Scope vs. Red Dot (video drill)

Tactical Gear Optics & Mounts
1

I am currently in the market for a low powered variable and found this video to be relatively eye opening. Looks like a little practice with the scope can net some pretty quick kills at 10 yards on 3 power.

I had my mind set on a 1x4 but now I may be looking for some 2x7, 2x8, 2x10.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7YmIioKk9_E&feature=youtube_gdata_player

Sent with a Gen 2 Nexus 7

2

I have to wonder how the scope shown in that video would have performed, compared to the red dot, in that same drill under low light conditions.

3

I’ve had to kill dudes inside enclosures with a 3-9x, and it sucks.
There is a reason that the folks that do these things professionally and frequently use 1x optics for the task,

In daylight, from conventional positions, in good conditions, I can make a 3-4x work o.k. Introduce lighting issues, head placement issues, moving targets, movement while shooting, and surgical speed requirement, and the mid power optics fall off rapidly. Add to that the weight, bulk, add relative fragility of mid power optics, and the scale further slides.

Sent from my VS980 4G using Tapatalk

4

I got to the part where the one guy finished balancing the gun on a chair. I stopped watching at that point… Anyone that wears pants like that and shoots a bushmaster and RRA to perform a “scope vs red dot” review shouldn’t be taken seriously.

Edit: I agrees with F2S…

5

I can’t watch that dude either.

6
    1. If you’re deer hunting no harm no foul. For two way ranges, the scenarios F2S outlines and dangerous game the rules change.
7

There are too many “data points” in that video for me. I made it to where he said “Tactical Doodle”…

8

You can kind of do the Bindon Aiming Concept with a regular 3x scope but it is funky. Would definitely not be my first choice (unless someone gave me a Nightforce 2.5-10X then I would happily deal with it).

9

Even an acog put a reddot on top.

10

Or close the front cover if you have one.

11

Plenty of test have shown this to be ineffective for anything more than getting shooters comfortable with keeping both eyes open.

12
  1. Clicked on link
  2. Saw Nutnfancy, closed window.

I think the concept is very interesting and very applicable to me, but I just can’t watch that guy.

13

I did not realize how bad the POI shift was on this until a few years back. I was a noob to RDS then and it only took a few drills to prove it to me!