The Pentagon’s Culture of Risk-Aversion and the Infantry Automatic Rifle (IAR) Solici

So I suppose the MK23 and M320 don’t count? :rolleyes:

Tspeis

The Comanche was designed to replace the Kiowa and Kiowa Warrior (OH-58 A, B, C, and D models). The Kiowa is another legacy design that has flown for 30+ years. It serves as the Army’s premier aerial scout/reconnaissance helicopter ans is essential for helping the Apaches find targets. The Comanche would have better complimented the Apache but now we are stuck with Kiowas. Do you seriously think that the Kiowa will be able to operate in the altitudes that we have to deal with in Afghanistan or would you rather have a couple battalions of Comanches at the ready when you are getting your ass handed to you.

I like this quote as it is a perfect illustration of all that is wrong with are military right now. Sure it is costly to maintain a large army and to field a large amount of weapons and weapon systems. Yes you can opt for less and plan to ramp up in time of need. However, there is a price for this line of thought. That price is the blood of the few that have to stand the line with old, worn out, or just downright outdated equipment. I joined the Army when we had 16 divisions and Four Armies. We could invade Panama with two to three divisions and still have five divisions on the line in Western Europe, a Division on the line in Korea, and still have three left over for contingency operations. Now we are down to 10 Divisions (albeit with four maneuver Brigades each) and we are running our selves ragged. Would you like to be one of the few that has to hold the line while we try to grow the Armed Forces (all volunteers) and procure the new weapon systems that you suggest we can wait to produce at a whim.

We tried this philosophy after WWII and paid in blood when the North Koreans came south. Task Force Smith was nearly eradicated because of their equipment shortcomings and lack of training. AARs state that the men were willing to fight but their equipment wasn’t up to the task of facing more advanced weaponry. This was a mere six years after the ended of WWII. I’m sorry this is harsh but I find it unconscionable to believe that you can develop weapon system from known technology and field them rapidly. By the time the weapons get to the troops it is too late and the war is lost. When a fighting man says he needs new gear he needs it yesterday not a few years down the line.

V/R

A few days ago I read the US military is replacing their mag followers with their newest anti-tilt design and spring.

At first I was disappointed that they did not go with Magpul’s follower as it is an already proven design. I thought about the point in the article in this thread, specifically the point about only dealing with companies that have proven they can deliver the large quantities that would be required by a military order.

I remembered how Magpul seemed to be out of stock on a lot of stuff with the sales they have now. I am not bashing Magpul at all, I have several of their products and think they make great stuff, but it did make me wonder if they had gotten a contract to supply their anti-tilt followers how they would keep up.

You make a valid point, but should realize many on this forum are Military Veterans with practical experience that deserve to share their opinions. Many of the Military beauruecrats are just as ineppt as their civilian counterparts. These are the ones that gave us the M60 GPMG and the M14. The M60 was piece of junk that was replaced by the M240(FN MAG 58). A Machine Gun that was in combat while the M60 was on the drawing boards. The M14 was a nice rifle, but failed to live up to expectations of being capable of filling multiple roles, ie, Rifle, Carbine, SMG and AR. It also goes done in history of being one of the shortest serving US service rifles. The adoption of the FN FAL would have been a better choice and would also have standardized us with our NATO Allies. The reason the M16 came into the picture was due to the shortcomings of the M14 and the influence of Curtiss LeMay and SecDef Macnamara. The Marines at that time were interested in the Stoner 63. Granted, the M16 has proven itself to be successful despite its early problems. I believe its fair to say that our Military has had a degree of difficulty making the right choice considering Infantry weapon systems.

Yeah yeah, military committees have never made any mistakes.

Both very fair points. However, in the context of this discussion, we’ve got folks who are explaining that they think one gun is better or more suited than another when they have not seen any test data and are basing their assumptions on things like spare parts commonality.

I don’t care how “innovative” your company is or how many times you can get it featured on The Military Channel, if your IAR candidate can’t maintain the required accuracy requirement then it’s a failure.

This.

Is why economic recovery is still a ways off and employment recovery is even farther away.

During WWII quite a few companies received lucrative gov’t contracts to produce war materials. Not all of these companies were large enough to meet the demand. What they did was simple. They subcontracted the work to other manufacturers and put in place internal inspectors to ensure the product meets the exact standards that the government was looking for. MAGPUL could easily partner with another manufacturer to meet any demand that they have for their products.

As for the followers, the Army isn’t going to get rid of millions of magazines to purchase MAGPUL mags.

What is sad is that our military’s procurement system for this type of hardware is based on who knows who and not who makes the product that meets the criteria or is simply the best.

During WWII, various hardware such as Fighters, Bombers, boats, rifles, vehicles, etc., were produced by multiple manufacturers because the emphasis was that the troops ot the equipment they needed.

I don’t see why RFIs cannot included such provisions in the case the winning bidder does not have the manufacturing capability to meet the projected requirements in the short term.

But then again, we’re talking about the same morons who paid $500 for toilet seats, hammers, and tape measures. :rolleyes:

Damn right some of us are a lot more qualified. We have quite afew Combat and Peacetime Veterans on this and other forums who can attest to the pros and cons of the equipment they have been issued.

I serve with quite a few Privates whose opinion I put more stock on than the procurement weenies. These kids don’t have an axe to grind or a career/pensin to worry about and only want to get issued the best USABLE equipment. Not like the damned politicians who could care less what gets issued as long as it is in their district or will guarantee them an income for life.

