Status report; Gen 4 Glocks

To all

Let me hear everyones recent experiences with the new Gen 4 Glocks - from what I have seen and heard a lot of the problems have been addressed and word has it limited to the first few months of production - the last few I have seen in classes work fine

I am all ears

LAV

Gen 4 g17, test fire date late October, 0-2-1 spring. Put about 300 rounds of federal champion 115gr through it in 2 familiarization range trips, then put 1100 rounds of AE 124gr fmj through it in 2 days for department training. No malfunctions or issues of any kinds. There were 4 other new officers there with me. 1 experienced what appeared to be magazine related malfunctions on one occasion, but hadn’t numbered his mags so we couldn’t confirm. All of the 4 experienced FTEs a few times, but I think most of this could be attributed to a weak grip.

Just this past Tuesday, we had a regular at my work leave his G17 Gen4 with us so we could put as many rounds down range between 4 people. The gun already had roughly 1000rds through her before we started. Between the 4 of us, we were able to put 950 more rounds through her within 9 hour work day using military issued ball and crane issued 9MM 124gr HP. None of us had any stoppages, malfunctions, nor breakages. It basically ran like a top. We didn’t notice any bi recoil changes between the Gen3 and Gen4. We all own G17 gen3s and use them for competition, training, etc. I don’t know about the other guys, but my reloads are faster with the Vickers extended mag release. Then again, I probably have 20000+ runs on it from dry fire practice.

I have one of the “problem” glocks. My G-19 was one of the first several out and has an 03 spring in it. After reading reports and with my own experiences, I quickly determined it did NOT like to eat softer loads. As a reloader, I had dialed in a soft 115 grain load that cycled mt previously owned M&P9 and ended up with several failure to feeds. Upon inspection it was obvious that the slide was not being forced back far enough, as rounds were getting stuck going up the ramp with the slide catching the round in the gap between the case rim and case wall. I’m certain there is a name for this gap but its escaping me at the moment.

My last qualification, we were given some 115gr blazer aluminum rounds to shoot. They shot extremely soft and I remember thinking “oh I’m going to have some ftfs today…” Surprisingly I only ended up with 1, and while I didn’t have time to do a complete inspection, a quick look at the slide position and angle of the round that failed to feed left me confident that the same error had occurred.

There is no question that the recoil spring is heavier. One simply needs to rack the slide back next to any other 9mm to realize that. I have read a vocal few who report that these ftf issues are due to a redesigned extractor and not the spring. While these extractors may be causing some issues in some guns, to dismiss the changes in recoil weight and its effect on feeding ignores the laws of physics.

As a reloader, the solution was simple for me. I knew my gun was 100% at feeding +P duty ammo, so I simply upped my powder charge and moved on with life. My gun has been 100% with this hotter load, and I began to notice an unexpected but very desirable side effect of this gun. With an 03 spring, my gen4 glock 19 shoots hot +P rounds extremely soft and flat. Competition shooters quite often drop their powder charges to achieve faster split times and greater shot on shot accuracy. It seems obvious to me that this is a wonderful “feature” (whether intended by Glock or not) in a self defense or LE application utilizing +P ammo.

I recognize that not everyone has the desire to make their own ammo or purchase +P ammo to practice with. I also recognize that there are people that desire a gun that will shoot absolutely anything they feed their gun, and this gun with this recoil assembly is probably not going to satisfy them. Glock has apparently issued an 04 spring for the glock 19 and an 021 spring for the glock 17. These springs are reported to be lighter and address the issues of cycling softer loads. It is not unexpected that people also report a noticeable increase in felt recoil while shooting +P ammo.

For me, I am very happy with my gen4 g19 with its 03 spring. I realize I may have feeding issues while on the range, but I prefer the extemely low felt recoil shooting self defense ammo. I am not aware of which series springs are currently being shipped with new glocks by default, but I hope the 03 (and 02 if you have a g17) springs are still available for those of us who prefer them.

If it matters, my background is that nof a full time firefighter paramedic and a part time police officer. In Ohio, all officers are trained to the same level whether full time, part time, or auxiliary. I carry my Gen4 Glock 19 with a tlr-1 on duty.

Shot a friend’s brand new gen 4 Glock 17 in a pistol class last weekend. About 500 rounds total with zero malfunctions. Ammo used was 115grs Fiocchi 9mm, which is loaded a little hotter than average, so no problems with a heavier recoil spring.

Some local dept’s we’ve sold on Gen4 9mm’s have been happy with their performance in T&E. These are with guns made after October (and some made in late November).

