SCAR vs ACR? What would you choose?

So I just read an article in the latest Tactical Operator magazine where they were comparing the FN SCAR to the Bushmaster ACR. They compared multiple aspects of the guns and performance etc., and at the end of the article they chose the ACR over the SCAR. I was a little surprised by that outcome, but they did have a few good points (reciprocating vs non-reciprocating bolt, ease of caliber change etc).

The people on this forum seem to be extremely knowledgeable, so I would love to know, which rifle do you think is better?

Thanks!

An AR15

Since neither is an AR you would probably be better off asking your question in the Other Assault Rifles forum.

Sorry if I posted this in the wrong forum… Moderators feel free to move this post to the Other Assult Rifles forum.

And don’t get me wrong, I love DI guns and own multiple. I agree that they have many more advantages than a gas piston system. That article just got me curious and I was simply wondering which gun was better between the SCAR and the ACR.

Didn’t mean to come across rude. I just don’t see any advantage to either over an AR

SCAR. Lighter, and fits me better.

The SCAR feels cheap to me, mainly because of the stock and I don’t like the limited amount of rail / forearm length.

OTOH, the M4 barrel profile and 1/9 twist on the ACR is a mistake too. I do like the ergos and adaptability of the acr though.

Sent from my Droid using Tapatalk

…interesting, while I can see going with an AR-15 over said weapons, as that’s what I did, saying you don’t see any advantages seems to leave you blind.

Oh by the way, I’d get the SCAR if just for the simple reason the US Military is using it. If the Mk17 gets adopted, it may be a more stable platform when it comes to support and such. One of the reasons we all like our ARs.

I’ll rephrase “any advantage worth the money”

From those two, FN for sure. No knock-off :smiley:

But, i personally don’t like them. It’s just too bulky.

I’d rather have well made piston AR. HK :cool:

I consider the ergonomics to be a pretty big upgrade: ambi bolt catch/release and ambi mag catch/release seem like a solid feature to have. The charging handle is also better located, but it’s not that big of an issue.

That being said, unless I get some significant range time with the ACR or SCAR, I don’t have the first-hand experience to say much else.

-B

the SCAR can be had for the same or less than some high end, similarly equipped ARs like a noveske or KAC. (see grant’s ‘SCAR group buy’ thread).
so, the question becomes reversed - does a top-end AR offer an advantage over the SCAR that’s worth the money?

between a SCAR and ACR, i picked the SCAR as i trust FN’s experience in military weapons designer/manufacturing more than the makers of the ACR.

Aftermarket options? Tried and tested for over 40 years? Combat proven?

I’d have to go with the SCAR. The weight is reasonably light, comparable to an M4. I personally like the ergonomics of the weapon, and the reciprocating charging handle doesn’t bother me (although I’ve watched my dad get his thumb jacked twice by my SCAR 17 :lol:). It’s well engineered IMO and everyone knows about the extensive testing and development of the weapon system with SOCOM. Not be mention it’s seen combat, unlike the ACR (to my knowledge at least).

I lost a lot of interest in the Masada once it became the ACR. I’ve never been a fan of Bushmaster, who managed to screw up the ACR just like anything else they touch. Hopefully the Remington version will show more promise in the military trials.

I’d pick the SCAR. Been tested for a long time and the bugs have been worked out. The ACR, not so much.

An aftermarket is slowly but surely forming for the SCAR. FN has already developed a rail extension for it, as have a few 3rd parties. So those people who don’t like the short rail have the option for something longer. Although the amount of rails available for the SCAR are obviously nothing close to the AR, the argument about the rail being too short is no longer really valid IMO.

The scar is obviously a much better choice because of the manufacturers reputation.

I have no experience with the scar system, but that left sided reciprocating charging handle is not on my list of requirements.

Putting the handle itself on the right side destroys the purpose.

So that leaves me with the ACR, which is made by a company that can’t even get an ar15 right.

So I guess I choose a good quality ar15.:wink:

aftermarket options for the SCAR are becoming available faster than they did for the AR when it was first introduced. the SCAR already comes with standard features that would be aftermarket on an AR. my only wish was for an extended handguard, and that has already been met.
while the basic AR design has been tried and tested, you can’t say the same for the manufacturers. not all of them have been around that long.
combat proven? takes time.

:lol::lol::lol:

So true. Now I’m waiting for all the incoming Bushmaster fan-boys to flame us :smiley:

I like the ergonomics and feel of the ACR better than the SCAR, I just wish Bushmaster didn’t take it over. When it comes to choosing between a rifle from FNH or Bushmaster, there really is no comparison -FN all the way.

I have heard that Remington makes a version of the ACR for LEO and Military only that is much higher quality than the Bushmaster civi version of the ACR. Is that true? If so, will they ever open that version up to the civilian market?