Piecing together first upper

Been lurking for a while and have posted in in a few spots, but now I’m ready to throw my project info out for all to see.

Thank you to all who participate here, knowledge and opinions are excellent and well appreciated!

I have plenty experience on the average A2, though not in active combat engagements :mad: (Army, O.I.F.).

I have good knowledge of the weapons platform (half of this based on gathering info here on m4c, other half from hands on experience).

I also live in a ban state, so I don’t have too many options. At first I planned on getting a complete upper, but most merchants don’t pin and weld the muzzle device on to the uppers I had been eyeballing; this has to be done before I can receive it in mail. Also questioned some merchants to see if they can remove the hider, but most said they wouldn’t. Don’t know why, maybe because it screws up their warranty?

So this led me to the option of making my own upper. I have a good shop close to me that can pin and weld a muzzle device and also pin the butt-stock on a lower (not hard to do at home, but might as well have them do it).

Here is the purpose and list:
Any critique is welcome.

Purpose: range/class

Upper
-DD 16" 5.56mm Lightweight Mid-length CHF Barrel - w/LPGB
-DD A4 Upper Receiver Assembly
-DD Complete Bolt Carrier Group
-DD M4 Rail™ 12.0, Rifle - I hate the standard 2 piece guards. Getting this rail because of the weight, and it’s length will allow me to experiment with trying out handling techniques and attachment points. Thought about the Magpul Mid-length MOE hand-guard also and haven’t ruled it out yet, though this would mean getting Delta ring and the rest for barrel.
-Custom muzzle break from shop
-MBUS front/back
-Not concerned with optics and other accessories until I’ve flung a few rounds downrange and got a feel for the weapon.

Lower
-Stag Lower - reasoning being that the shop has them at good prices.
-Stock- not sure, planning on what they have at shop for cheap and going with the flow. I can also try out some of what they have in stock (recently I saw: CTR, ACS, Skeleston Stock). I also gotta see where my cheek weld is, so I can get it pinned the the proper distance.
-Trigger package - will prob. go with a G&R or Giessel, but depends on how the stock trigger feels.

Other Accessories
-Magpul MS2 Sling - Don’t know if I should get the ASAP yet. I will be sticking to 2 point for now. Haven’t tried single point attachment, but plan to in the future.
-Lots of PMAGs
-Color - probably sticking to black or Flat Dark Earth/Black, whatever is practical and conceals the weapon fairly well in tactical situation. (hot pink with purple flames did cross my mind):smiley:
-Maybe some bullets
-A clue

Don’t think anything is missing, but I’m only 95% perfect.
Thank you for the advice.

Nice list of items, but I would not be afraid to look at an aimpoint optic and build off off that for your future needs, you’ll enjoy it more in the long run. Can you give more info on the muzzle brake. For range purposes I am not sure you would need to drop the cash on a Giessel trigger, save it and put toward something else.

Rather than go with a build upper, get this instead and build around it.

http://www.bravocompanyusa.com/BCM-BFH-16-Mid-Length-Upper-Receiver-light-weight-p/bcm-urg-mid-16lw%20bfh.htm

Not much info on it; the shop pushed it. It looks exactly like the A2 flashider. The end is not wide open but mostly sealed like the PRI MSTN QC

Regarding the trigger: yeah, that’s a good plan.
Optic: I can wait. It was pretty easy to hit targets 300 meters out with irons the last few times I hit the range while still in the Army (w/standard issue 20" A2). I want to replicate that with this new build, or come close before hitting the bank with an Aimpoint. Thinking about a T1.

Yeah, contacted BCUSA, they said they can’t take off the flash hider and ship it. Don’t know why.
Otherwise I’d gladly do this, would make things a whole lot easier. Not that I mind the challenge of building my own upper (and have bragging rights).

Alright, so plan has now changed due to new info.

Due to my Ban State status, I am reduced to a few options.
Luckily, as I read through some of Rob_S technical posts (gotta plug), I came upon Rainier Arms option, which I hadn’t even thought of yet.

New plan Version 1:
-Rainier Arms Upper: Rainier Arms Combat Series Upper - CS16
-Irons: Magpul front/rear (from RA)
-Pinned and welded RA Xtreme Tactical Compensator

-LMT Defender 2000 Lower: standard lower, can always upgrade accordingly. Pretty sure they can pin the stock, but will have to check on this with RA.

Version 2:
Daniel Defense M4V4 from RA: not too keen on carbine length gas, but they may get the M4V5 in stock when I’m ready in a few weeks (fingers crossed).
-Plus all the aforementioned pinning and welding of components.

Reasoning for the rifle and it’s use is unchanged from previous post.

Question to any who can answer: so far I’m believing the quality claims as stated by RA of their complete uppers, but I always have a cautionary side that would rather double and triple check. So, in this light, I would welcome any experience-based comments/recommendations on RA upper assy. quality.

Thank you as always for any help or comments.

(Excuse please the post-modernistic impression of an upper.)

Some updates:

The Lower above is a Stag ($346 w/pinning).
It includes:
-Magpul MOE stock pinned at position 3… I think… I went with feel, not number of holes before pinning… :dirol:
-Standard Stag LPK.
-Magpul ASAP plate
-MS2 sling

Some later enhancements to Lower may include:
-Magpul MIAD
-G&R LPK
-Geissele Trigger
-Magpul BAD
-ReadiMag

Upper ($663 w/pin & weld of muzzle device, bayo lug removal)
(In the mail already)
-Rainier Arms CP 16Upper
-Magpul AFG (1st gen)
-Vtac weapon light mount
-DD Rail QD swivel attachment
-Required Magpul Rail segments for MOE handguard
-Magpul Rear MBUS

Some future enhancements:
-SureFire G2
-Optic - Aimpoint Comp M2
-I might switch out the Magpul MOE handguard to a rail from Troy or DD. This will depend on my mood, since going through all that cutting (Delta ring) may just inspire me to instead start a second build.

