Spray and Pray

Its been a long time since I heard this term thrown around but just today on another forum I frequent, a member brought it up as an arguement against the LEO/Military use of high capacity pistols.

My question to the members of M4Carbine is this…

In your experiences has the popularity of high capacity magazines either in Modern Pistols or Rifle/Carbines attributed to the “Spray and Pray” practice in combat scenarios?

I would really like to hear the observations from any who have served recently in Iraq/Afghanistan.

Lets not make this a 9mm VS .45 debate…which is what prompted the arguement at the other site.

Interesting question! I have heard this before and always thought it was an excuse for poor training or a red herring to divert attention from poor training.

I suppose it is possible that someone would smash the trigger until they had just a few rounds less and then somehow realize that they were almost out of ammo and think “I need to make these last 3 shots count because I missed with the first 15.” However, to me, it seems more likely that someone like that would more likely continued “spraying” to the very last shot.

I think those who are under trained and yank the trigger until their weapon is empty will do so regardless of capacity. Under trained people perform like under trained people whether they have a 5 shot revolver, a 1911, or a Glock with a 33 round magazine.

Those who practice to control the trigger and align the sights effectively will get better hits, not because of capacity but because of training.

One of the maxim’s the average warfighter is trained under (or should be!) is “Fire without maneuver is wasted ammunition. Maneuver without fire is suicide.” I’m uncertain as to how often the LE community covers movement with a couple of hundred rounds of automatic fire, given that their concern over schwacking those not directly involved in the gunfight is generally far greater.

We teach our students that every round deserves a sight picture. All that means is that, even when they are engaged in “acoustic suppression,” they are still aiming. That footage you see of Marines in Hue shooting around corners without looking…I’ve only seen that done by our Iraqi counterparts, these days. My guys were behind their sights, taking cover/concealment when necessary, and putting rounds in the direction they needed to go. That it may have been at a high rate is in no way inappropriate

I’m currently doing a training evolution aboard Ft Stewart. During the night shoot (training the unit is required to do before we release the issue of PEQ-16As to them) 12 of our 34 students were pressing rounds, on average, every 3/4 of a second, standing and dinging steel 8 times out of 10 @ just under 200m. While there’s folks I know that can match or surpass that, these were kids that hadn’t done any MFAL training since School of Infantry. Hardly a “spray and pray” standard, though to be honest and humble, I’m an awesome instructor. :smiley:

Sounds to me like the folks you were arguing with have trouble defining the boundaries of what they want to argue about.

Why pray? You will be wasting valuable energy while trying to focus on what you are doing. You can pray later for your sins.

Do you find this consistent with pistol training also, or is your experience mainly with rifles/carbines? I mainly see the “spraying and praying” in the hobby shooter realm, and not in the military. We were always given a cetain amount of rounds per stage in training, so you really had to be a maniac/fool to throw any of them away with wild shooting.

Just a few comments-

I see Spray and Pray as relating to full auto fire, normally with military rifles obviously.

With the pistol, your average shooter has a hard enough time learning to shoot fast with trigger reset. I think they end up with something like a fast point shoot with no sight picture. More like “Point and Pray.”

I think that says it. Platform isn’t really relevant.

The following is the post in unedited form…which prompted me to start this thread. As I stated in my first post this all started out as one of those 9mm VS .45 ACP threads.
My intention is to strictly address his statement that High Capacity seems to encourage spray and pray.

Fact of the matter is, when given a choice, by hook or by crook, professional military folks are going back to the 1911 due to the fact it always works and is a consistent one shot show stopper. If you could do an equipment check on Special forces units, and some of the airborne units as they enter the sandbox, I would guess that 30% or more have some how gotten their hands on a 1911 for their personal side arm.The choice for switching to the 9mm berreta 92F was based on the theory that it would be easier and more economical way to train the average troop in pistolmanship. The reality is with proper training, the average “snuffy” can be trained quite readily on the 1911. On paper there does not seem to be a real discrepancy but in the real world there is absolutely no comparison. And as to high capacity, it does seem to encourage “spray and pray” during an emergency. As a well known gun pundit, Mr Cooper once said “nobody has ever been killed by a loud noise”.

There are some holes in the logic of that post.

  1. It assumes that capacity is the difference between the 1911 and the M9 that reduces or improves shooter performance. I would maintain that it is most likely the trigger and ergos of the 1911 that improve shooter performance.

  2. I would venture a guess that there is also quite a training difference between the units that are able to choose 1911s and those that are stuck with the M9. This comparison is akin to someone comparing me shooting a 1911 to Ernest Langdon with a Beretta 92 and concluding that the Beretta is obviously the better platform. Ernest would smoke me with the Beretta because he has trained to be as efficient as possible with one.

So I still maintain that this is a training issue on which capacity has little or no effect.

i know you want to stay away from that part of the argument, but i am reminded of an old and wise saying…

don’t argue with idiots…they’ll drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.

I think where the real issue comes in play is with this persons information. I remember this rhetoric being thrown around alot back in the mid 80’s.
I won’t ever say anything bad about men such as Colonel Jeff Cooper, Massad Ayoob etc… But doesn’t this posters information sound like it was taken directly out of old Guns and Ammo articles?

Agreed.

“Spay and Pray Fire” = “Negligent/Indiscriminate Fire” in my book. Anyone ever using it will be jailed and sued, even in a combat zone. Wasting ammo in that manner if extremely foolish. Indiscriminate Fire, even more foolish. Nothing beats accurately aimed fire, unless a Chinese Human wave is coming at you, then use a mini gun…Accurately.

AFA LEOs go, it seems it fairly common for them to run their gun to slidelock w/ very few or marginal hits

or on the other hand you hear of 2 or 3 officers shooting a guy 24 times etc also

so…

There are a crap load of officer involved shootings where 2 or more officers fire 50 or more rounds, and the BG is only hit 2 or 3 times. The one that comes to mind is the shoot in NY where the suspected BG was shot on his wedding day, in a moving vehicle, where over 80 rounds were fired, and he was only hit a few times. Lucky for most bystanders, the natural instinct was to dive for cover.

well said !!!

“pistolmanship”???

Who wrote that, Farnam?

Here’s the thing:

When confronted with a lethal threat the dominant human instinct is to point a weapon in the direction of the threat and, to borrow a phrase, “jerk the piss” out of the trigger as fast as humanly possible.

This is especially true when one pops up on you unexpectedly as it does for most LE officers. The majority of the time they are minding their own business when some assclown starts trying to kill them. Most police officers are not meat-eating, combat hardened gunfighters.

Pushing through the fear response to properly execute the fundamentals does not come naturally.

Yes, there are a lot of shootings that have lots of shots fired for only a relatively small number of hits…

…but you have to consider the dynamics of a gunfight. They usually happen in low light, and everybody’s moving. Those who have cover generally try to use it. Adding a vehicle to the mix makes things even more difficult than it ordinarily is.

Accuracy under gunfight conditions is no small feat.