No, praise the heavens, this isn’t an “M4 vs lightweight” thread.
It does, however, have to do with the first government profile barrel, the M16A2 barrel. There have been threads about accuracy and threads about availability and whatever, but what I still don’t fully understand is why the government profile barrel exists. It’s completely counter-intuitive. Tapering to a heavier profile is the strangest thing, but I’m not a mechanical engineer and I don’t understand vibrations or harmonics or other engineer-y buzzwords…yet.
The only place I’ve found a halfway good answer to the question of why the government profile barrel exists is on Wikipedia. It claims that the government profile barrel in the M16A2 was a product of wanting a heavier barrel less prone to overheating but still wanting to deal with the conundrum of being able to clamp the M203 to the barrel. The article claims the mounting M203 is the reason that M16 and M4 barrels have intermittent .625-ish thin sections.
There is an Army study about the A2 adoption and it has some enlightening reading though.
The M16A2 “heavy barrel” is heavy in the wrong place. The problem with
the M16A1 is a temporary bending of the barrel which occurs from the stress of
various firing positions causing bullet strike to vary, e.g., the difference
between a bipod firing position, and a position using a hasty sling will
change the strike of the bullet at 300 meters by three to four feet or
more. The “bending” takes place between the receiver and the sling swivel/
bayonet stud. The M16A2 barrel is “heavy” only from the sling swivel to the
muzzle–where it can have no effect on the bending problem. The Marines plan
to test a new barrel which may correct this problem. (Discussed on p. 29).
And then on page 29
Heavy Barrel. The light weight barrel of the MI6AI is prone to external
pressure, and our firing tests have revealed large differences in bullet
strikes based on these stress extremes, i.e., a hasty sling as opposed
to a bipod position with downward pressure (see Figure 13). It is proposed
that only sufficient weight be added to the barrel at the receiver and mid-
barrel to help the barrel bend problem and that this be coordinated with a
more securely fastened handguard to help provide rigidity while retaining
light weight. A heavy barrel has been tested and there may be plans to
incorporate it as a preplanned product improvement if it proves to be adequate;
however, the goal is not a heavy barrel, but the elimination of serious bullet
displacement resulting from various holding positions. Another consideration
must be to retain sufficient cooling air space, already reduced, between the
barrel and the handguard.
The whole report is too big for me to upload here. Draw your own conclusions but it sounds like they were worried about bending it with sling and having it light enough to cool fast.
Edit: The report is:
ANALYSIS OF M16A2 RIFLE CHARACTERISTICS AND RECOMMENDED IMPROVEMENTS
ARI Field Unit at Fort Benning, Georgia
When the M16A2 first came out, it was being reported that they went to a heavier profile barrel because GIs were damaging their rifles by bending the barrels when using them to break the shipping bands used on pallets. The heavier profile was supposed to prevent the bending
Ive heard that reasoning regurgitated a few times on History channel as well as Military Channel. Would not the cheaper and easier solution be to not use the rifles as pry bars? I would turtle fuck the stupid out of my guys if I saw that.
I have a little more information on this subject than the average bear.
One of my previous military sales reps was a major factor in the design of the M16 A2 while he was a PM for small arms at Quantico. He was a Korean War sniper and match shooter. Basically he wanted a target rifle in the hands of the Marines with a heavy barrel, longer stock, and finely adjustable sight.
They did all this, and OOPS! the barrel between the receiver and front sight castle was too large to accept the M203. So they turned down that portion of the barrel leaving the front part large. (supposedly because the GIs were bending them opening C rat cases) However, I think it is possibly because they had already printed out the increased barrel diameter for the hole in the front sight castle, and probably even made a bunch. So it was simplest to turn down the barrel.
Since they wanted the front sights to be interchangeable at the time, they left it that way for the carbine, which was way different then.
It was very common for GI’s to use their M16’s to pry the ends or there cots when making their bunks. Also jumping out of airplanes had a tendency to bend them in front of the FSB.
The simple remedy to the issues given in ZRH’s quoted articles is to free-float the barrel. Then you don’t get POI shift due to sling or bipod-induced forces.
This is also from the same report, which makes it sound like Marines were the initial purchasers and they only bought them because it’s what Colt had on the shelf. The only thing the Army liked about it was the faster twist. Sights were considered too delicate, and it weighed too much.
The rifle which has been type classified and designated the M16A2 is
considered to be unsuitable for Army use, and purchase under any circumstances
is not recommended.
Time was a major factor with the Marine development effort. They
were short a large number of rifles and had to purchase new rifles. It did
not make sense to puchase old rifles when new rifles were ready for testing.
Therefore, they decided to purchase new rifles and stepped up the tempo of
testing activities accordingly, taking what Colt had available on-the-shelf
and conducting a quick Modified Operational Test (MOT). When the system (MI6A2 firing XM855 ammunition) failed to meet requirements for major portions
of the test, it would seem appropriate to have delayed testing and new weapon
purchases until the system could undergo successful operational testing. But
under time pressure, the Marines have ordered combat rifles which failed
to meet minimum standards for accuracy, durability, or reliability.
When under fire, trying to disburse a pallet of ammo just para dropped into the perimeter while being given the gentle ministrations of a veteran sergeant to do so yesterday maggot!, a GI will do what needs to be done with the tools in hand
Guys would also bend their rifle barrels making tight Parade Slings. They would open up the rifle shotgun style. Adjust the sling and then close the upper. The process would make the sling super tight and also bend the barrel.
Col. Lutz said that by the time they figured out that the barrels weren’t bent permanently, but rather just had burrs on the gas port, it was too late to change the M16A2.
I would say that more than a few of the weapons that came into our shop where do to misuse or improper use. Like the one where a person staked his trigger and hammer pins so they would not walk out. Or the one where the guy loaded his rifle with a blank round and then cut open a bunch of blanks and poured the powder down the barrel.
It doesn’t surprise me that people use the barrels as pry bars and the butt stock and hammers.
I was in the Marines in the early 80s when the transition took place from the A1 to the A2, steel pots to Kevlar, and also when they came up with the marvelous idea of MREs vs C-rats. No B2 unit to make into a stove, no way to heat water in your helmet to warm the food. I also remember when they got to Diego Garcia and found that the plastic pouches were not rat resistant. Right much stuff happens because of the politics of procurement without a lot of consideration for the end user.