OBR, MWS, SR25-EM and JP LRP-07

Has anyone done a side by side comparison on these rifles? Pros and cons on each?

Or if anyone has pesonal experience with them, I’d love to hear your take on things and recommendations…

No side by side, but own two of them, and shot the other two (friend owns the MWS and JP).

I’ll start and work down.

SR-25 EMC
Pros: Great balance between accuracy and weight, manageable recoil, ambidextrous out of the box
Cons: Cost, proprietary threading (muzzle devices limited in choice), a tad finicky on some ammo/magazines

Larue OBR
Pros: Very accurate (stainless steel barrel out of the box), soft shooting, very reliable on multiple ammo and magazine types.
Cons: Heavier then the EMC, middle of the pack cost wise.

JP LRP-07
Pros: Very soft shooting (feels like a 6.5spc), accepts SR-25 pattern magazines, very light for competition use.
Cons: Asthetics may turn some off, side charging handle has the possibility of becoming hooked on gear.

LMT MWS:
Pros:Lowest priced of the guns listed, accurate, and similar ergonomics to the SR-25 EMC. (Same style lower receiver).
Cons: Front heavy (due to modular barrel), cost is negated by using a stainless steel barrel, hardest recoiling of the 4.

Tried to keep it to what I experienced, I’m sure others will either agree with that, or post up counterpoints.

I have a JP LRP-07 and I have shot it in a couple 3 Gun Matches. Here is what I can offer.

Cost: Base price $3300

Configuration: http://www.jprifles.com/document_pdfs/LRP07%20Spec%20Sheet_115.pdf This is a custom rifle built how you want it. I have two JP rifles and have talked to John (owner of JP) at a few 3 Gun Matches. I don’t know of anyone who has ever ordered a JP Rifle and been unhappy with their rifle or their service.

Weight: Depending on your stock and barrel configuration, it can weight about the same as a .223. My CTR-02 and LRP-07 are about the same weight. I have the 18" lightweight profile barrel, with a Magpul PRS stock and JP thermal dissipator.

Recoil Impuse: What recoil??? JK, with the LMOS, adjustable gas block and JP BC break it recoils like my Noveske 16" Recce with a Vortex flash hider. Follow up shots are fast, but not as fast as my CTR-02. There is nothing punishing about the recoil.

Accuracy: It likes 168 gr. ammo best, but I can shoot 5 shot 1 MOA groups with WWB 147 gr. ammo. I have never shot it past 420 yards, but many have. Just call JP and ask them if you have questions about the long range accuracy and capability of this rifle.

Unique Features: Non-reciprocating side-charging handle. The side of the handle folds in and has never been a problem for me (even when I need to sling it and run-in fact it is even less likely to snag, or hit my in the belly, nuts, etc, than the BCM Med. Gunfighter charging handle on most of my ARs).

I am generally right in the middle of the pack in big 3 Gun tournaments and the last one I decided to shoot my LRP-07 against everyone else shooting .223 and I still finished exactly in the middle.

Cons: 1. Wait time. I haven’t ordered from JP in a while, but it took me 6 months to get mine (Good things come to those who wait)
2. My perception is that this is not a “tactical carbine”. However, if one wanted more of a "battle rifle"configuration, you could simply get the tactical trigger group and go with a non-adjustable gas block. Call JP and talk with them because I know he has supplied Travis at Magpul Dynamics with a LRP-07 to run during their training courses.

Summary: If you are looking for great balance, light weight, minimal recoil impulse, excellent accuracy, very personal customer service and know what custom features you want in a 308/7.62 platform, then the LRP-07 is and excellent option.

In the next few months I will be getting another semi-auto 308 from a different manufacturer and then I will be able to post a comparison. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not unhappy or dissatisfied with the JP, but I do like choices and variety.

Ive owned a MWS, own an EMC, and shot the OBR.

MWS: Same lower as KAC, the stock trigger is lacking the quality feel of something like a Geissele or KAC trigger, the barrel profile is thick and you cannot use something like a Surefire reflex mount. The gun recoils noticeably harsher than the KAC or OBR. The quick change barrel feature might appeal to some but it doesn’t to me. The stock iron sights are useless to me. I shot right around 1k through it, and zero issues with a wide variety of ammo. Feels pretty heavy and a lot of that weight is in front. With 1-4X optic, light, and a loaded mag it was over 13lbs.

EMC: More costly than anything else but comes with a nice trigger, gas system means recoil is easy even without a brake/comp, comes with the best iron sights out there in my opinion, is pretty light weight for a 308. Setup from the factory for a can. Accuracy is great.

