of the ground.
While I have experience and training in defensive concepts and competition, my focus is in offensive small-unit combat, so that is the perspective that drives my training choices. As such I do not consider myself qualified to dwell on defensive or competition training concepts beyond my broad-stroke distinctions.
As far as “combat” training is concerned appropriate training in marksmanship, manipulations, and mindset should be embraced by the instructor and student. I consider them to be of equal importance. A superior shooter that can’t solve an inline double-feed is ineffective. A hard-charging individual that can perform a long-gun reload in 3 seconds is inefficient if he lacks the marksmanship skill to place bullets into the threat with the degree of precision/accuracy needed to stop the threat.
Some differences as I see them-
Threat engagement. In fundamental and competative marksmanship the shooter is generally delivering a pre-designated number of shots to the target. When it comes to fighting one cannot assume that any number of pre-designated shots will actually work. The shooter must be trained to rapidly deliver shots and instinctively switch to alternate shot placement should those initial shots fail to achieve the desired result. The shooter must constantly be expecting another threat to be present or imminent.
Orientation/Pivots and turns. Most pivoting techniques, especially 90 degree pivots, are often dwelled upon, much to my amusement. As I see it the only evaluation points are the ability of the shooter to quickly acquire a firing platform without cranking a round into the ground, orbit, or another shooter. While I consider muzzle awareness and discipline to be a hall-mark of a professional warrior, how much live-fire is really necessary to accomplish this? It generally doesn’t take long for me to see who is incaipable of keeping their gun pointed in a safe direction at all times, including changing direction.
I do however place a bit of importance in 180 degree turns with a long-gun. The reason is that I teach 180s a bit differently than most others do. My 180s are not intended to engage a threat that is shooting at your back- there are much better ways to deal with that than to be standing upright and performing an aikido box-step. Rather, I focus on the skill to negotiate a door-way/button-hook, which is a directly applicable critical skill. It is not the fastest way to turn around, but it is the combat skill needed combined with a marksmanship/speed standard.
Gear. Most things will be the same or similar whether fully jocked-up or wearing a polo shirt and oakleys. There are some things that will dramatically change though- magazine access, stock placement, eye-relief, and other subtle changes that can only be appreciated once the gear is on. Some fundamental and competition skills will not cross-over when your chest is 2" thicker, and your arms are 2" shorter due to your armor and you can no longer get to your belt-system. Likewise, there are techniques that work with armor that don’t work as well as other techniques when running slick.
No/Low Light. Combat happens whenever it happens. Competitions and fundamental marksmanship primarily occur in daylight or in lighted conditions. This makes a distinct change in what needs to be on your gun and how you interface with the items. Optics that do great in the day suddenly become unusable or sub-optimal in transient lighting conditions.
Targets. In combat shooting it is important to provide the shooter with a realistic threat to shoot. I could go on for several pages just about targetry, but I will cut it down to simple concepts for brevity’s sake. Having a target that looks like an actual bad-guy serves more than just psychologically preparing the student to shoot at another human, it also prepares the shooter to see what the aiming device looks like in actual use. A sighting system that looks great on a buff-colored target in daylight may not do so well when using a white-light during darkness on a 10 meter target clothed in a dark shirt. Further, during most training the targets are fully frontally presented as if standing up- most bad guys are not so dumb. Targets at odd angles, partially exposed, with varying amounts of exposure are far more common. Training beyond a basic level should exposure the shooter to these factors while requiring the shooter to maintain a standard of accuracy.
Positions. There are relatively few times when the traditional standing, kneeling, sitting and prone positions will be the solution to a combat problem. Shooting from cover, support, and unconventional positions should be thoroughly practiced and mastered. Understanding how to best use cover in different situations pays dividends when bullets are smashing into your little piece of hell. Bilateral use of cover and its training under pressure can carry over to real-life use, but only if trained and practiced with the same regularity and intensity of “normal” use. While most shooters will be better served by focusing on “normal” strong/support hand use, dedicated training to maximize cover will better protect the shooter in a combat scenario without massive degredation of effectiveness. This also plays into effect for wounded shooter use, a situation that rarely plagues bulls-eye shooters.
Manipulations and transitions. While it is all well and good to teach shooters to immediately transition to a side-arm if inside 25 yards when your primary stops working, it can be a bad habit if the shooter is not actually going to be armed with a secondary in real-life. In a similar vein, learning how to reload a pistol without coming close to breaking the 180 may be beneficial to USPSA shooters, but won’t be of much benefit to someone primarily concerned with retention. There are most certainly benefits to reloading quickly, but there is just as much benefit to minimizing exposure and profile while reloading quickly. There are many examples of minor differences in not only name and technique but also of intent and priority.
There are also things mistakenly attritibuted to “combat” techniques that really bring no benefit.
Racking the slide during a reload. One of the things beaten into most of us under the threat that depressing the slide-release/stop would cause erectile dysfunction. Hitting the slide release is faster and causes no more stoppages than racking the slide. The argument that not all pistols have a slide release is a bit weak. If the weapon you are armed with has one, use it. Not all pistols have a set of sights, a triggerguard-area mag release, safety, or even a slide, yet there are few that recommend against using these features when available. Further, there are several weapons that have the controls located in different places. If you happen to be forced to a battle-field pickup I recommend a TRB before you need to shoot anyway. Once the smoke settles, feel free to determine what controls the gun has and where they are if you are unfamiliar with the new roscoe.
The Weaver Stance. There is a ridiculous amount of data that indicates that the weaver breaks-down under stress. Sure, there are guys that are very good with the weaver on a one-way range and some on the two-way as well, but generally speaking the iso will be more natural and effective under stress with equal training.
Just a few of my thoughts when it comes to determining what type of training is applicable to the user and some specific examples of differences. I do not pretend to hold the one true path to tactical enlightenment, just experience in the field and in training people to suceed in bad places.