For some reason, new pistol shooters loooooove XDs.
I don’t know what you mean by “feeling”. The way it feels in your hand when you just hold it, or the way it feels when you shoot it? Unfortunately, feelings lie.
With regards to .45 Auto in a carry gun, the more boolits the better. And almost without question, people shoot smaller plastic guns better with 9mm than they do with .45 Auto.
“…there is no appreciable difference in the effectiveness of the 9 mm and the .45 ACP cartridges.” Vincent J. M. Di Maio, GUNSHOT WOUNDS: Practical Aspects of Firearms, Ballistics, and Forensic Techniques SECOND EDITION, Page 150.
Let me start by saying I’ve shoot many makes, models and calibers of hand guns before I settled on the XD 40. XD’s are a great first gun for people just getting into shooting, backstrap safety, striker primed nipple, comfortable grip angle and and the grip width is pretty good for small handed people.
My first handgun was a XD 40 full size 13rd model, which now has around 5,000 rounds. The gun has been nothing but reliable and has eaten everything I’ve put through it. My better half, my mother and sister all love shooting it(mom and sis have smaller hands). The only cons are the slight muzzle flip and the long take up on the first trigger pull(reset is fine). My better half currently keeps the XD 40 in her car/work truck/tool bag(she’s an electrician).
I’ve owned an XDS 45 as a cc for a while. The gun was super reliable but I just didn’t like it. The trigger pull felt longer than the XD 40 and the reset was super long as well. I ended up selling it to my buddy who carries it and replaced it with a S&W Shield 40. I really like the way the Shield handled, very controllable recoil but the trigger sucked. I’ve moved to a Walter PPS 9mm M2 for cc, the trigger is amazing.
I just picked up a M&P 9mm M2.0 last week. I’d say the trigger is very close to the PPS and is a huge improvement over the original m&p. Both my brother(40) and father(45) have the the original M&P’s, brother had an apex kit installed and my father had a local smith work over the trigger. Apex was obviously better than the smith work over but cleaned up the trigger. I do see an M&P 40 m2.0 in my future, but won’t be getting rid of the XD.
As was stated above, a 9mm with appropriate ammo will be just as effective as a .45 ACP for self defense.
Hope my experiences help you make your decision.
I do a lot of hog hunting. I know that’s quite different than CHL world, but, having used both a 9mm and .45 as a side arm, despite what has been said about the comparability of the caliber, I’ve found that with identical shot placement, the 9mm just doesn’t do as well as the .45 with knock down power.
I haven’t settled completely on the XD, it’s just top of my list as of now. I’ve still got 2 months before I’m even of age.
I like the idea of a compact .45, and the grips fit like a glove.
The XD is the only one I’ve listed I haven’t gotten to shoot yet, however I have plenty of experience with glocks, S&W’s, and various other handguns. Not a fan of the glocks safety, nor the finger placement. S&W’s just felt too small for a reliable carry grip. 1911 styles are just simply too large for an “all occasion CHL.”
In terms of aftermarket, I like the idea of crimson trace grips, which don’t seem to have hit the market, or some kind of non profile altering laser sight. I’ve seen a few guide rod lasers but they seem to not stand up to the abuse of use.
Again, I’m not set in stone on the XD, but it definitely peaked my interest over the rest.
Take a pistol class from one of the guys in the BCM Gunfighter ad at the top of the page. After that, I virtually guarantee dreams of XD45s will disappear.
It’s also quite different than the two-legged predator world. “Knock down” power doesn’t exist, even in regards to hunting. Sending something the size of your index finger tip at 900fps won’t knock anything to the ground, even at point blank range.
Do you mean the Glock trigger safety? there are no external manual safeties on Glocks.
You need to rent the XD at a range and shoot it. I’m talking over 100 rounds to start. Really get a baseline feel for it. Put whatever bias you have aside, and find out the pros and cons for the XD on your own. I was in the same boat as you a few years ago, but I was more anti-Glock. I thought the XD was going to be my savior, so I bought an XDM and an XD40c without ever firing them. I had several issues with the XDM, and I ended up hating how the XD compact 40 shot. Now, I won’t ever buy one again. Cost me a lot of money to learn the hard way. I always rent before I buy now. YMMV.