I kinda wish there were more muzzle device options but they are slowly coming out.

Maybe once in 10 shots I get a day light visible flash with the stock M110 FH but I think that has more to do with the commercial ammo I was shooting which isn’t going to have the flash suppressant in it or to the degree, at least, a mil spec load will have.

Can be finicky with ammo since its running a rifle length gas system with a 16" barrel that is tuned to military loads. Ive shot a lot of different types of ammo through mine, and its all ran 100% except for Hornady Superperformance 178’s that popped primers, and one time I had the bolt fail to lock back with Herters russian steel case. Its run Herter’s 9 out of 10 mags without issue before and after that one fail to lock back. Ive run DAG, Silver Bear, Fed XM80, and tons of Hornady, Black Hills, Federal match loads through it.

I ran it to 2100+ rounds without a cleaning (not even out of the box) and only had those 2 ammo related issues mentioned above. Since the 1st cleaning Ive run another 300+ through it without issue. Accuracy is still right there with no noticeable degredation.

OBR: Not a lot of experience with it but shot reliable, was accurate, and is obviously well built. Im not a fan of the raised top rail as it causes problems with LaRue’s own scope mounts. You can get a shorter optic mount system but then you’re limited to the front bell size of the optic you can run. You can get some sort of cheek riser but for me Id rather keep thing simple, and not resort to contraptions to get a proper scope & cheek weld height. Not saying it won’t work but you can avoid all those issues with a mount with 20MOA built into it, and get the same exact outcome without the contraptions and issues. Then the CTR is what the riser was made for, and if you want to use something else it wont work. Like an A2, UBR, SOPMOD, ect. Theres basically 2 stocks that will give a cheek rise…the CTR with riser and the PRS.

The OBR also has the gas port selector so you can run a different setting with a can or without a can. Pretty cool feature since getting gas in the face with a can isn’t very fun, and it can improve reliability.

OBR comes with a Geissele trigger which is personally the best out there.

OBR is very accurate but not much more and I don’t think the very slight difference would even be noticeable other than bench shooting for groups.

I will also say LaRue has the best CS in the business, and Id feel a lot more comfortable if something went wrong with an OBR than my KAC. I also live 10 minutes from LaRue so it would be easy for me to get something fixed or get a replacement part. Im not 100% confident in KAC’s after the sale service. I asked about getting some replacement parts or what type of maintenance I need to do and never got more than a few rather vague answers and non-response in one case. If I needed a part Im also sure it would come with a hefty price tag for a little bit of metal. They’ve admitted in the past they are not setup to handle civilian issues so take that for what its worth.

My end opinion is that there really isn’t a perfect 308 out there yet since they all have some major drawbacks. I got the EMC since its the closest to perfect for me but the cost is 2k more than other guns. I was willing to throw in the extra 2k in price to get that. I thought the MWS would be near as good as the EMC until I shot them both side by side. I sold my MWS a week later since it was ‘that’ much better to me. I think, based on the competition, 3800-4k would be a more reasonable price for the EMC over something like the MWS w/SS barrel.

Does the JP take the Magpul mags?

Yes, it most certainly does. It’s an SR-25 pattern gun.

Sweet looking rig…although those don’t look like Magpul mags.

I have only run my LRP-07 with the 308 PMAGs and I’ve never had any problems. I’m sure it would function with many others, but the PMAGs are a great value and I have not had any problems.

The LR20, in my opinion, is not built to the PMAG level of quality.

No self limiting follower, and the covers fit like shit. I took a flat bastard to mine to get the covers to fit properly. Before they would pop off with an evil stare.

I think that is a good anecdote for the whole ar10/sr25 pattern rifles. Not as much time and not nearly the number of beta and “charlie” testers to find all the flaws and fixes. The AR15 platform is polished to such a state that most of the issues are worked out. Lot less people shooting the 308 guns- and frankly a lot more powder burning makes things interesting. Just a feeling I get.

I have a 16CL LMT 208MWS and have shot the Larue and have handled the JP and EMC. The Larue versus the LMT, the Larue was more accurate and more easy to shoot. I would like to get in a 18 inch SS barrel for my LMT for a more direct comparo. Why, O why LMT made the 16inch CL with carbine gas and not mid length gas, I’ll never know.

The Larue is a piece of art. I’m becoming more of a fan of slick fore-ends like the OBR and the Viking tactics (I have one of each type).

LW, let me know and we can take out my OBR and put some ammo through it.

