Private Security Contractors and Mercenaries?

Is there a difference between a Private Security Contractor and a Mercenary?

I was under the impression that mercenaries are warriors who are paid to fight and that security contractors are also paid but they have a defensive role only.

Im uneducated on this topic and would like to learn more.

It seems like the two terms are thrown around interchangeably and I was wondering if this was ok to do.

Check.

One thing that needs to be distinguished here as well is sanctioned or non sanctioned. Two different values and the public’s awareness is part of this mis-perception of context. Hence the negative connotation sometimes gets awarded/associated within the community. Regardless of the rationalization or justification for the cause.

If we are talking sanctioned the following applies. :smiley:

From my deployments and experience there are “Offensive” types of contracting opportunities within GB.

My first was w/ a DoS contract. So there was a lot of lattitude in procedures, the inter agency cooperation I experienced was outstanding operationally, relaxed ROE, bennies were outstanding as well. etc.

From the program I knew about, aspects of it or mission’s statement of purpose/mission profile etc. had components/tactics in it, that could be considered offensive in nature.

The rest is somewhat open to interpretation imo.

Terms vary, contractors who in reality are people (albiet different skill sets no doubt). Having said that, one contractor may have a different description/definition etc. than another.

As far as other philosophical aspects regarding personal beliefs for me it’s, good vs. evil, everything happens for a reason and HOW MUCH MONEY ?

HTH
YMMV…

So there are both “offensive” roles and defensive roles depending on the company’s contract?

imo, yes.

‘Mercenary’ is an occupation defined by the Geneva convention. I don’t think there are any other recognized definitions, hence journalists who don’t like outsourcing tend to call everything from a security guard to someone flipping burgers for KBR in Iraq a ‘mercenary’. (notice any articles where they counted ‘mercenaries in Iraq’, they would just tally up all ‘contractors’ regardless of their role and then compare that number to, say, Britain’s contribution)

  1. A mercenary is any person who:

(a) Is specially recruited locally or abroad in order to fight in an armed conflict;

(b) Does, in fact, take a direct part in the hostilities;

(c) Is motivated to take part in the hostilities essentially by the desire for private gain and, in fact, is promised, by or on behalf of a Party to the conflict, material compensation substantially in excess of that promised or paid to combatants of similar ranks and functions in the armed forces of that Party;

(d) Is neither a national of a Party to the conflict nor a resident of territory controlled by a Party to the conflict;

(e) Is not a member of the armed forces of a Party to the conflict; and

(f) Has not been sent by a State which is not a Party to the conflict on official duty as a member of its armed forces.

http://www.unhchr.ch/html/menu3/b/93.htm

Interesting discussion.

So technically, a private security contractor is a mercenary based off of that definition, correct?

I don’t think any court or authority has ruled that (unless you count the Daily Kos as an authority on legal matters). The difference between ‘taking a direct part in the hostilities’ and ‘being motivated by financial gain to take part in the hostilities’ and what the PSCs are doing in Iraq is apparently big enough for them to not do that.

What they actually do is not mercenary activity. Let’s say, if after the Fallujah tragedy, Blackwater were the ones laying siege on the town rather than the USMC. That would’ve made them mercenaries plain and obvious to any observer, casual variety or not. :stuck_out_tongue: It’s kinda like pornography; hard to describe, but you know it when you see it.

It is my understanding that all of those conditions must be met to be considered a mercenary. If you want a true modern example of a mercenary look at Executive Outcomes.

There is a Yahoo PMC group that consists of academics, scholars, journalists, and idiots. This was recently posted by one of the members called Doug, but I forget his last name. Anyhow, here is his thoughts…

The ‘mercenary’ term is used by few serious scholars of the topic
and is usually found in the work of ideologically left-of-center
academics, sensationalistic journalists and the stubbornly
archaic “UN Working Group on Mercenaries”. The term certainly
grabs the attention of the uninformed and seems to be quite
useful in selling books, articles, dissertations and even entire
academic programs.

But even among those who embrace the term few argue that the
private sector really fits into the narrow Article 47 definition
of a mercenary
(during their Panama meeting a member of the UN
Working Group half-jokingly estimated there were no more than
about four individuals on earth that fit the definition, which
would mean true mercenaries are outnumbered by the five-member
Working Group on Mercenaries . . . but still they cling to the
name). Generally the ‘mercenary’ term is derogatory (I like to
point out that the real definition of the word as used by the
media and sloppier scholars is ‘a foreigner or business person we
don’t like’). It implies illegality and rampant greed. All of
which is why you can almost hear the eyes rolling when the term
gets trotted out again and again in the seedier literature . . .

For me, the best terms to encompass the entire industry come from
the Pentagon, which refers to ‘contingency contractors’ working
in ‘stability operations’. From an industry perspective it is
useful to further break down the Stability Operations Industry
into:

-LSCs (logistic and support companies) - the 90% of the industry
that is not hired to carry weapons but are hired to do tasks that
would be fairly mundane outside of areas of disaster or conflict,
such as base construction and support, fleet maintenance, air
transport, medical services, landmine removal, heavy air
transport etc.

-SSR & D (Security Sector Reform and Development) - the 5% or so
of the industry that provides long-term solutions to weak and
failed states and are used to help rectify the problem that led
to the international intervention in the first place. These
companies do things like rebuild legal systems including courts,
prisons, lawyers and judges. They train police, prison guards,
border guards and soldiers. They rebuild educational systems,
train teachers and develop appropriate curriculum. They mentor
specialists and technicians to take over from the international
expats that are temporarily supporting the operation. They are
used to foster the stability that has to be in place for an
international intervention to actually succeed to the point where
the international community can gradually withdraw.

-And finally, the PSCs - the 5% of the industry that ‘protects a
noun’ (and the 5% rule for PSCs has fluctuated remarkably little,
even at the height of the Iraq conflict). PSCs are inherently
defensive in nature, and while international law does not
differentiate between ‘offensive’ and ‘defensive’ combat, most
academics, policy-makers, legal experts and the industry itself
do see a fundamental difference between taking the war to the
‘enemy’ and simply protecting a person, place or thing. Although
a small part of the industry, it is PSCs that make the headlines
most often and many academics and journalists have made their
papers significantly more exciting exaggerating the numbers or by
implying that most contractors are actually PSCs. In Iraq it
seemed like every newspaper article looking at PSCs would double
the estimated numbers (as I recall this peaked when one of the
major wire services estimated 300,000 armed contractors in 2004
or 05). In retrospect the only way to get much above 10,000 was
to include Iraqi private security doing security for Iraqi
clients. I used to joke that as of “March 2007” there were more
academics studying PSCs than contractors actually doing PSC work.
Now I think I was pretty accurate . . .

Doug Brooks perhaps?