Piston AR's. A Solution looking for a problem?

Ummm, bullshit! Don’t let your bias distort the real world. Not saying that the AR platform isn’t perfectly reliable but to say it is “more” reliable than the AK is just BS…

Ever seen Templars video where he fills it with sand at Blackwater and still cant get it to fail? Try the same thing with your AR and let me know how it works out for you…

The AK has its short comings (sights, safety lever and mag release) but reliability is not one of them. Keep in mind I am talking about a “quality” AK like you are with the AR not some CIA garbage.

I don’t think that test performed by ATEC is very realistic either. For instance, in the middle of a hellacious firefight I was in back in 2003 in Iraq, during a very brief lull in the fight, I reached into my right cargo pocket and grabbed the small bottle of CLP I always carried in there and squirted a large amount of the liquid into my bolt carrier group.

And during the whole invasion, from Kuwait to Baghdad, myself and my fellow Marines always constantly kept our weapons clean. And it’s not like it was a hassle to clean them and maintain them, as we were used to cleaning them all the damn time since boot camp anyways, and it took just a few minutes to give it a good field cleaning, which was good enough to ensure that we would not have any stoppages as a result from dust, dirt or debris when engaging the enemy in a gunfight.

That is just my experience, but I would be willing to bet that other combat vets and grunts would attest to the same results and outcomes as I just have.

I take issue with this statement. A quality AR15 is very reliable when well maintained. However, a quality AK is almost ALWAYS going to be more reliable. With over 95 million in existence, your statement against AK reliability by comparing it to AR’s is utterly moot. Third world countries, zero maintenance, cheap corrosive ammo, no lubrication, rampant rust…the AK is tops for reliability. This is to it’s detriment in the department of precision and accuracy, but a good AK needs to make zero excuses for its ability to operate in almost all conditions. Try running an AR COMPLETELY DRY for 5K rounds with zero cleaning either…can’t be done. MAYBE with a super high-falutin’ piston gun…maybe. It’s done every day with dozens of AK’s in countries across the globe.

Sorry for the thread drift, but let’s keep perspective here. The entire topic for this thread is about the viability of piston systems. The entire piston concept is an effort to convey AK reliability on the AR platform. I think a good piston system can and will be developed. POF & LWRC look like the best available options right now. I’ve held and shot both. I was pleased with both. They are not the penultimate, but they are both legitimate steps in the right direction. However, I see it all heading toward a clean-sheet design like the FN SCAR, Remington ACR, or something of that nature. I would quickly hop onto the KAC bandwagon if they developed a full-size version of the PDW dual-piston operating system for a 5.56/6.8 rifle. THAT, IMHO, could be the penultimate. I also see a caliber change coming with the platform change; 6.5 or 6.8 along w/ heavier bullets (100-140 grains) are where things are heading.

The entire piston concept is an effort to convey AK reliability on the AR platform

I refuse to believe that a piston is the deciding factor in reliability.

It’s about tolerances, not pistons.

I was never a fan of piston ARs. Piston ARs seemed like a insult.

Thats said, my whole view changed after seeing the Addax ATAC style uppers. (no they are not the same as PWS, you get better shit when you get them from Addax and you can customize your order too)

The ATAC has:

Minimal carrier tilt (compared to others, plus there is a special buffer to fix that anyway if it concerns you)

Recoil of an ATAC is still not as soft as DI but much softer than other systems I have had the pleasure of playing with.

Long stroke design ( op rod is part of the BCG…looks like a fucking AK!!)

What I like best was no knobs, no adjustments needed when using different ammo or suppressed and unsuppressed. It just shoots no adjustments needed.

So in my quest to build an SBR (11.5) and run it suppressed…the ATAC is my choice. Hopefully, I can get it all together soon. For me it has nothing to do with clean or dirty its just what I want.

PS…No idea what happened or the story surrounding it with clear detail yet but, Saw a completely snapped in two Adams Arms op-rod the other day. Guy said it was a complete upper, Adams Arms as far as I know does not offer complete uppers…Spikes?:eek:

I agree that just slapping a piston on an AR pattern rifle can be borderline insulting when poorly done. Many conversions fall into this category for me. They just make me cringe. I would much rather own a good mid-length upper than an el-cheapo piston deal. However, the DI system is NOT the best way to make a firearm function from the git-go. As posted, a clean-sheet redesign is needed. Just slapping a piston on what WAS a good system is not the answer… but neither is settling for a system that blows all those dirty driving gasses back into the receiver. We need something new. The AR was a fresh design. We need something equally innovative again.