S&W Shield 9mm Durability

How many rounds have your fired through your 9mm S&W Shield? 2,000? 3,000? 5,000? What issues have you had or have you had no issues at all? How much shooting experience do you have and what kind of accuracy do you see at 25 yards?

I’ve fired a few .40 caliber Shields owned by friends, but I don’t own a Shield. I get questions from students and past students about the durability of the Shield 9mm and would appreciate input. If I purchased one tomorrow and fired 300 rounds through it, I would not be in a position to offer an informed opinion.

I would like to hear your personal experiences please and not something you read on the internet or heard in the local gun shop.

Just broke 2500 at my last range trip based on my own ammo consumption. I am a CCW instructor (whatever that’s worth these days) and have loaned it out to a countless number of students to try in/post class as well as friends giving her a go. I would say in all reality I’m likely north of 3500 down the pipe, and not a single stoppage that I can recall. Accuracy is as good as I can do which is consistent A zone hits at 25 and beyond. Have shot it to 50 & 75 on an IPSC with a little elevation adjustment cover up.
Manufacture date of January of 2013 prior to the trigger recall and the G43 which I wanted bad until I shot it. No mods other than an Ameriglo HD front sight and a self stippling job. Rotation of two 7 rd, and one 8 round magazines.
I consider it reliable to the point that it splits EDC time based on attire with a G19. It just does the single stack 9 concealment gun so well. Always thought this video was funny as he produces parts for the glock but sides with the shield.

https://youtu.be/EdYH2M7CJN4

The trigger bite issue he describes is what kept me from getting rid of my Shield for the G43. Honestly if it suits your needs and your looking to fill in a gap or need in this type of firearm I’d say look no further.
Hope this helps.

I shot two range rental Shields yesterday for the first time.

Both had an issue that the slide release took emenace force to drop the slide. Almost like there was something stuck. They both seemed kind of have some rattle compared to the G43 I shot. I don’t know if they are like that new or they just had way more rounds on them compared to the G43. If your looking for a carry gun, the 43 was noticeably smaller.

Skintop has a good thread about the Shield.

The slide stop is hard on mine too, I have my gf rack the slide during reloads.

I have a few thousand (less than 3 I think, may be more) rounds through it. 100% reliable. Can’t comment on accuracy as I only tried for groups a few times and could not deliver (my fault). It was around 9" at 25yds, I’ll try again next time out.

I have shot a full mag into a group covered by a fist at 7 yds, .5 sec splits. The gun is accurate enough for sd, but I wouldn’t try for a headshot at 25 without more practice.

My experience: I shoot a bit, I typically get 4" groups at 25yds, but I’m beginning to think it’s my reloads. I’ve shot sub 3" groups at 25yds, this being with my mp40fs. I haven’t been consistent going to matches, but I’m ussually ranking with c class shooters. F.a.s.t test is always under 6 sec.

I have the 9mm Shield that I’ve run around 6k rounds through right now (124g 5.2gr power pistol) I don’t know the “accuracy” at 25 yards, but I normally start at 15 then move the 20 and 25yards at the plate rack. It’s not a guaranteed hit every shot but it’s 85% or so at 20 and 25. As for experience I suppose I’ve owned somewhere around 150 pistols and have been shooting pistols since 1980.

A side not, the 100yd gong is pretty easy to hit with the shield also.

I’ve had a handful of failures where I’ve screwed up my OAL, for whatever reason my shield requires a shorter length than any of my other 9mm’s so I’ve started loading all my 9’s to fit the shield.

BTW it’s a slide stop, not release.

It’s a release to those trained to use it as such.

//youtu.be/acnXCTb6cT0

Hit that edge of the slide stop with very fine sandpaper, or an emory board. Fixes the hard to release slide stop issue in 2 minutes instead of waiting 2K+ rounds for it to wear.

I Have no desire to run my carry gun super hard to the point of failure. I like to buy them, run them 300 rounds or so and hopefully no malfunctions to confirm reliability. Then I run a couple boxes of AMMO every few months or so make sure it’s running well.

I don’t want to run that gun to failure and figure that out when I need it.

It’s cool to see what abuse these carry guns can take though. Glad folks are running them to test the limits.

PB

NYPD tested the Shield 9 and it passed their tests. I believe it’s at least 10K rounds of duty ammo, which is Speer Gold Dot 124 gr +P HP.

Bud’s Gun Shop has the Shield 9mm listed for $329 shipped. I ordered one and will put it through it’s paces when it arrives.

I am at or just slightly above 2000 rounds on my Shield-9 (don’t have my log book close by). When I first got the gun the slide stop/release was super tight. After about 500 rounds it has loosened up.

I have not shot it for groups but I can hit 5 inch plates at 21 yards consistently (I am not a great pistol shooter).

The only issues I have had are user induced. I ride the slide stop and prevent lock-back on an empty mag with most of my pistols except my G19 and 1911. This came about when I started using "thumbs forward grip with the purchase of my G19. It is something I am training to remedy. Harder than you think once you have learned the muscle memory…

I picked up my brand new Shield at the local FFL last night. Notice anything missing?

The magazine.

But I’m assuming there’s something else.

The drop safety is missing from the trigger assembly. I contacted S&W Customer Service and the CS representative e-mailed me a Fed Ex shipping label. It is scheduled for pickup today.

I will post updates.

That’s the special gunslinger version.

Saw that and wondered if it was possibly a new trigger style. Bit scary it got shipped out that way. Lots of folks would not have noticed…

Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk

I have 3897 rounds exactly through my 9Mm. No failures. I am a 37 year concealed carry old guy with the eyes to prove it now. 75% accurate at 25 yards, still deadly within 25 feet.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-N910A using Tapatalk

Since my last post about my 9mm Shield, I have put 1K rounds exactly through it over the course of three range sessions inthe last 3 weeks or so. All of them were trouble free with one cleaning between session #2 and #3. Ammo was a mix of cheap range fodder…Tula, Fed. Aluminum case, Perfecta brass case, and my own handloaded plinking rounds (115 RN xtremes w/4.5 gr of HP-38)

Prior to that (I have owned the pistol since April), I had about 400 trouble free factory rounds through it, and another 200 or so handloads that mostly ran trouble free, with the exception of a small lightly powered batch I made that gave me a few stove pipes.

I am shooting this gun A LOT better now that I have taken it, and only it to the range and practiced with it heavily the last few weeks. It took some getting used to after shooting 1911’s (and not that well with those to begin with LOL) my entire adult life.

I briefly considered parting ways with it because of how poorly I shot. I will say, that thought is 100% gone now, it’s a keeper. But it’s a gun I do feel like I need to shoot a lot to stay proficient with.

Great thread. Thanks for the information. I just snagged one of these yesterday so that I beat the Post Hitlary price triple or quadruple. I have a few thousand rounds through the .40 version and love it.

So, can anyone recommend a a good OWB holster??? I live where it’s too hot for me to do an IWB. It’s only one layer of clothing 9-10 months a year, so I cannot have an IWB and gun on the bare skin. OWB only unless you guys have found something that works with only one shirt worn over.