Not as blind as a bat, but...

Hey all,

Sometime next month or so, I’m hoping to pick up some optics for my new AR. Being very new to this idea, I’ve been doing lots of reading and trying to figure out what “makes sense” to me. So, I wanted to quickly run something by you and get some opinions.

My friend has both the Aimpoint Micro R1 and the EOTech XPS3 RDS optics on his ARs. I had a chance to look through both and I think both are great, with my preference going toward the XPS with the larger circle reticle around the dot. However, obviously neither of them magnifies the target (on their own), so that got me thinking.

I’ve read a lot of good threads about the Vortex PST 1-4x scope, especially for the price point and as an entry-level scope. I am not a sniper, I am not military or police, I’m also not a hunter. However, I do enjoy my time at the range and I do like the idea of having something helpful during any CQB situation. I’m not blind, but even at 25 yards I can’t make out anything significant on a paper target (which is the minimum rifle distance at my range).

Looking at price points, I can get the Vortex PST and a nice American Defense RECON-S mount for under $700 shipped or so (say, from SWFA). That is not bad at all for what appears to be a quality entry-level optic for a guy like me.

If I went with the XPS I’d have to eventually get a magnifier, same thing with the Aimpoint. So we’re talking much more money for essentially the same functionality. In addition the Aimpoint would need a mount, so it all adds up.

Am I missing anything obvious, or is the Vortex + ADM a pretty good choice for me? Like I said, I don’t delude myself as to my use case. I’m not a badass but I do like reliable hardware, and I think I could really use a zoom. What do you guys think?

Thanks!

Can’t help you with the 1-4x…I’ve never owned one since virtually everything I do with the rifle is under 100 yards, but for those times when I’m shooting out farther, I use an Eotech G23.FTS magnifier on my Eotechs and on my T-1. Doesn’t work that great with the 4 MOA dot on the T-1, but it’s excellent with the Eotech. It would be bigger money, though…an EXPS2 is $495 and the G23.FTS is $549.

Well, right, so you see my point. That’s basically $1000 for essentially the same functionality, at least from my use perspective. I realize that in the end I should buy what I want and like and find useful, I was just curious if anyone disagrees with my reasoning. That’s all :slight_smile:

I think your logic is sound. The PST + ADM mount would be a good choice. The dioptic adjuster on the eyepiece is easy & quick (does not require loosening a nut). This should be an aid in adjusting the reticle focus to your eye issues.

Here’s another variable to factor into your equation. SHOT is coming up.

A lot of people will be announcing new products, and there are a fair number of new optics rumored for release.

There are always folks that have to have the “latest and greatest”. They typically put last year’s greatest on sale, here and on TOS.

So if you keep saving your nickels, you might be able to step up, and get a barely used Accupoint or something similar.

Food for thought.

I’m in the same boat with my old eyes, and have a Trijicon TR-24G in a Larue mount, and love it. But I’m a big fan of ADM gear as well, and like their mounts.

Good points, of course, though the PST is supposedly the “latest and greatest” :slight_smile: It seems to match some of the criteria I’m looking for (true 1x, solid build, good glass, reputable company). I guess my question is more about the RDS vs. Variable Scope decision as it pertains to my situation. I’ve already read several threads on the question, but the posters were military/police/competitive shooters, so their criteria didn’t really match mine.

You wanna know the sad thing? I’m about to turn 31, I just have astigmatism and wear contacts, so I sacrifice a bit of clarity/focus for the comfort of contacts. I don’t even want to know what will happen when I’m older :slight_smile:

As you get older, you’ll lose your ability to focus on your front sight, so irons will be a problem. If you don’t have refractive surgery (LASIK or something) you’ll need bifocals in order to see distance and close up at the same time. If you do have refractive surgery, you’ll only need reading glasses. I had refractive surgery about 16 years ago and still am 20/15 for distance, but I now have to use 2.5 diopter reading glasses for reading and 1.5 diopter reading glasses for shooting iron sights in order to be able to focus on the front sight. That would have happened with or without the surgery, but at least I don’t have to wear glasses all the time.

A red dot sight collimates the reticle image and projects it to infinity, so it will appear just as in focus as the target. Therefore whatever correction you need for distance (if you need any) will also mean the RDS reticle is in focus too. With a scope like the the Vortex, the eyepiece can be focused to accommodate whatever correction you need, so you’re good to go with that option too.

If you stick with contacts, as you get older, you’ll most likely need to go to monovision, meaning that you’ll wear a close-focusing contact in one eye (probably your dominant eye) and a distant-focusing contact in your other eye.

Having had refractive surgery, I find that for shooting I only need a corrective lens on my dominant eye and only when I’m shooting iron sights (mostly a pistol since I rarely use irons on a rifle).

Anyway, I think you’re reasoning is sound on scope vs RDS. It’s a matter of preference and/or how much money you want to spend. For me, the money wasn’t that important, especially since I use the same magnifier across three different rifles if I need it. Even so, I don’t use it that often since most of what I train is close-in shooting and I didn’t think that a 1-4x would work well for me in that role.

Have you considered the Trijicon TR24? I’m in the middle of this hunt right now myself and the TR24 keeps coming back to me.

I run an EOTech OPMOD on my short barrel, which replaced an Aimpoint Comp ML3, and considered it for my mid-length build as well, however I too have been looking for a 1-4x for longer range shooting.

Anyway, just throwing another option out there for you.

You cannot hit what you can’t see. I have astigmatism and 62 year old eyes. Red dots used to work well at 200M and even at 300M in perfect conditions - assuming targets of sufficient size. Those days are fading quickly, (pun intended).

With the PST 1-4, or any decent magnified scope for that mater, I can both see and consistently put rounds on an 5" plate at 200M; 10" plate at 300M - in poor light. “Poor Light” includes both dim light and harsh light (bright sun somewhat in my face), which is even worse. Same for reasonable sized targets at 400 and beyond so long as the rifle and ammo are up to the task.

Red dots on the other hand rule at house clearing distance, with a possible exception for shooters with weak-side eye dominance. If you don’t know which eye is your dominate eye, this would be a good time to find out. (This is very easy to do.) A true 1x magnified optic, while still second to the RD for “most” shooters, is still very usable at room distance.

In the end, you pays you money and takes you chances…Or eventually do like most of us and end up with different platforms for different sues.

Wow, thank you for all the lengthy and informative responses, I really appreciate it! This is precisely the kind of information I was hoping to read. The vision-related advice was just a nice bonus, so thank you for that as well :slight_smile: