NIGHTHAWK or KIMBER?

my next 1911 purchase has come down to this,sell my nighthawk talon to fund a wilson cqb,or sell my nighthawk to buy a kimber custom II and cutomize it ? I am by no means bashing my nighthawk, it has been completely reliable through well over 6k.BUT ON THE OTHER HAND SO HAS MY KIMBER RAPTOR. So my question is sell my nighthawk or buy a kimber and make it to my specs? The only reason i am considering selling my nighthawk is due to the rear sight which is a novak adjutable . I just pefer a fixed rear like the 10-8. any kimber custom II EXPERIENCE is appreciated.

Try as we might to make reasoned comparisons, there really is no comparison. A Nighthawk or Wilson Combat pistol is really a different class of weapon than a Kimber. That isn’t said as a knock to Kimber at all, because price point is certainly relevant, but you’re really comparing apples and oranges.

Sights can be changed, but you can’t recoup lost bench time under the hand of a master, and that makes all of the difference in the world where the 1911 is concerned. Just because you cannot easily see or even feel the difference does not mean that it isn’t there. There is a reason why die-hard 1911-types will shell out $2,500 or 3,000+ for a gun that has a competent lineage.

I once faced a similar situation with a Wilson Classic (and was considering a swap to the CQB or Protector), but in the end, decided that the adjustable sight unit was sufficiently robust as to render most of my concerns mere vanity. In fact, after years of doing my best to put that to the test, I went right back out and bought another Classic. If it ain’t broke … :slight_smile:

AC

I have a Kimber Custom II that I customized.

Two issues as I see it. First the Swartz safety. You should research Swartz and decide for yourself. For me, if I had it to do over I would not get the Kimber for this reason. Second, MIM. Again, research and decide for yourself. But Kimber has a significant number of MIM parts, which they do well. However I now have a bag of Kimber MIM parts that I replaced with tool steel parts. The Kimber slide & frame, and probably the barrel too, are very good.

At the end of the day, I’d have been better to have either bought a custom (read: Wilson, Nighthawk, Ed Brown), or stock-standard Springfield Mil-Spec to customize and gone from there. That is what I would do if starting over because you get to a higher level faster & cheaper.

For my second project 1911 I did buy a Mil-Spec Springfield and proceeded to replace just about everything with tool steel to my liking.

YMMV. Good luck.

If you’re going to sell an already running semi-custom pistol just because you want something new, I’d recommend getting a Caspian frame and slide and sending it to a pistolsmith. Unless you just want the rollmark, it doesn’t make much sense to buy a Kimber, Colt, Springfield, etc. just to tear it down and build it back up again.

That said, between the choices you listed, I’d go for the custom job. I’m really wanting to send my Stainless II away for a rebirth but can’t quite swing the cash right now.

Can you outshoot your Kimber? Are you at the point that you wish it was more accurate? If not, please invest in ammo and a class.

I don’t get it-you’ve got a completely reliable Nighthawk, one of the more highly regarded 1911-pattern pistols, and you’re considering selling it solely because you don’t like the rear sight?

This is probably a blatent restatement of the obvious, but why not simply change out the rear sight? It’s not as if this is an unheard of procedure, and there certainly are plenty of excellent alternatives-other Novak sights (I personally prefer their wide-notch on my Nighthawk), 10-8, Heine, Yost/Heirloom Precision…

Best, Jon

I vote to stay with the Nighthawk. The sight can be changed.

The last Raptor I looked at was really well finished and I am sure it shot well, I just can’t do the Schwartz safety and therefore wouldn’t build on a Kimber.

MIM doesn’t scare me although I would prefer tool steel parts in some areas. There was some discussion on 10-8 and the 1911 forums and the census was that they see as many parts break of both types. My opinion is that areas like the hammer, sear, and extractor would be better if made from steel because of the heat treating process and how the parts are fit to the gun.

Even the big boys use investment castings for some of the parts like the thumb safety and beavertail so when a manufacturer says “no MIM” that does not mean that all of the parts in the gun are steel.

The problem with the Novak adjustable sight is that it is a distinctive cut to the slide and you can’t simply just install a different rear sight. I know this because I too have the same rear sight on mine and would have swapped it out if I could. That rear sight is the only thing I would have made different about my Nighthawk.

