For some reason I really want a p7m8; I sold one many years ago because at the time, I felt the capacity was lacking.
With the advances in 9mm, I am rethinking that choice.
Are there statistics that show the average shots fired in a civilian defense situation?
(I specify as I know that there are lots of Law enforcement that I would imagine have different needs)
I would imagine situations like gas station, downtown areas, across state traveling and day-day in a fairly safe area
( I am not looking to crash a meth house, or serve warrants)
I much as I would think a double stack would be nice, I wouldn’t imagine firing 15 rounds in my perceived threat levels…
But that’s why I humbly ask;
Check out the websites, podcasts, and posts of noted experts Claude Werner and Tom Givens. Both cover and quantify citizen uses of firearms in self defense and their related variables exceptionally well. There are other sources too, but both are widely regarded as leaders on the topic.
There is no “average”, just watch the news. Everything is going to crap everywhere. Personally I don’t leave the house with less than 11 rounds (G26). More often than not it’s something with a 15 round mag, 9 rounds just doesn’t sound like that many for that kind of weight (P7). Me and my wife shoot a lot of fun shoots / league shoots around here and she shoots her Shield and I shoot the G26. Even with only 3 targets to engage that capacity goes quick. You also have to figure under extreme stress you may miss. In fact you may miss a lot.
I’m sure stats can be found with the DOJ or FBI, maybe Ayoob files etc… What the average is anymore just isn’t going to hold true, too much mental illness, criminals in groups or even excited delirium. Not to mention terrorists.
I carry the gun that conceals well with my wardrobe and is not so cumbersome that I avoid carrying it.
Ammo capacity is not a factor, because a low capacity gun is better than no gun at all.
And aside from LE serving warrants, I bet that my lifestyle puts me in parts of town/situations that would make me far more likely to need a gun than the majority of the family-oriented M4C members.
I prefer a high capacity weapon, but for carry as a civilian or off duty, I would feel completely comfortable carrying a single stack 9mm with a single or double mag holder.
This is stolen from a friend at LAPD. He says expect two bad guys, missing 75% of your shots fired and the idea that pistol calibers are terrible people stoppers. So even if you hit you may have to fire a lot to change the suspects mindset. if you have a 6 shot .380 how will you fare? His minimum carry was a Glock 26 with +2 extension and a G17 or 19 mag as backup.
If you hang around gun boards, gun guys, LE folks, etc, you’ll see a lot of the same stuff from credible sources come up over and over. The themes are:
-Handguns are weak and ineffective as a general rule, it may take many COM/high COM hits and a little time to stop an attacker, only disabling the CNS is a guarantee
-Typical hit rates for OIS and private citizen self defense seem to run about 20%, give or take. Maybe even slightly higher for the private citizens given the different nature of typical encounters
-One or, more likely, both parties will be moving and/or behind cover or concealment
-The matter will probably be settled, one way or the other, with what is in the gun at the time (for private citizens reloads in self defense seem quite rare)
-That said, rule of 3’s says that many/most private citizen defense handgun uses in public will be within 3 yards, 3 seconds, 3 rounds
-Best as we can tell, in the majority of defensive gun uses, no shots are fired. Often when shots are fired nobody is hit, and about 80% of those shot by a handgun survive
Edited to add:
-Most defensive gun uses by private citizens do happen in low light or no light or otherwise reduced visibility, night sights are recommended
First - a reference point…
My day job is as a professor (NOT your typical lib, btw). I teach Forensics, with emphasis on ‘death analysis’. I consult around the state, and give workshops to local LEOs. While not an active operator by any means - I have talked to many who are/were, and I’ve been reading anecdotal and scientific AARs for close to 40 years.
Having said that - I don’t leave the house with less than a g26 with 16 rounds in it, and 2 x 12 reloads for a total of 40 rounds of 124 +P. Actually - that is what I carry all the time I’m around the house. Preferred load out is a g17 with 2 x 17 reloads on me and more nearby or in the car. YMMV
Regarding the OPs specific question, I too have seen and heard plenty of knowledgeable individuals refer to the “rule of 3’s”. It makes sense. Most defensive stories that are shared go something like this. BG acts in a manner that warrants force. Good Guy pulls gun (sometimes fires, sometimes doesn’t), BG is stopped or runs away. Most criminals will choose to pack it in when confronted by the barrel of a gun. They may be stupid and have no regard for common decency, but are smart enough to know it’s no fun being shot.
