I’ve started looking into getting a new pistol for training/carry. and have settled on going polymer for this one. This means that I’m considering the following weapons. I’m leaning towards getting it chambered in .40S&W for both ammo availability, carry capacity, and stopping power.
Springfield Armory XD 4"
Smith & Wesson M&P Fullsize
Glock 22
Now, I know little about these pistols, so, I’m posing it to you guys what would work best.
I’ve also considered a Sig, or a CZ, but, I’m fairly ignorant on those systems as well.
CZ P-06, or SP-01
Sig P226
Any advice you could provide would be appreciated.
-Adam
If you want something with “stopping power”, I’d recommend a 40mm grenade launcher. Truth is, the 40S&W isn’t any better than other service calibers (9mm/45ACP/.38/.357 etc.) for terminal ballistics. My preference is for the 9mm - good ballistic performance with hollowpoints, relatively inexpensive, easy to shoot, and easy to find (notwithstanding the recent ammo scarcity). If you like the 40, that’s fine. Just don’t think it will drop the bad guy every time like Thor’s Hammer. Here’s a good source for ballistics info: http://ammo.ar15.com/project/Self_Defense_Ammo_FAQ/index.htm
I have no experience with the P-06, but I did own the very similar P-01 in 9mm.
Here is my take on the P-06:
Trigger - You will have to learn 2 different trigger pulls - a long double-action trigger pull for the first shot, followed by a much shorter single-action trigger pull after that. Depending on your skill level, it may take you some time to master the 2 different triggers. For me, I found that I didn’t shoot the DA trigger as well as I would have liked. I ended up selling it and switching it to an M&P 9 compact.
Grip/controls - I found the location of the mag release, slide lock and decocker to be ideal for me. The grip felt like it was made specifically for me.
Slide configuration - the slide rides inside the frame, which can make the slide harder to grab. I never had an issue with this, but other people have had problems with it.
Accessories - CZ’s are not as popular as other brands in the US, so accessories (sights, holsters, etc.) are not as available. You may not be able to find a holster or night sights for a CZ at your local gun store. Having said that, you will be able to find most anything you need via the internet.
Fit & Finish - most CZ’s come with a polycoat finish over parkerizing. It’s not pretty, but it works. CZ’s are also known for somewhat rough internals, but this does not affect function. Personally, I don’t care about that - it’s a tool, not a barbecue gun.
I don’t think you can go wrong with any of the manufacturers you listed.
My advice would be to put in some time with all three and base your decision on what fits you best. If you can’t rent them from your local range perhaps you could borrow from a friend.
The full size is not going to be as easy to conceal, but if I could only purchase one pistol I would go with fullsize.
The only thing I would question is the .40 caliber choice.
If I were you (and perhaps this is personel preference) I’d consider going to .45 or a 9mm. Again, if it’s your only gun I’d choose the 9mm. Plenty of stoping power, ammo is relatively inexpensive, and it’s fairly plentiful. All that boils down to is much more frequent and affordable practice and training.
If I could only have one pistol I’d get a full size M&P 9mm.
Tough decision-the good news is, I don’t think that there’s a bad decision to be made in your matrix. Out of YOUR provided choices, I’d recommend the Glock 22 over the others-while it’s not perfect, it has the advantage of being fielded for years, with most of the bugs worked out and Glock provides superlative after-market support. I’m impressed with the excellent “grippability” of the latest Glock iteration of the G22, the G22 with their Rough Textured Grip (RTF2).
I’d have to echo some of the previous comments about the viability of .40 when compared to contemporary 9mm choices. Unless your agency/organization mandates .40, and assuming that you do have accessability to some of the modern, good performing 9mm cartridges available, I just not sure that there’s a good reason to choose .40 over 9mm. I’m not faulting the performance of good .40 cartridge choices, I’m simply suggesting that comperable performances can be achieved with a 9mm selection-and 9mm is usually significantly less expensive.
Given that, I’d suggest that a Glock 17 or Glock 19 be a first choice consideration.
Among the guns NOT in your matrix, in .40 I’d suggest considering a SIG-Sauer P229, or one of the current HK family of .40 pistols.
In all fairness, a consideration FOR .40 might be ammunition availability, at least in the current/short run; in my neck of the Pacific Northwest neck of the woods, it’s currently actually easier to find .40 than it is 9mm and .45 ACP…but I suspect that demand and availability will eventually level off for the better.
If you’re in law enforcement, the military, or a first responder, Glock, SIG-Sauer, Smith & Wesson, and I believe Springfield (and I’m sure others) have some excellent individual officer discount programs in place, but you may have to buy from specific dealers to take advantage of them.
I have both the Glock 17 & 22. 17 for teaching, classes and competition. 22 for what is left. No more 1911’s, revolvers, subcompacts or extra large guns (G21 is on market). Decided to slim down and stick to what i shoot well and forget about having an armory. The fit in the hand and trigger arrangements work for me.
True the 9mm ammo is cheaper but oddly enouth the 40 is available now where 9mm is MIA (in my locality). So im glad i have both.
I would tend to believe what most people here say about terminal ballistics. However, i often wonder why the FBI, the “Unit” and so many, many others have chosen the 40 S&W/G22 over the 9mm and Glock 17. Until i fully understand this question and 9mm ammo comes back from captivity i am glad i have both.
BTW i held the M&P 40 the other day and could not stop thinking about how good it felt in the hand. The trigger system kept me from opening my wallet, but i came close.
