No, it is something I want to do IF it can be done reasonably and that depends upon the answers to the questions I posted.
Not looking for validation, looking for “will this work?” answers. The questions are right in the OP.
Thank you, that is the first time I have gotten a definitive answer to this question, previously you just mentioned it was the same under the FSB but experience has taught me that doesn’t always means the same thing under the handguards.
Well the first part is long experience has taught me that Company A doesn’t always work with Company B. So after many years of being taught this whenever possible I keep all parts original or original manufacture. I have no doubt that DD is a quality barrel.
But if you read what I wrote (rather than just read in for things that aren’t there) the basis for my motivation is the belief that it will be far more economical to cut and crown the existing barrel than replace it with a brand new barrel. This is because there is nothing wrong with the existing barrel so IF I can use it, I would prefer to.
As far as the “collector issues” you are inventing in your mind because you think you can read mine, once you modify a original rifle it loses most of it’s collector value. From a "collector standpoint I’d be much better off getting a DD barrel and then being able to return it to “original configuration” if desired. But this will be a shooting SBR, not a collector rifle.
I’d like to do it that way because I believe it will be more cost effective. But I still haven’t been able to get answers to the questions in my original post which will be the “make or break” deciding factors.
Do you happen to know the answers? Again I’m concerned with cutting and crowning a chrome barrel. Is it not a big deal or is it something that usually results in flaking problems like mentioned on the SCAR SBR threads? Also wondering if the gas port will need to be modified.
Thank you for recommending ADCO, if I can’t find the answers here, sounds like I might find the answers there.
Ya know what Rob? I’ve had two already, sold them both. The M4 was just too heavy and as I was gonna run it without optics I decided a short A2 would be exactly what I’m looking for.
You know me in person and you know me from my posts. And while I am very much a collector also, please don’t assume you know everything about me and my motivations. When you make such assumptions it makes it very difficult for me to get answers.
How can I be looking for validation for an idea that I’m not certain will work? I know what I’d like to do but that doesn’t make it a foregone conclusion. And what I’m seeking is not validation, what I’m seeking is answers to the “will this work” questions I asked.
You don’t need to sugar coat any of those answers. Yes it will or no it won’t work will be just fine. But please stop trying to be Miss Cleo because you suck at reading my mind or divining my motivations (even when they are clearly spelled out as in this case).