Email sent with details.

I just posted the results of my 2000 round challenge with a Gen 4 G19. In a nutshell, I like it. I like the grip texture, the changeable backstrap and the magazine release. I ran the gun with the large backstrap and added a set of Warren sights.

The gun was purchased new in August and was only broken apart to make sure everything was where it was supposed to be. No lube, etc was added to the gun, just ran it as it came from the factory. The gun had a total of 2 FTE’s over the course of the challenge. One FTE with a handload and one with a Tula 115fmj with no mag in the gun. We replicated the no mag in the gun FTE 3 more times so I reckon this is to be expected.

The gun has the 03 spring in it but hasn’t shown any issues with a variety of ammo to include WWB, Federal Champion, Tula, Wolf, handloads and Fed Tac.

ETA 1363 rounds of Walmart Federal Champion no issues, 588 rounds of Tula one FTE as stated above.

I’ve been running a Gen4 22 on duty for about two months now. I’ve run about 1500 rds of Winchester Ranger through it. I have a TLR-1 mounted to it and no issues feeding. Even one handed shooting from behind a shield and no hiccups.

Our department is transitioning from SIG 226 (both 9 and .40) to the Gen4 Glock as we bring on new hires at the beginning of next year.

I have a Gen 4 17. I ran it through Ken’s Handgun class in PA this past September. I have had the firearm since spring of 2010 and it has the orginal spring that was shipped out with the first batches. The 01 if you will? I have yet to have any malfunction of any type and I have fired all sorts of weak loads through it as well as hot carry rounds.

My only gripe is that the recoil spring does not seem to like to stay in the little notch on the barrel recess. Sometimes during break downs to clean the rod will completely fall out. I have noticed some wear and tear going on mainly on the underside of the barrel next to the guide rod. No realy noticeable frame wear, but I do only have about 3200 rounds through it thus far since I prefer the Gen 3 19 as my carry and training gun if possible.

I know of the after market recoil adapters for the new change in the slide itself, but is anyone else having the problem where the recess in the barrel and the thin metal backing of the recoil spring don’t really mate up well together? It seems really easy to sway the recoil spring from side to side.

I may have to give the Glockmeister or Lonewolf deals a try to go to a more Gen 3ish feel.

Gents, let’s reserve this thread for first hand experience only. There are plenty of other threads for questions (at this time just post your experience until LAV opens it up for questions) and “my sister’s husband’s third cousin, by marrage said so” posts.

Sir,
I purchased one earlier this year [Gen4 17]. During the first two mags there were issues with feeding. After that, faultless Glock like reliability. Ammo used was my own competition based reloads [124/125 gr FMJ @ 1090fps]. I blamed the reloads for the initial issues. I don’t own it anymore, traded for a HK P-30. The gun was reliable, I traded for other reasons.

I have a 19 with 03 recoil spring (04 not out yet).

I had a couple FTE, FTL in one trip. This was the only trip I did not have the M backstrap on it. People are reporting that, although the smaller grip “feels” better in the hand, they get more muzzle flip. I’m guessing this, combined with being slightly oversprung for light loads (I was shooting Tula and cheap Federal), caused the malfunctions.

My opinion is, the gun isn’t unreliable, it’s just not tuned for target ammo. I’ve yet to hear anyone complain of an issue using defense ammo. I haven’t tried any yet.

That’s good to know. I also had 0 malfunctions in about 100 rounds of Fiocchi. That was also with the M backstrap.

I have an early 19 purchased in July. I’ve run nothing but cheap Wally World Federal and a few boxes of Ranger Ts through it and after roughly 1,500 rounds I haven’t had a single issue with it; no FTFs or FTEs. I did have one piece of empty brass hit me in the face but the following round loaded just fine. I have changed the trigger and trigger bar to a Gen3 G17, installed a Glock - connector, and polished it. I ran this through the LAV Basic Pistol class in Carthage in November and it ran very well.

I run the large back strap on it and that has made reloads slower than my Gen 3 with the Vickers mag release. At this point I’m carrying my Gen3 RTF2 but I’m impressed with the Gen4.

