Question for the Armorers

I am not an armorer so I wanted to pose this question to those that are. I was researching on Brownell’s… and came across this little number. I did a “google search” for reviews, and also did a search on here. Came up with zip.

Made by Fulton Armory… called the McFarland Bolt Gas Ring. Seems that it’s one continuous ring, wound to be the thickness of the three gas rings on a conventional DI Bolt.

In theory, this sounds like a great idea, but is it just turd polishing or does it actually work?

In my 24 years in the Army, I have never had a failure due to the gas rings lining up causing issues. Can it happen? Sure it can… but, I’ve never seen it.

Then again… I just had my very FIRST extractor break on me the other day. 24 years of running M16’s / AR’s… and I had my first.

What are your thoughts on this?

Thank you so much, in advance for your input.

Cheers!

Here is the link… http://www.brownells.com/.aspx/pid=18722/Product/AR_15_MCFARLAND_trade__BOLT_GAS_RING

Here’s a picture:

I have heard that these work well.

Though I’m not sure they work any better or worse than regular gas rings.

This is an absolute myth - an AR can run on a single gas ring.

Mr. C… I’ve actually tested that theory myself. I was just sort of lending to the idea that this part may be just fluff. Was curious if anyone has ever tried it.

I can remember when I was a NUG, going through BRM… they taught us when cleaning the BCG / Bolt to ALWAYS stagger the rings. It sunk into my brain housing group so early on, that I do it on auto-pilot and never think about it. That’s why I said that I have never seen issues with it.

I’ve seen the broken extractor issue before, but never happened to me. It did the other day though… so, I can no longer claim that.

Cheers!!!

I remember a thread about some oversized McFarland rings that were causing issues.
I know others (Iraqgunz for one, IIRC) that install them as a precautionary measure (low probability of breakage or wear within the lifespan of the bolt) and haven’t had any issues.

FWIW- I have personally shot many rounds with an M4A1 with only one gas ring, and I still habitually stagger them during reassembly. No harm in doing it, and it quiets my inner DI.

I’ve used the McFarlands a few times. They do last longer than normal gas rings.

I have two of these in my spare parts kit. Bought them after the oversized issue was dealt with.

I bought a couple sets of the McFarland’s quiet awhile back,and finally installed a set on my Oldest & highest round count AR,the rings were getting kinda lose,when I did the stand the bolt on the end thingy it would drop on its own,so I decided to change the old out for the new !! Once installed everything went together and worked fine. I ended up putting about 5/600 rounds through that rifle,but ended up selling it awhile back to fund other projects !! I have no hard proof or long term test with the single piece rings,but it is a novel ideal I guess,& for under $4 bucks,they are worth a fair shake I think.

I used them in my older Bushmaster and had no problems, but I had no problems before with the original gas rings. I put it in because they were supposed to be better… In my current rifle I just have the standard rings. Still no issues. I remember reading something about the McFarland rings not expanding evenly when heated up, but I am not sure where I saw that at.

Jeremy

We have them on our rifles at work. A previous armorer was sold on these and every malfunction we had was “gas rings”.

I’ve yet to see or hear of one breaking since we swapped over to them. Personally, I don’t see a real advantage over conventional gas rings.

I have been using the McFarlands for a few years now. Based on my experience with them, they seem to last longer and I have had no issues with them at all.

My decision to use them wasn’t based on the staggering rings myth. I heard from others that they were good to go and lasted longer so I tried them out.

All of my AR’s are outfitted with them at this time.

I think it’s someone trying to reinvent the wheel. I never used them, because the basic rings are fine. Remember to add a few drops of oil on them and you will not have any issues.

Armalite uses them on their AR10s.

I think this is one of those things where either version works fine if made in spec.

The standard 3 pc ring set obviously works well and IMO is probably easier to get right regarding fit / tolerance.

Thank you all for the input.

For my own testing, I ordered a few sets. I will install them on my M&P-15 and see how they work.

I will mic them, to see if there is any tolerance variable between the three sets that I ordered.

Again,

Thank you for the input.

They were undersized most seemed to be .498- .501 and were failing the bolt carrier test. .503 seems to be the ideal size to pass the bolt carrier test.