With that being said, there’s no way I’d take a Kimber over a Nighthawk. I also own a Kimber and there is no comparison between how those two are built. And Kimber does not make a pistol suitable for building upon. I’ve replaced all the MIM parts and customized mine, but no matter what I do to it, it’ll never be on par with a semi-custom. On top of that, many of the best smiths won’t even work on a Kimber. That, in my profession, would be a clue.

This is exactly what I was wondering.

Nighthawk vs kimber?

thats like ferarri vs yugo…

Keep the NH.

Sell the Kimber, use the proceeds to get something else.

FWIW, I have owned Baer, Colt, Kimber, NH, Para, Springfield, STI, SVI, a Henie custom, and a YoBo custom.

Some of the above I still own, some I don’t.

I’m a 1911 armorer and have worked on several Kimbers and got them running when the factory couldn’t and wouldn’t make them right.

I have an idea of what quality is and isn’t.

IMO, the only Kimbers worth owning are the Series 1 guns.

+1. I cannot see selling an NH–a beautifully made, semi-custom gun which you have already proven is a great shooter–and DOWNgrading it to an inferior brand. If you want to customize something, why not customize the NH?

I can see going from a NH to a Wilson. I can’t see going from a NH to a Kimber. Ever. To really gut out the Kimber and pay a smith to do it (if you can’t do it yourself) to get the level of the NH, would cost approx what the NH or Wilson will cost, and I still woudn’t consider the Kimber the equiv of the NH or Wilson. To throw an additional thought, personally, at NH/Wilson prices, I can get a true custom gun built using the best of the best parts from all manner of companies to my personal needs/wants/specs for a real one of a kind gun. Unless I simply wanted the brand name of NH et al, that’s the route I generally go. Or, buying base GI SA, or old Colt series 70, etc and having a build out on that. I had a Ti framed commander built on a Caspian frame and slide using various parts to my exact specs, and it cost approx that of a Wilson. This was the results:

Another Nighthawk vote here but a full sized one.

Jon,
Pretty sure it’s because of the Novak adjustable rear sight.

“The only reason i am considering selling my nighthawk is due to the rear sight which is a novak adjutable . I just pefer a fixed rear like the 10-8. any kimber custom II EXPERIENCE is appreciated.”
Someone correct me if I am wrong but I don’t believe the 10-8 rear will fit in the Novak adjustable rear sight cut.

Yep, I think that you (and others, like Federale) have nailed it-after checking, I realized that the Novak Adjustable sight dovetail is unique.

Perhaps Novak themselves have an interchangable sight that would be more acceptable to the original poster. Currently according to their chart 10-8 specifically does not have a rear sight for that dovetail (but it might be worth a call to Hilton Yam for confirmation).

I suspect that a custom gunsmith could relatively easily create an acceptable solution, given time, money, and appropriate amounts of silver soldier…but it might be disproportionately expensive to what the original poster is willing to pay. It might be well worth a call to Nighthawk custom themselves to explore alternatives at this stage.

Regardless, I still recommend that the original poster is far better off remaining with the Nighthawk than switching to a Kimber-but I do stand corrected regarding an easily interchangable rear sight switch-thanks.

Best, Jon

Haven’t heard that one. Examples?

The Schwarz safety system on the Series II guns is not something that many smiths want to mess with. There’s a reason why people recommend buying a 70 Series Colt or a Springfield or even a Series I Kimber for a good base gun.

Not only that, but the spotty Kimber quality control and well reported reliability issues have also caused people to shy away from working on them.

If you want to read what several well-regarded gunsmiths and serious end-users think of Kimber, go to 10-8 Forums and start searching for Kimber threads. And if you still don’t believe me, call around to some gunsmiths and see what they tell you. I did and guess what? All the modifications to my Kimber Series II were done myself.

A top smith can likely weld over your dovetail on the NH, and re-cut it for a standard dovetail. I know I’ve seen it done for the front.

Interesting. I know John Harrison will work on them, other 'smiths I have no first hand experience with. Don’t know about the “serious” end user either, but my expectations have been met with my Kimber.