LAV,
I have a 4thGen17 that I used at the “house clearing-active shooter” class you did last year at USTraining center. Since I had lack of faith in it’s reliability for carry gun I set it up as a test bed for the RMR, that way I could test the Gen4 and RMR set up at the same time.
The reliability with the first run of duel recoil springs was nothing short of abysmal. My friend and I will meet up for training sessions on a biweekly basis and usually end upthrough a hundred rounds
or so of Winchester white box when done. I couldn’t get through two mags without a failure to eject and many rounds in the face. I went through the paces with the 02 spring and couldn’t personally discern any difference in spring resistance between the first recoil spring and the 02 version. As suspected the reliability with the 02 spring was just as bad if not worse.
*Even though I’m the first to advise people to leave their Glocks alone this case was an exception because it “was broke and did need fixin” I threw in a Jager aftermarket spring and the reliability issues vanished.
*one issue with the jager spring is the flange at the end is speced out a little too large and rubs the inside of the frame. I then tried the Glockmeister version and found it to be a higher overall quality and is what I recommend anyone with a 4th Gen to get. keep in mind the Glockmeister is captured and the Jager can be broke down to change the spring weight. I’m not sure so anyone who knows please chime in but I think neither of these use the stock oem springs or weights, if someone comes out with that product it would be ideal.
*On a positive note I’ve done some of the best pistol shooting of my life with this set up and have to give some of the credit to the grip being smaller. I have small hands and being able to get my trigger finger directly in front of the trigger allows me to pull the trigger directly to the rear much easier. Every little bit seems to count when it comes to handguns and small hands.
*hope this helped.
Cheers
Hanna
*

I bought my 17 Gen4 in July. So far I’ve put at least 3,000 rounds through it.
Mostly a mix of Ultramax, Brown Bear, Tula and CCI Lawman (mostly Ultramax).
So far no failures whatsoever. Although the trigger is a lot heavier then the Gen 3s.
But I fixed that issue. Also, it has the 02 spring.

Later in this thread a few people mentioned that their Gen4 shoots to the left.
Mine is dead on accurate.

I got an early Gen4 and the spring “locked” after my first day at the range (100 rounds) . Glock replaced the spring and it’s run fine since (500 rounds of reloads)

Fourbits

I have (2) Gen4 19s. One with the glossier slide finish and one with the new matte finish. My primary (the early 19) has about 2500 rounds through it … in about 30 days.

The 03 spring has been working just fine, but I’m now using an 04. The slide lock is easier to use as a slide release with the 04.

When is your new slide release due out? I could really use two.

My G17 Gen 4 was purchased on 8/12/10. In that time I have logged 2178 rounds through it. They have been a mixture of about 1/3 FMJ factory ammo and 2/3 hard cast lead reloads. Yep, it’s the factory barrel. Nope, there is no lead buildup right in front of the throat. Only a little bit of lead near the muzzle and is no worse that other conventionally-rifled handguns I have.

It came with the original spring design and the non-counterbored slide. I suffered two FTEs in the first 359 rounds. I ordered the 02 spring from Glock and proceeded to run a one-day handgun class (550 rounds) without a hitch. I ran the gun through 250 more trouble free rounds when I decided that I had had it with the spring’s front coil getting hung up on the rim of the slide’s hole for the guide rod. While the pistol never locked up and I could always remove and reinstall the slide, getting the recoil spring/guide rod assembly off the slide was a constant pain in the ass and I could not discount the possibility that such an issue could lock the gun up.

So I bought a Glockmeister 17 lb single spring/guide rod assembly and installed it. So far I have run 994 rounds of various weights and velocities, factory and home made, without a single failure of any kind and field stripping the pistol is as easy as it should be.

If I had a pistol with a counterbore on the slide’s guide rod hole, I would have kept the 02 spring since the CB cures the spring hangup problem. But I did not know about that fix until after I bought the GM guide rod and the GM rod/spring works so well and it is so easy to install that I will roll with it from now on.

I also had a trigger job done to it, including the installation of a Scherer 3.5 lb connector to get the trigger to a more manageable 5 lbs.

While the Glockmeister spring assembly uses a non-Glock spring, GM advertises their 17 lb unit to be “factory weight”. I assume they mean G17 Gen 3 factory weight.

Whatever the weight is in reality, it doesn’t matter to me. My pistol runs and runs and eats whatever I feed it and that’s what matters the most IMO.

Gen IV Model 17. Initially, I had a few (three or four incidents) of failure to cycle. SOME of it was me coming off of shooting 1911s (insensitive to limp wristing) but after, maybe, 500 rounds I’ve had ZERO issues with it. I’ve even been using as a training pistol for those who have not fired a pistol before and even diminutive persons shoot it with no issues which is somewhat surprising as it has to be more sensitive to “limp wristing” (though locking the support hand wrist eradicates this - at least for me).

It’s so good I want another…