Recoil impulse question

I recently built 2 uppers with similar specs, different barrels

Upper 1:

LMT Flattop upper
Sabre Defense 10.5 barrel
DD Mk18 RISII
Low profile gas block
PWS FSC

Upper 2:

LMT 10.5 upper
DD Mk18 RISII
Larue low profile gas block
PWS FSC

I’m using the same LMT BCG and lower with H2 buffer on each upper and I noticed that upper 1 had a stronger recoil impulse and could definitely feel the buffer returning back with a jerk. While upper 2 is more smooth shooting and has no violent return.

What seems to be the problem? Do I have a gas problem on upper1? Is the diameter of the gas port holes on the LMT barrel and Sabre Defense the same? Or is it something else?

LMT’s are known for having smaller gas ports. Maybe it’s just the difference in how much gas each one is sending back to the carrier.

does the one that seems to recoil more throw the brass farther?

Take a look next time. How far the brass flies is a comparative indicator of how much gas each upper is sending to the bolt.

My guess is that the one that recoils harder throws the brass farther.

Don

Bingo.

The LMT has the smallest gas port on the market.

C4