I have one of the “problem” glocks. My G-19 was one of the first several out and has an 03 spring in it. After reading reports and with my own experiences, I quickly determined it did NOT like to eat softer loads. As a reloader, I had dialed in a soft 115 grain load that cycled mt previously owned M&P9 and ended up with several failure to feeds. Upon inspection it was obvious that the slide was not being forced back far enough, as rounds were getting stuck going up the ramp with the slide catching the round in the gap between the case rim and case wall. I’m certain there is a name for this gap but its escaping me at the moment.
My last qualification, we were given some 115gr blazer aluminum rounds to shoot. They shot extremely soft and I remember thinking “oh I’m going to have some ftfs today…” Surprisingly I only ended up with 1, and while I didn’t have time to do a complete inspection, a quick look at the slide position and angle of the round that failed to feed left me confident that the same error had occurred.
There is no question that the recoil spring is heavier. One simply needs to rack the slide back next to any other 9mm to realize that. I have read a vocal few who report that these ftf issues are due to a redesigned extractor and not the spring. While these extractors may be causing some issues in some guns, to dismiss the changes in recoil weight and its effect on feeding ignores the laws of physics.
As a reloader, the solution was simple for me. I knew my gun was 100% at feeding +P duty ammo, so I simply upped my powder charge and moved on with life. My gun has been 100% with this hotter load, and I began to notice an unexpected but very desirable side effect of this gun. With an 03 spring, my gen4 glock 19 shoots hot +P rounds extremely soft and flat. Competition shooters quite often drop their powder charges to achieve faster split times and greater shot on shot accuracy. It seems obvious to me that this is a wonderful “feature” (whether intended by Glock or not) in a self defense or LE application utilizing +P ammo.
I recognize that not everyone has the desire to make their own ammo or purchase +P ammo to practice with. I also recognize that there are people that desire a gun that will shoot absolutely anything they feed their gun, and this gun with this recoil assembly is probably not going to satisfy them. Glock has apparently issued an 04 spring for the glock 19 and an 021 spring for the glock 17. These springs are reported to be lighter and address the issues of cycling softer loads. It is not unexpected that people also report a noticeable increase in felt recoil while shooting +P ammo.
For me, I am very happy with my gen4 g19 with its 03 spring. I realize I may have feeding issues while on the range, but I prefer the extemely low felt recoil shooting self defense ammo. I am not aware of which series springs are currently being shipped with new glocks by default, but I hope the 03 (and 02 if you have a g17) springs are still available for those of us who prefer them.
If it matters, my background is that nof a full time firefighter paramedic and a part time police officer. In Ohio, all officers are trained to the same level whether full time, part time, or auxiliary. I carry my Gen4 Glock 19 with a tlr-1 on duty.