This is not an easy Q to answer. On the surface it should be, but it’s not. My rule is to make sure I have choices so that I have no excuse not to CCW in all places it’s legal. If one goes far enough into all that you could possibly need to be most prepared, you’ll end up with an entire Bat Belt of stuff at some point. Some have fewer choices in terms of what they can wear, etc. All has to be factored in. I’m self employed, so I can generally dress as I wish, which means I can dress around what I CCW vs being forced to CCW what I’m wearing forces me to CCW.
My opinion, a store owner in a high crime area might have a different set up than a guy in the very low crime burb who’s job is also of a low risk nature.
How do you dress? Where do you go? What’s your expectations? Do you want to be prepared for worst case scenarios, or what most likely to happen in your given situation?
I did ask that Q in another thread in a round about way regarding .357 rnds for medium sized animals that could be dangerous, with gators in mind as well as hogs, etc. I figured I’d dedicate my .357 wheel gun to my hiking out of the way places in FL gun. Never shot a gator. I’m just guessing, but I’d think deep penetraters as was recommend in the thread I started would be the best choice. I’d think 10mm would be a good choice with the right load, but I don’t have one.
I’m trying really hard to not jump the shark with yet another Howdy Beretta 93R reference.
It’s just so damn versatile. There are countless threads where it would work.
Speaking of single stacks, something I am very unfamiliar with, aside from single stack 9mms and .45’s (1911’s), is there such a beast as a single stack 10mm? That would be interesting. If you’re going to give up capacity, may as well get some power in exchange.
The Gator shows shoot them in the brain with .22LR. Back to shot placement.
They key as Euro eluded to, is to carry what you will actually carry. 123 degrees in PHX the other day, the shield got the call to duty. Often times I grab the j frame. It would be nice if it were 72 degrees and more cover were easily worn, but it’s not so carry something. I use the extended grip in my shield.
Follow Skintop’s advice and search out the data from Tom Givens and Claude Werner. As far as what and how much to carry, you have to make that decision for yourself. If a person tells me a single stack subcompact with no reload or a j frame with no speed strip or speed loader is what they’ve chosen based on their needs, I won’t argue with them.
Problem is, I can’t predict what I’m going to eat for lunch on any given day, much less what I may or may not need for self defense in a given location. I shoot compact and full size double stack semi autos better than subs, snubs, and single stacks, I don’t find the larger guns to be problematic to carry and conceal, so that’s what I carry with two reloads.
Civilian self-defense shootings are like car crashes. There are similar themes yet each is it’s own snowflake.
Lets start at the point where avoidance has failed and your in fear of life:
If the BG really doesn’t want to get shot they take off upon presentation/getting shot at/getting hit. With any gun at all.
If the BG (BG’s) are willing to stick it out, and the defender is willing to stick it out, then folks often shoot until their guns run dry. The one who runs out first usually runs away, and often (not always of course) the person with ammo left gives chase and keeps shooting until empty.
After belligerents have parted ways they assess themselves and whats done is done. Off to make phone calls, to the hospital, or to the morgue. Unless someone got a spine or head shot. Those can drop a person right away.
My advice, in order:
Don’t get shot
Keep moving/find cover (see #1)
Get your gun out quick once your spidey sense says, “oh shit” if not before
Shoot accurately
Recognize that that having your gun run dry while defending your life is as bad as it sounds
Additional tips! - The caliber of your pistol?..almost certainty won’t matter. The brand of bullet you use? Almost certainly won’t matter.
Agreed. Everyone on the internet seems to carry a G19. But… If you look at gun sales Shields, LCPs, BG380s, 442s are what are selling in the last 10 years during the “concealed carry revolution.” My point is----you have to weigh your life and risk level and how much risk you’re willing to accept. I ALWAYS carry, sometimes a FNS9C/G26, but sometimes a BG380 or 442. I understand the risk when doing so and accept it.