Just look at the new “lightweight” plate carriers that they are currently issuing our deploying troops. Despite the fact that it was more than a pound heavier than the ones submitted by Eagle and MSA Paraclete, both of which have been in use by the SOF community and the Marinesm it still somehow “won”. I’m sure the fact KDH’s facilities were in Murtha’s district had absolutely nothing to do with it. I’m also willing to bet that the “data” for this procurement says that KDH won fair and square.

If I could earn a penny for every piece-of-shit equipment I was issued and had to use/carry and/or maintain in more than 25-years of combined military service; I would probably have earned enough to buy the last presidency. :rolleyes: JM2CW.

Your ire is misplaced. The reason those kinds of contracts aren’t let anymore is because the companies don’t want to release their intellectual property. The Army tried to establish a consortium of .mil, .edu, and .com folks for small arms development about five years ago. It’s never really accomplished anything because none of the big companies want to partner.

I’ve never questioned their ability to attest to equipment they’ve seen and used. That doesn’t give people a psychic ability to know how, e.g., the KAC or LWRC guns did in objective testing compared to the Colt, FN, or HK guns that made it past the down-select.

The continued assumptions that the Marines involved in this procurement are stupid, inexperienced, and/or politically motivated are simply unworthy of the regular level of professionalism seen at M4C.

And there are “joes” out there that would take a gold plated desert eagle to combat if they could.

Contrary to popular belief joe does not always know what is best for him.

I deal with this kinda stuff at work, the officer will see that this flashlight is “brighter” so its got to be better, right? Only, when I pick it apart in front of them, and point out, what should be obvious flaws, do they see it.

All to often guys want knew gear based on:

It looks cool
It is more comfortable(the lazy kinda way)
Its what Blackwater uses’
I do or don’t wanna look like Army/Marines/XXXXX
Any number of myths that they believe. with no technical knowledge of the equipment.

Talking with the company procurement official, I was told, “But, this is what you guys wanted” well, things don’t always work out like we thought they would(I wasn’t there when this stuff was chosen).

What is needed is balance and a close working relationship between the troops, the “technicians”, and the procurement people.(That sounds a little to Obama like).

I’m sure the military procurement system is broke, or at the very least needs some improvement, but just leaving it up to joe, is not the answer, because I guarantee, you’ll get out voted by the knuckleheads, every time.

As far as the IAR thing, I haven’t followed it to closely, but if it supports USMC doctrine good for them.
From my Infantry days though, I’m not to keen on yet another weapon in the inventory. Lets not forget why we went to an assault rifle and GPMG in the first place.

Bob

Ding ding ding ding!

Head’s up, fellas, manufacturing capability (to use the cited example) is merely one of a metric assload of considerations in a procurement process. That it isn’t written into some particular document to the satisfaction of the reader in no way means that it isn’t one of the things that a company can fail to meet threshold on. It’s sorta like correct spelling: something that should be expected past a certain maturity level.

Somebody already mentioned how things seem weighted toward the ‘entrenched’ companies, and while that may be factual or not (WAY above my pay grade and ability to ability to objectively judge), that finger can be pointed right back at the yuckapuck that crabs about their favorite company not making the cut, when they have no idea as to the events that led up to that decision being made. Everybody has their bias, which is perfectly :cool:.

I’m coming at this from the standpoint as somebody fairly surprised that the Corps went with HK, given the giant, costly, horrific abortion of the MP-5 sustainment debacle. Think of it this way, if one can: The Corps chose a weapon from a company that they have a VERY good reason not to choose, given the history. It stands to reason that Occam’s Razor may be just as valid as any other cockamamy theory; the thing might be a good platform for its intended role.

Yes, I know how nuts that sounds.

Those are not standard A service wide weapons.

“Those are not standard A service wide weapons.”

And neither will these be.

The Marine Corps strength fluctuates between 130-140,000. About 25% of that number is infantry. Subdivide further into rifle companies and fire teams and you’ll see that the Corps is not buying a whole shitload of these rifles either.

We already know this.

That is not the definition of a standard A weapon.

You probably do. I’m not singling anybody out. It does not, however, read as though “we” know anything of the sort.

What about rail systems that must maintain no shift with a 50,000 to 70,000 round firing schedule when the barrel of the gun lasts 10,000 rounds?

I’m aware the HK outdid the Colt. There isn’t anybody that doesn’t realize this in this thread.

My point is how realistic is this going to be in real life?

How are all the little things like having a “pseudo AR15 like” weapon on the battle field that is not really AR15 based quantified such as parts commonality, optics mounting issues, people trying to change parts in between the two and they don’t fit?

What about the 416 style magazine well and P mags? P mags are in circulation even though they are not the standard magazine, what is going to happen when a soldier attempts to stick one in the HK IAR in the middle of a fight?

Look at it this way, the HK rifle can be adjusted in some areas, but it is doubtful the other rifles can be made any more reliable or suitable. From what I can ascertain HK submitted what amounts to their stock HK416N 16.5’’ variant with a longer rail, M16 bayonet lug and it basically ran like a raped ape.

The only mounts wouldn’t want to run on a 416 would be anything designed to provide a lower 1/3 on an AR15. LT-104/139 mounts, ACOGs, or aimpoints in QRP’s would be fine. The original stock 416 sights are pretty solid, I have a pair.

I’d buy a 416 right now if given the opportunity at the right price, even if it couldn’t take p-mags.