Ack you’re right, so here’s a gift:

This is why I’m a huge fan of the Larue’s rail, I can’t fathom the need for mounting stuff on the back sides of the forearm, or really close to the magwell. The Larue and VTAC rails have it right, make it slick so you can choose not to have anything there, or make it modular in case you need a handstop or something else. It should come as no surprise that KAC is now doing something similar.

I tried their M110K1 upper, which is the EMC with slick rail, and it’s definitely nice, though I think the Larue’s is just out of the park effective.

Depends, I found the LR20s ran questionably in the SR-25 (their factory mags ran great), but the LR20s run great in the MWS and OBR.

I think it comes down to guns like the OBR, JP, MWS all being built up from functioning on civilian ammo and mags with the strength to handle M118LR and M80, while the EMC can sometimes struggle on the more varied and lower power civilian ammo and different tolerance mags.

I’ve seen the JP and OBR run almost any brand of ammo. But this shouldn’t be surprising, you get a high end sports car you don’t feed it crappy unleaded. For my budget and firing schedule I need a gun that can run on whatever I feed it.

I haven’t had any of the reliability issues you experienced. Im at 2400+ now. Herters was the only ammo that caused a malfunction due to lack of power, and that was one occurrence in 200 rounds of the bolt not locking back.

So the LR20’s work for me I just don’t think they are as of high quality as PMAG’s. The covers would not stay on no matter what. I had to expand the little groove in the mag where the cover clips in to get them to stay on securely.

Ive got 2 LaRue mags now, too, and they have worked fine although I wish they were not so slick. They feel like they are coated in silicon or something.

I certainly found the MWS was hard to shoot quickly because it would recoil off target. The EMC stays on target MUCH better. I even put a BABC on my MWS and it was still not to where the EMC is out of the box.

Ive not yet shot an MWS with the SS and rifle length gas but hopefully thats an improvement over the CL barrel setup. Id really actually have a slight headache after shooting the MWS. It was a sharp recoil impulse. No such issues with the EMC. That was one of my chief complaints about the MWS, and shooting them both side by side it was easy to see how much easier it is to shoot the EMC. The LaRue is also much better in recoil control than the MWS.

Awesome, and that’s good to hear. Mine definitely had feeding issues with multiple ammo types, and multiple magazine brands. And it was run very aggressively, not slow fired.

As for pmags, ammo doesn’t stay in my magazines long enough to make that an issue.

I know it’s heresy, but the OBR recoils softer then the EMC, and without the help of a 600 dollar muzzle brake.

Does anyone have an opinion on how the JP (or any of the others too, actually) would do in a very dusty environment?

It should recoil less with its heavier weight and a true brake like the surefire. Thats not heresy. A brake like super tap or BABC will never work anywhere near as well as a true brake.

My EMC works fine with PMAGs. I only use M80, M118lr or BH 175 so I dont know about other ammo with it though.

I have used the M110 K1 rail as well, I prefer it over the larue for only the reason of the integral sling mounts and integral front sight. I dont know why Larue didnt include integral sling mounts on the OBR rail. I do like that the side rails are removable from the OBR though.

Can you remove any part of the OBRs rail to get at the barrel to clean it? I have never taken one apart. I really like that the URX rails lower section is removable while still being a free float.

The rail technically is removable, not sure I’d want to do it without a good torque wrench. When I’ve filled mine up with dust and dirt I’ve just cleaned it out with an air compressor, water, then WD40 to push out the remaining water. Generally a swab on a stick makes quick work of the task.

I ran mine with a lot of different ammo types, for training purposes M80 and M118LR are too cost prohibitive to purchase and utilize when we’re talking about 1500-2000 rounds in a few days of use. The OBR does great in that regard since it was built for civilian spec ammo all the way up to the milspec stuff, so it really eats up the lower grade stuff. The JP is the same in this regard.

While I would like a QD mount in the tube, so we agree on that, I’m running the gun with an RSA, but I could still see the value in that though as an addition. I don’t mind not having an integral sight, it’s nice when it’s there, but it can limit how much of the rail you can actually use. Different strokes I suppose, either way the amount of rail you get on the OBR and EMC is just nuts.

Thanks for the question you poised. Lots of good first hand info. May I ask why you did not ask about the REPR Im not a fan just wondering is all?

I am interested to hear how the OBR handles next to a comparably set up MWS (like a 20" OBR vs a 20" SS MWS). Has anybody shot these two side by side? How do they feel with regards to weight, balance, recoil, accuracy?

Wondering how much the barrels with longer gas systems, and more weight, affect the sharper felt recoil with the carbine system on the 16" guns.