Penetration Videos

Interesting videos. Gives one a better grasp on the subject of bullet penetration.

http://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=brassfetcher

Thanks!
Interesting videos to watch; however, I did notice that many of them listed the material as 20% gelatin vs. 10%. Not sure how much difference that would make in the videos.

Good stuff, however I would like to point out that many people seem to misinterpret these types of videos. Because the only thing clearly visible is the temporary cavity many tend to use such videos as a justification for using light fast projectiles. It was the comparison between the video for the 5.7 x 28, and the .45 ACP that lead to the conclusion that the 5.7 was just as effective as .45 because their TCs were the same size. Without further information (bullet recovered diameter, penetration depth, etc.) it is very difficult to assess the effectiveness of a load solely based on video information.

Well, a 20% gel would have a greater density than 10%, so theoretically you would have a shallower penetration as compared to “proper” gel used for testing, or at least that’s how I understand it.

I agree, the videos give a lot of highlighting of the temporary cavitation, but does little to show us the permanent cavities generated, or anything that would be useful to determine any sort of effectiveness.

What this would lead to, in my opinion, is someone basing a choice of ammunition on temporary cavity alone, when we know that pistol rounds in general do not generate a sufficient cavitation to cause damage to tissue.

As Joe pointed out as well, some of the videos are indicating use of 20% gel as opposed to 10%, so this would, I believe, increase density of the gel, skewing the deformation and penetration, so I think it would also be hard to call these demonstrations definitive or representative, since they’re hardly controlled or completely transparent, no?

The more testing that I see from Brassfetch the more I think that the tester has no interest in giving readers a valid comparison to FBI protocols. I’ve also noticed that they seem to test far more lighter loads like 9mm 115gr and .45acp 185gr+P instead of tried and true FBI approved heavier loadings…even though most of those lighter loads have trouble meeting minimum penetration standards. Then they start changing test media around and shifting focus to temporary cavity stretch while offering no scientific reading. At this point they are bordering on becoming Marshall & Sanow in terms of relevance to accurate ballistics science.

Totally agree with you on this. Just re-enforced the feeling I got when I saw their 5.7 vs .45 comparison.

Good point. Do we know who Brassfetcher is and/or where they come from in terms of doing research? I went to their website and looked through some of the PDF documents they have available, and all of them have the same recycled hash in them with some minor changes for the loads they’re testing. :confused:

I am not exactly sure who does the Brassfetcher testing. The problem is that the tester is trying to adapt the gel test into some made-up method for measuring bullet lethality and stopping effect. The FBI gel test was NEVER designed to measure lethality. It was designed to duplicate the mechanism needed to cause a bullet to expand/yaw/fragment, and be a standard for comparing the penetration and expansion capabilities from one load to another.

Bullet lethality is determined in shootings, followed up by a detailed medical examination of the patient/body. This is what Dr. Fackler did for decades and was the basis for the science. Loads used in the field were analyzed after the shootings and determined to be good/bad/need more penetration/need more expansion/…etc. The same loads were measured in FBI gel tests, and their performance was measured in the gel. Once good loads were found, that performance could be measured in the gel and all others could be compared to it and improved.

That is the purpose if the FBI gel test in a nut shell.

That’s how I’ve always viewed it. If I want to see how it works in the body, well, I’ve got about 1500 medical cases, and have talked to maybe 60 medical professionals just to get a better understanding of that so I have some inkling of data to start…