Smith and Wesson M&P .40S&W. It manages recoil well, is a VERY robust design to handle the .40S&W cartridge, and it is more accurate than a lot of polymer alternatives out there.
I went through this searching process about 6 years ago and I found that the Glock 23 was the 40 taylored for me. I have shot competitively with one now for about that long and have loved every second of the gun. I clean it once a year and maybe relube it one other time during the year out of guilt.
I put about 1,500-3,500 rounds a year over the 6 years through my Glock without one hick up. If I had to guess I’m around the 12,000 mark with it.
Bonuses for this gun are abundant mags because you can use both the model 22 and 23 mags for it. They use to be pretty cheap brand new at a whopping 24 bucks retail now I think it’s 29 even that’s not horrible.
You can customize the gun for next to nothing by adding an extended mag and slide release and even a 3.5 lbs. trigger for around $50.
I would even suggest getting some Heine slot 8 night sights for it.
It is officially my favorite firearm.
Good luck with your decision I hope I have helped in some way.
At this point in time, I would not choose the SA XD, especially in 40 cal. I would also strongly suggest you avoid the G22 or for that matter any Glock in calibers other than 9 mm. Because of the recent decline in Sig QC, I would also not go that route. CZ is a non-player.
Your best bet for a high quality, new out of the box pistol would be to choose:
– a 9 mm Glock, as these are very well proven, reliable, durable pistols with world wide availability of parts.
– any caliber S&W M&P, as these are proving to be extremely capable, soft shooting, accurate pistols and S&W offers the best customer support in the business.
– an HK P30 or HK45, as these are seemingly working very well, although spotty parts availability can be a bit of a deterrent, as can HK’s mercurial customer support history
I would like to echo the call for a Glock in 9mm. I’m partial to the 17, but the 19’s are great too, especially if you will carry them.
The M&P’s I’ve shot have been excellent, and would also be an excellent choice. They currently have their 2 free mag coupon in effect, so that makes them even more tempting. They were also designed with the .40 cal in mind, so they are built around that cartridges recoil energy.
As to HK, Doc’s comments are spot on. Smith is a great source of parts for their guns, and you can get Glock parts just about every where. I will add that mags for the HKs are tough to come by. I finally found a couple of mags for my HK45, and I thought they were a bargain at $55 each. If you train hard, you’ll need proably 5 or more mags. With Glock, you’ll be out about $75-90. With the coupon, you’ll only need to pay for one more mag, say $30-40. With an HK, you’re out over $150. Now try to find holsters and sights. Everybody makes a Glock holster or sight, and the M&P is catching up. HK is way behind.
For .40 and .45, I think the M&Ps are the best thing going. For 9mm, I still like the Glocks, but the M&P’s are good too. I would pass over the XD and any DA/SA gun. That’s just me though. Try to find a place that has rental guns for you to try out.
I just picked up a M&P full size to compliment my 2 compacts. This one will be for keeping at my bedside with a light attached. I also expect it to be easier for my wife to shoot well. She has a bit of carpel tunnel syndrome.
[ol]
[li] Smith & Wesson M&P Fullsize[/li][li] Glock 22[/li][li] Springfield Armory XD 4"[/ol][/li]
All normal advice to newbies applies: Try them yourself, assess your specific needs, get a 9mm instead of a .40, yadda yadda yadda.
The xd is a little bulky and heavy for CCW, think of trying to conceal a small brick:D trust me, I picked up the 4" thinking it would conceal well, picked up a new ccw and probably gonna sell my 4" for the 5". For concealing I think the 239 or atleast the 229 would be the better choice in that platform
From my experience I would recommend a Glock in 9mm VS .40. Both my G19 & G23 have performed very well in the past several years that I’ve owned them. Personally I wouldn’t purchase the G23 again and would stick with either 9mm or .45 and would recommend you do the same.
That being said I’m taking a hard look at the M&P line in either 9mm or .45 with the thumb safety. I’ve been shooting my 1911 alot this past year and have really gotten used to a thumb safety and think it has some definite benefits to it. Does anyone have any experience with the thumb safety on the M&Ps either positive or negative or reasons not to have one?
Marcus, thanks for taking the time to post the detailed test results. Looking at the data, it strikes me (no particular pun intended) that while you get greater expansion with the 180 gr .40 round, you concurrently get greater penetration. Without knowing what the ideal benchmarks are (i.e., what is the ideal penetration depth, and at what measurement does overpenetration become a concern) it’s difficult for me to comment on the results.
You also extensively quote Urey Patrick (or is it Patrick Urey?) and his “10mm Notes.” I appreciate the partial cites, and the information, but what is the date of the comments? If it’s back in the 1980s or 1990s, I think much water (and subsequent cartridge/bullet development) has passed under the bridge. Nor do I hear of much individual or institutional/organizational clamoring for any reinstitution of the 10mm, either cartridge- or platform-wise, other than for hunting/wilderness use (despite the probability of it penetrating vehicles better than 9mm or .40).
Unfortunately, I think that your first quote about the 9mm being “generally as good as the .38 special” does little but cast credibility questions on the remainder of his quotes. Are you indeed asserting that this is still the case?
The next question that I would have is that given the expansion numbers, what is the ideal/benchmark for ideal incapacitation? At first blush the assumed answer is that the greater the expansion, the greater/quicker the incapacitation, but is this actually the case-and, if so, given that in most cases cited in the test results that we’re only seeing about .1" difference, is there an actual, empirical real-world difference in incapacitation rates between 9mm and .40 in the rounds tested (or otherwise)?