Sound advice here.^^^^^ RENT BEFORE YOU BUY IF POSSIBLE… That saved me some money myself, I had the hots for a Glock21 awhile back, I rented one at a local shop, It spit almost every piece of brass back at me, and that was a real shame… I loved how it shot, It was a very, very, accurate pistol, very soft shooting… I shot it like a house afire, and I’d never shot one before. I loved everything about it. Granted, a new one out of the box may not have had that ejection issue, I don’t know. But, I wasn’t willing to take a chance on it, especially since Apex doesn’t make a extractor for the 21. Very sadly, I handed it back to the guy at the counter…The bright side here is, I was only out a few dollars it cost to rent it out, (the ammo was mine) I figure I saved myself a lot of grief…
Well if you’re dead set on a 45 I would look at these 3 pistols since you didn’t seem to like the others you mentioned:
HK 45C
Sig P320
Walther PPQ45
The only XD that I have shot that I am willing to speak highly of is the XDS in 9mm. For what you get out of the box for the money it isn’t a terrible gun. My only real complaint with it (and this applies to all XD’s I’ve ever shot) is it is begging for a good trigger job. Their triggers are like squeezing mushy over-ripe fruit. Problem is nobody does trigger work on the XD series of pistols except Springfield Custom Shop.
If you want a laser you’re spoiled for choice in 2017. The Crimson Trace grips are bloody brilliant on the S&W M&P’s, 1911’s, Beretta 92’s and Sig22X series. On everything else they’re just kinda “Meh” to me.
The XD’s were great when they were the HS2000 and you could get them for ~$200. Now they’re just overpriced and say “GRIP ZONE” on them.
But my best advice to you is, If you really want a pistol for hog hunting and a pistol for concealed carry then you should really consider getting two guns. A big bore revolver for the hogs and a 9mm for them two legged varmints.
Yep that’s the drawback on them. I have to have an SF or Gen 4 frame with my hands. It’s my second favorite 45 behind the HK45, which sets the bar for ergos and comfort. On top of being stupid accurate.
I want to thank everyone for taking the time to comment. I really do appreciate it.
I want to get this clear really quick: in no way am I saying CHL pistol will be used for hunting. That would be silly.
I was just stating that in my experience, the .45 had noticeably improved stopping experience. That’s just my experience. I also am not comparing hunting to CHL world.
I just really liked the .45 when I carried it, and was hoping to keep it as a CHL caliber for both ease of ammo AND preference it.
I am not opposed whatsoever to a 9mm or .40.
Also, to those saying to try before you buy, I agree 100%.
I’ve done so with the mentioned pistols before, I just haven’t found anyone/anywhere with an XD for me to try. I will definitely try before I buy, I just haven’t found one yet, but thought I’d ask online for those who have carried.
Thank you again for all the responses. Keep em coming. Like I said, no where near set in stone on the XD’s, and love hearing what people have tried and what does and doesn’t work!
I’ll second the thought that the XD isn’t a bad first gun. They’re not great, but they’re not terrible and they come at a decent price if memory serves. If you’re dead set on a smaller gun for carry, you will enjoy shooting 9mm more than .40 or .45, and as the links suggest it’s they’re all pretty equivalent in terms of ‘stopping power.’ Good luck.
I can see why this guy likes that XD Mod 2 .45…it’s a very nice gun, ergonomically speaking. I WISH Glock’s 30 was close to as nice.
That said…I’m trending back to Glock .45’s myself. Currently looking to trade a Walther PPQ .45 for a G21.
And I have had an opposite experience with my daughters XDM 3.8C in 9MM…it has been pretty much flawless for a couple thousand rounds, both with the 19 round and 13 round magazines. But YMMV.
I have only been shooting for 45 years so what do I know?? I have a 3 and 5 inch MOD2 and a XD9 before that. Never had an issue with any of them. I just never liked the way a Glock felt. I’ll agree with the others… Shoot as many brands as you can before deciding and get the nine for capacity.
For a new shooter, I’d say a g19. Easy to conceal, reliable, cheap practice, and good resale, and huge aftermarket… it’s the pistol equivalent of a colt ar. Practice and find out what you need in a pistol.
Chances are you’ll stick with it. If you find you need something else, you won’t have an issue offloading it and won’t be wondering about the glock down the road.
As for caliber, be sure to buy a good round with 9mm. It’s more ammo critical than other cals, but when youre using hst or gold dots, caliber is pretty irrelevant.