for those of you who do, what are you guys using for dedicated rescue knives, and whats your opinion?
i’ve been on the hunt for a few months- albeit sort of half-assedly- for a dedicated rescue knife, but i’m not finding the right combination of attributes. my ideal rescue knife would have a beefy, narrow grind on a slightly recurve blade, full “curtain” style serrations (versus aggressive spiky serrations), auto folder or fixed blade (redundant one-hand operation), rounded tip- versus blunt, and be from a GOOD quality manufacturer. brighter, non-tactical colors preferred, but not necessary (paint!).
as to my application- emergency cutting of 6-12mm poly/nylon rope and tubular webbing, mostly, under load and likely against clothing/skin. general cutting of random shit will remain within the domain of my current all-purpose knife.
My time as a Paramedic dates back to the introduction of gauze, and prior to Mr. Emerson’s sale of knives. Back then, everyone carried a Buck 110 Folding Hunter.
the budget is very flexible. it’s a potentially life-saving device, i’ll spend whatever i need to to get something good. i’d originally figured since it’s an emergency-only thing, cheap was probably the way to go… but having broken plastic-handled cheap gerbers in the past, i reconsidered. i don’t want to be hung up with 6mm cordalette trying to cut through my or my partner’s finger/arm/leg/neck only to discover my knife broke in the fall. if it’s wise to spend $200, i will… but i suspect, for this class of knife, which is typically less expensive in general, i can easily spend less than $100 for a quality fixed blade, less than $150 for a quality auto.
i know they’ve got a following around here, but i’m not a fan of emerson… to be blunt, they’re plain over-priced in general. i looked at the sark a while back, and concluded it’s more of the same- plastic handle, manual open, and they want more for it than an aluminum-handled benchmade auto.
unfortunately, hooks are no good for rope. otherwise, that’d be the answer, plain and simple.
I have two different knives in my turnout gear, my left pant leg has a Spyderco Rescue and my right has a Benchmade rescue. Both have been great knives, the Benchmade only takes a flick of the wrist and it’s open, the Spyderco is a bit more positive in the opening force needed. The Benchmade rescue that I have looks like it’s been replaced by a new model called the Triage:
It looks like it’ll be a combo edged knife instead of a full serration, but it does have a hook cutter and a glass breaker as well.
The Emerson SARK would also be a good option, especially if one handed opening is a huge concern. My CQC-7 Wave deploys faster than any of my automatics. I realize they’re pricy, but I’ve been considering one for my gear.
Good luck with your search, let us know what you end up with.
You can track down a genuine Emerson for considerably less than retail, looking around. That will honestly be tougher to do with a SARK, however.
Have you thought about commissioning a simple custom? There are several talented blademakers on this forum that might help you. Bgoode and cosmok leap to mind, off the top of my head. Jeremy Krammes is also highly skilled.
A sturdy handle, hooked blade, kydex homemade sheath. It would not need to be pretty, but could be what you need. Perhaps your own custom version of a wider rescue hook?
The Spyderco Jumpmaster while not that cheap, would be a good pick. A guy I know that does a lot of skydiving swears by it. I’ve had the chance to examine it and if I had a use for one, it would be my choice.
The hook style cutters are much safer around any cordage under tension. Kernmantle or webbing under tension “responds” readily to a sharp edge. The caveat is that the edge in question is not picky and will cut whatever it contacts; the tension on the rope/cordage/webbing adds an almost synergistic effect.
The hook style cutters provide just a little cushion for human error.