Springfield Loaded or Kimber Custom II

I am buying a 1911 specifically to work on myself - I have a Wilson and an Ed Brown and that don’t need any upgrading and would prefer not to practice on those in any case.

I would like some opinions on wether a Kimber Custom II or a SA loaded is a better gun to start with. They are both available for about the same price locally. I expect that mostly i would be replacing componant parts, slide stop, thumb safety, sights, etc and then send it off for any frame or barrel modifications (flush cut slide stop) and refinishing.

Thanks for the help, your opinions are appreciated.

SA MC Operator

Get the Springfield.

Go with SA - better warranty and no Swartz safety to mess with.

I’m about to get another 1911 and have all but decided on the SA Operator (vs. a build).

So, as stated: SA.

Thanks all - would an 80 series colt be preferable to either or both of these as a base gun? The 70 series repro is not available in California.

The kimber IIs or 80 series Colts are now where near as good a base 1911 as a Springfield
My other choices would be a 70 series colt repro or a series 1 Kimber

Agreed, series 70 Colt, which you can’t get in California, series 1 Kimber or the Springfield.

Springfield is your choice if you want a new gun. Otherwise a good series 1 kimber can still be purshased used.

Ive have owned a few examples of both. Of the two I would get the Kimber, but would go ahead and spring for the TLE model which gets you front strap checkering and night sights. In my experience the slide to frame and barrel to bushing fit is better on the Kimbers than the SA Loaded models.

There are better guns for the money than Colt IMO as well unless you are going to do a full custom build in which case I would still get a Springfield GI and save the money.

if you’re going to keep it stock, probably the springfield for lifetime warranty. If you’re going to be upgrade crap here and there, the kimber. The kimber has a nicer fit, the barrel looks nicer…for some reason the springfields barrel looks like it’s a MIM even though i don’t think it is.

I own a kimber tle/rl II and a springfield loaded. Like the kimber more.

I can’t speak to the Kimber, but I have owned a Springfield Armory Loaded (Black Stainless) model for right around 3 years now.

It had some teething issues, which in the first 500 rounds or so were annoyingly frequent (and would definitely have kept me from trusting it as a carry/duty/SD/HD weapon) but seemed to fade over the next 500 and now seem to have vanished.
As a hobby pistol, it’s been a lot of fun to own and shoot. I don’t have the high round-count some guys do, though. And it’s still not a duty/carry/HD piece.
On the other hand, within the narrow frame of reference I know, I liked it. Once its initial problems smoothed out, it got to be a very fun shooter and accurate enough that my abilities are by far the limiting factor.

I’d buy it again, all in all, with the caveats above.

1911s can be a little tempermental when they are new. Most production guns require a break in period as the parts wear together.

That can be avoided if you go with a custom gun or take your gun to a trusted gunsmith to get it dehorned and accurized.

I vote Springfield for the reasons already mentioned.