Scar 17

What barrel length should i cut the barrel down to?. the stock barrel is just too long

13" is the SOCOM CQC length. Certainly wouldn’t go any shorter than that (for the same reasons Crane/SOCOM chose 13").

After running the SCAR17 through an EAG Tactical class a couple of weeks ago (3 days, 1200 rounds), I find the 16" barrel to be very handy and not at all cumbersome. It’s the first 16" gun I’ve owned in a while and don’t plan to change it.

Stephen

Stephen,

Will the AAC Miter mount on the civilian 17s muzzle just like on the Mk17? I don’t want to have to fabricate some spacer or something.

Yep. The only difference between the SCAR 17S and the SCAR 17 Standard issued to SOCOM is the group therapy setting on the selector.

Well, that’s not entirely true. I believe the 17 Standard barrel is an even 16" while the 17S has a 16.5" barrel.

Stephen

I am thinking about going with the 13" barrel. How long is the barrel with the AAC flashhider mounted?

I’ve read that the .308 round really needs a min barrel length of 16inches to perform as designed. Have any of you seen a noticeable diminishment from a 13inch barrel?

If I get one, I’m going to perm attach the factory PWS brake to get it back to an overall length of 16". So the threaded barrel will likely be around 14".

I’ve read that the .308 round really needs a min barrel length of 16inches to perform as designed. Have any of you seen a noticeable diminishment from a 13inch barrel?

At usual 7.62 rifle ranges that’s the case. FN has been very clear that 13" CQC barrel is specifically designed FOR CQC situations and the occaisonal scenario where a soldier would have to engage a threat attempting to escape/retreat/pull back from a CQC situation. Long story short: 13" barrel reduces the typical effective range of the 7.62 to 5.56-esque levels (generally considered to no more than 300 yards).

So why do the CQC version at all? Two damn good reasons: 1. It allows guns the military has already bought to be rapidly reconfigured to a different mission at minimal cost and 2. At CQC ranges, a 7.62 even coming from a 13" barrel will strike a target with considerably more force than ANY 5.56, making it an ideal selection for troops engaging threats in body armor or who are willing to take the recoil/report penalty for additional destructive force.

So while going to the 13" barrel drastically reduces the useful range of the 7.62, there are still some real benefits to be reaped within it’s reduced effective range.

They’ve been known to have some pretty good accuracy out of that 16inch barrel, something you’d be sacrificing by bringing it down to 13. Why not go for an AR SBR if you’re looking for something that short?

They’ve been known to have some pretty good accuracy out of that 16inch barrel, something you’d be sacrificing by bringing it down to 13.

What makes you think that? In point of fact, all things being equal: shorter barrels tend to yield BETTER accuracy than longer ones because they are more stable. The price of barrel shortening is solely in ballistic force, which most commonly results in a reduction of effective range, not accuracy.

If you listen to the KAC guys explain why they chose the barrel lengths they did for the SR25, they point out exactly this.

Why not go for an AR SBR if you’re looking for something that short?

I literally explained exactly that above. Did you not read my entire post?

None of my input was directed towards you, it was intended for the OP.

None of my input was directed towards you, it was intended for the OP.

Ah, that makes a lot more sense then.

Still, he wouldn’t be giving up accuracy by chopping his barrel (assuming the cut and re-crown is done properly).

Having used all three barrel lengths in factory trim I can safely say that 16" is the way to go for 7.62 unsuppressed. The reduction in dust getting kicked up is worth it alone but it’s also much more shootable. If you have to have a shorty just go with the 13" like the USGI barrel.