Cost of all additional accessories (said mounts, slings, mags, blah blah blah): $357
Total nausea inducing cost: $1366

I had hoped to build one for less than this, but the ban state I live in precludes I have to spend and average of at least $150 more than most people living in non-ban states.
The hardest part was finding a vendor who had the right quality upper and could also pin and weld the muzzle device and cut off the bayo lug nut before shipping. This alone was the most time consuming part of the deal.:suicide:

Now my next challenge will be to assemble a rifle out of complete spare parts and see where the cost of this will come out (with the ban state extras).

Question: The Rainier Arms Xtreme Tactical Compensator (XTC) is allowed in a ban state, including CT, right? I’m fairly certain it is, but then again I have been known to be an idiot who misses the obvious.

Again, comments and criticism are welcome.
I will post pics of complete rifle in all it’s glory when the upper arrives in the mail.

Why do you need to pin and weld a flash hider on a 16" barrel?

I pretty sure the AWB here in CT does not allow the muzzle device to be anything but permanently attached to the barrel, no matter the length.

You either have a comp/break on, or you have a bare barrel end. Nothing in between.

Interesting? Did you do any research into the specifics? Just curious as I have no clue about CT gun laws.

Yeah. I’m pretty sure.
The shop I went to to have the lower pinned specifically drilled it into my head that if I want to get an upper worked on, it has to have either no muzzle device or one that is legal (break/comp) and pinned and welded, otherwise they won’t even touch the upper with a ten foot pole.

They service and fix plenty of local PD firearms so I tend to trust what they say about the law.

Here’s a link to the law.

Just to get specific:

(From http://www.jud.ct.gov/JI/criminal/glossary/assaultweapon.htm)

A part or combination of parts designed or intended to convert a firearm into an assault weapon as defined in subdivision (1) or any combination of parts from which an assault weapon as defined in subdivision (1) may be rapidly assembled if those parts are in the possession or under the control of the same person.

  1.     Any semiautomatic firearm not listed in subdivision (1) that meets the following criteria:
    

(A) A semiautomatic rifle that has an ability to accept a detachable magazine and has at least two of the following:

i. a folding or telescopic stock;

ii. a pistol grip;

iii. a bayonet mount;

iv. a flash suppressor or threaded barrel designed to accommodate a flash suppressor; and

v. a grenade launcher.

To boil it down:
A legal semi auto firearm can have a detachable magazine and pistol grip, but no more… that’s it. There cannot be a bayo nut, a flash supressor or threaded barrel designed so you could put a flash suppressor on, a grenade launcher and a telescoping stock in addition to the weapon being a semi auto with a detachable magazine and pistol grip.

It can have a detachable magazine, a flash suppressor, but nothing else listed as a feature that would make it an ‘assault weapon’. Any two features can be had, but no more.

Makes no logical sense, but it’s the law, and it sucks.

Wow, that’s a pretty crazy section of he law.
Maybe you could get a full upper from either DD or BCM and ship itto adco to get the A2 fh taken off and the comp of your choice pinned and welded on?

This did cross my mind, and will be considered for my next build. But for now I still make out decent with Rainier Arms.
I believe their barrels are DD so I’m not skimping on quality on the most important part of the rifle.

I am not a lawyer. But, if I read that correctly since you are having the stock pinned, and the bayonet lug ground off, I would think that you could in fact have a flash hider (or maybe a Battle Comp) on there and it would be legal.

Because it cannot have more than two of the following items and you will only have a pistol grip. I may be wrong since I am not good a reading legalese.

I can’t speak to the laws, but you’ve made good choices with your picks. BCM, DD, and Ranier Arms all have superb uppers, good prices, and unbeatable customer service. Look forward to seeing the finished product.

This is where they get you, because an “assault weapon” has the ability to accept a hi-cap mag and has two of the items listed, ie; the pistol grip stock and the threaded muzzle with the flash hider or comp. And that would make it an “assault weapon”.

I have the same issue here in western NY, and it sucks ass.

Same here in MA

Without pinning or welding the muzzle brake, it’s considered a threaded barrel. If you pin it, it’s not a threaded barrel and you will only have one on the list. Pistol grip.

It would seem that way, but the law specifically mentions “a flash suppressor or threaded barrel designed to accommodate a flash suppressor”, therefore the proper reading would be no flash suppressor, irregardless of how many of the other 7 items are on or not on the rifle.
It is pretty confusing, but living here makes it an obligation to properly interpret the law just to cover your ass in case the unexpected happens (legally).

Thanks Birddog1911, I am eagerly awaiting the upper (about 1-2 week turnaround due to the gunsmithing RA has to do).
Yeah, New England AWBs are pretty good at confusing and pissing off law abiding citizens who have to jump through flaming hoops just to have an AR.

I will have to play around with the sling attachments to the MOE hand guard. I’ll see how far the DD QD sling sticks out from the rail piece on the hand guard. If it’s too much then I might just go with this idea:

(credit to Jimbo45 and rob_s)