Tax Discrimination

For the lawyer types on here.

Since the tax code taxes different incomes at different rates, and the top sixty percent pays for the bottom forty percent. Couldn’t one argue that they are being discriminated against based on income? Why should one group pay more as a percentage, than any other?

Yes, they are being discriminated against based on income-- by design. It’s called a “progressive” tax rate structure, meaning that as income rises, tax rates progressively raise. As I recall, the policy rationale for a progressive structure is that people at relatively low income levels experience more financial pain from taxes because the portion of their income that goes to necessities (food, shelter, etc.) takes up a larger portion of their overall income, and lessening their tax hit makes life easier.

That’s the policy. Personally, as I get older and make more income, I find myself hating that policy more and more :slight_smile:

The top 1% of income earners make 19% of all the $. They pay 28% of all taxes. The top 25% of income earners pay 47% of all taxes. The top 50% of income earners pay 97% of all taxes. The bottom 10% of income earners pay .04% of taxes. This data is straight from the GAO. Indisputable since the data is taken directly from IRS records. Who says the top income earners don’t pay their fair share?(Obama) The bottom income earners don’t pay THEIR fair share. Translation: Dem. voters for life.

Just like Obama says anyone earning over 250K/yr. will have taxes raised. D*A knows that the majority of Americans(74%) are employed by small businesses. These people generally report their business income on personal income tax statements b/c much easier. So, Obama will raise taxes on the so-called rich. Guess what? They will simply respond by firing/laying off b/c they only look rich on paper. I should say Obama calls them rich even though he knows the profit margin means they are an ordinary income person.

Two words: Flat tax

Two better words:

Head Tax

I’m a big fan of flat/fair taxes as well. I wonder if anyone has ever filed a suit against the IRS based on tax discrimination.

I knew this site had smart people on it. When I see discussion of flat tax rates and the FairTax I know there are intelligent people around. We just need to keep telling our friends, family, associates, and writing/calling our Senators and Reps. When we see b.s. misrepresentation of a flat tax, politely correct them. Just look at the way the Immigration Reform bill was stopped several years ago. BY THE PEOPLE. We can make a difference.

i have even better words:

no taxes

and here’s some more:

fuck taxes

and some more:

teriffs are how the government made money for the first half of this country’s life, it kept them small and efficient, and it encouraged more exporting/less importing- production rather than consumption. now that they have more money than God, they’re not small or efficient, and we consume 1,000,000,000,000.2 times what we produce. it’s not a coincidence.

and some more more:

tax protester.

I haven’t heard of this one before. Can you elaborate?

immigration tax? canada had a “head tax” in their history that they ended up offering repairations for, IIRC.

The bottom 10% of income earners pay .04% of taxes. This data is straight from the GAO. Indisputable since the data is taken directly from IRS records. Who says the top income earners don’t pay their fair share?(Obama) The bottom income earners don’t pay THEIR fair share. Translation: Dem. voters for life.

to me, this makes no sense, why wouldn’t anyone want to climb the ladder to wealth thru their own hard work and dedication towards their personal success. i know several people who successfully, "MADE IT ! (Millionaires)

Kind of a joke. A head tax is a per person tax. Kind of a checkered past, but the concept is simple. How does income affect how much police, defense, roads and such you use. Where else does membership or dues depend on how much you make? If it did, country clubs would be full of bums, who else has time to golf? Go to Vegas and does the ante for poker depend on how much you make?

You’re right. It makes no sense. But it seems there are many people who don’t believe in hard work. Hard work was the way I was raised. Work hard and better yourself. However, not all see it this way. They are happy to get a government handout and live the life this affords them.

I’m a construction contractor. We’ve been doing a bunch of dick repair work with the economic situation… keep-working type work. We just got done with a pretty big structural repair at a “section 8” apartment complex… replacing rotting posts and beams underneath. all day every day, these people are hanging out, watching us work, smoking weed, screaming at each other… anything but working. at lunch today, i sat on my tailgate with my number 1 and listened to him tell me about his ex-wife, who works a part-time security job at $9/hr, lives in section 8 with her live-in unemployed (doesn’t work- as a RULE) boyfriend who literally does nothing but play video games and eat junk food all day. they get food-stamps and get their rent almost paid for. the boyfriend got some kind of $10,000 settlement not too long ago- what did they buy? plasma flat-screen, video games, new computers, home theater system, probably drugs/alcohol… and he says they were hitting him up for help with rent “three weeks later.”

i know this stuff is probably totally normal life for a big chunk of Americans, but i’m rarely exposed to it, and it came up… i just cannot fuckin fathom a life of zero ambition. the breaks can get you, but you fuckin drive-on. i thought i’d make a career in the military- that didn’t work out. got hurt, got out. i’m elligiable for 50-60% disability rating- screw that, i work for a living. when life throws you lemons, you better get a damn pitcher and some sugar. i picked up a hammer and learned how to swing it. and if tomorrow i fall three stories and cripple myself, you can bet i’ll learn computers, or consulting, or something.

get up. drive on.

You should read Atlas Shrugged, it talks about this very thing.

I know how you feel but there has to be some tax, just substantially less of one.
The Fair Tax is the way to go

Atlas Shrugged is an excellent recommendation.

I shudder when I look at what is happening in the US today because the correlations are so strong.

Word!

My opinion is that a progressive tax is unconstitutional.

If everyone is recognized as the same then how do you justify forcing some to pay more than others?

I’m not a lawyer, but being wealthy isn’t a “protected class”… race, ethnicity, religion, color, national origin, age, sex, disability, sexual orientation, etc.

It’s called taxation without representation. If we were all taxed equally, we would all equally feel the pain and taxes would always be low. But politicians know the poor will always vote for them if they promise to “GET” those evil rich.

Get used to it until we can restore the Republic and stop the slow move to Socialist Democracy.