IIRC, Brassfetcher started out working at a USG facility that eventually spearheaded the JSWB-IPT efforts beginning back in 2002 or so. The U.S. government gathered numerous experts from a variety of disciplines, including military and law enforcement end-users, trauma surgeons, aero ballisticians, weapon and munitions engineers, and other scientific specialists to form the Joint Service Wound Ballistic Integrated Product Team to conduct a 4 year, 6 million dollar study to determine what terminal performance assessment best reflected the actual findings noted in combat the past few years. The test protocol that was found to be correct, valid, and became the agreed upon JSWB-IPT “standard” was the physiological damage based static 10% gel test, evolved from that first developed by Dr. Fackler at Letterman Army Institute of Reasearch (LAIR) in the 1980’s, promoted by the IWBA in the 1990’s, and used by most reputable wound ballistic researchers, including the FBI BRF, NSWC Crane, USSOCOM, and the USMC for their recent ammunition assessments. Physiological damage potential is the only metric that has been shown to have any correlation with field results in actual shooting incidents, based on law enforcement autopsy findings, as well as historical and ongoing combat trauma results. In other words a damage-based metric has relevance to and accurately reflects the real world. If you look closely, Brassfetcher’s early testing tended to follow this static gel test format, although his gel was often out of spec.

From what we have been told, after a shot stint in industry, Brassfetcher began working at a different prominent U.S. Army research lab. This is a bloated facility that continues to push the old dynamic 20% gel testing method which emphasizes using high speed video, kinetic energy dump, and computer modeling to make wound ballistic assessments. This is the lab that Dr. Fackler had many arguments with over the years. This lab repeatedly stated that they had “classified” data which proved the validity of their test methodology. Yet when finally directed to present this supposedly classified data in a Secret Level setting during the JSWB-IPT investigation, the lab was unable to provide one shred of valid evidence to support their test scheme. On many levels, the purported measures of “lethality” and “incapacitation” pushed by this lab are elaborate fantasy games of mathematical calculations and engineering statistics that fail to truly reflect the fact that in the gritty realm of face-to-face combat, incapacitating an aggressor is about rapidly inflicting sufficient physiological damage to the enemy’s critical anatomic structures in order to stop that opponent from continuing to be a lethal threat. Brassfetcher’s most recent testing seems to be reflective of the kinetic energy based methods pushed by his current employer.

That’s unfortunate but at the very least the videos are somewhat entertaining for whatever that’s worth.

Too bad personal politics can’t be kept out of this. The makers of these videos obviously have access to good equipment and could turn out useful videos if they could stick to one valid protocol.

I would like to see a whole series of tests done on ammunition from the Revolutionary War to the present to determine if historic references to effectiveness parallell with what we know now.

Videos such as these, if done properly, could add some useful data to our knowledge base.

“I would like to see a whole series of tests done on ammunition from the Revolutionary War to the present to determine if historic references to effectiveness parallell with what we know now.”

Quite a bit of such testing was done by Dr. Fackler at LAIR, going back to U.S. Civil War era weapons, Spanish American War, WWI, WWII, Korea, and Viet Nam era small arms. Back in 2002-2003 we posted results from an assessment of all U.S. military standard .30 caliber FMJ projectiles from 1900-2000. Likewise, we have looked at quite a few foreign military offerings and posted those results over the past decade.

Posting this data on the forums is a great thing and I’m very grateful to you, Doc, for having taken the time to do so, as well as Dr. Fackler for doing the research.

Perhaps someday, maybe even the next time my cardiologist sticks me in the hospital, I’ll take time and start building a large database and put all the data together in one spot so it’s available in one quick reference.

These observations are supported by examining Brass Fetcher’s “Reommended Reading” page:
http://www.brassfetcher.com/index_files/Page3207.htm

“Incapacitation probabilities” seem to be based in the mathematics of kinetic energy.

The documents presented there are certainly interesting reading, but from a layman’s standpoint, I don’t see much in the way of data that actually ties what they’re theorizing with what happens in the real world. I could have missed something, of course, but it seems to be a lot like reading theoretical physics books…

So why are they still funded, if they have no data to support their research claims?

Good question…

I know they used to have a link/setup where you could send them test materials and money, and they would perform the tests you wanted done. I assume you could spec the tests to be run with 10% gel. IIRC, they were reasonably affordable at a few hundred bucks a scenario. Considering the trouble and expense of doing this yourself, if you only wanted 1 or 2 tests done, it sounds viable. Do they still offer this?

I have never spoken with the gentleman who is “Brassfetcher”, so do not have that info; why don’t you contact him and ask?