I’m really not a fan of the TR-24 triangle reticle. I’d much prefer a traditional mil-dot type setup for a low-powered optic. There is no “absolute” 1x-magnification and whatever its advantages you shouldn’t confuse it with a red-dot. It doesn’t work that way.
Having owned both the TR-21 and TR-24 there is no functional difference between the two except slightly more light/clarity, slightly better FOV and a better tube in the latter. When I say “slightly” I mean that it wouldn’t make a difference to the overwhelming majority of people even on this board. The notion that they are radically different scopes is overstated. People have their preferences obviously but the real disadvantage to both of these scopes are the lack of reticle options and the current ones suck.
What I did like about the 24 was the more consistent eye-relief, but the nice thing about the M4 with a fully extended buttstock for longer-range precision shots the eye relief times up nicely on the 21. Since that time however I’ve sold both after taking a DMR and a couple of precision shooting classes. It just changed my thinking on how a scope is employed and the TR-21/24 both fall short of that requirement.
No scope can do every job well. The idea with the Accu-Point was that the you get the “best of both worlds” of a red-dot with the advantages of a precision optic. You also get the worst of both worlds. It’s not nearly as fast as a RDS and you don’t get the ability to place your eye wherever you want it like you do with a red-dot which becomes very relevant when you’re shooting non-traditional positions (e.g. rollover prone etc.) though this will be the same with any magnified scope you get, and finally you don’t get the precision of magnification.
For me the main virtue of a magnification is that it allows for greater precision, both the 21 and 24 are at their most precise at their zero distance. The reticle post means that uf you have it zero’d for 100 yards (my typical zero), you’re going to lose that precision rapidly as you move out to 300. Beyond 300 yards I found precision to be atrocious. This means that if you want true precision at 300 yards you have to zero at that distance and then learn your holds closer in. If you’re absolutely never going to shoot beyond 300 yards than it’s perfectly adequate but I don’t know that it’s still the ideal. Honestly if that’s the outside range of your shooting needs, I’d stick with a quality RDS and maybe a magnifier if you’re absolutely certain you need one.
In short IMO you’re better off committing to the advantages of the RDS or magnified scope, understanding their liabilities, and getting the best out of it rather than compromising on everything.
This really left me with two-options: a fixed power combat optic like the ACOG or a variable power mil-dot optic like the Leupold.
For light-weight and simplicity there are few magnified optics that compete as well as the ACOG. I’ve owned two TA-33s (amber triangle in .308 as well as the amber horseshoe in 5.56). These are both excellent optics and though not nearly as fast as an RDS the light-weight and BAC makes them comparable to the 24 at 1x. The horseshoe reticle however has some of the same problems as the 24 reticle post in that precision is not really its strong point. In the end however neither of these were sufficient to my purposes either and so I sold one and traded the other for some training.
At the end of this journey I decided that the best option was a variable power with a mil/mil or moa/moa reticle/adjustment that are externally adjustable. I like the ability to dial in your dope like I do with my bigger scopes as well as the ability to be precise both at close and longer ranges. I think the Leupy CMR2 reticle holds a lot of promise. If the TR-24 had an option for mil-dot it might be acceptable, but the .25MOA clicks and the inability to rapidly change your dope is a distinct downside.