Here’s the problem, My friend picked up a used S&W M&P upper at a gun show last week. Finally got to the range to give it a try. Released bolt into battery, first shot ok, when it cycled it would NOT strip off the next round. We try different steal mags and different PMag’s and under firing condition, would not strip of the next round. If you ran the bolt charging handle manually it would feed no problem.
Pulled my Bushmaster bolt out and compared the 2, as seen in this picture, the end of the bolt carrier on his M&P has about a 1/2" more steel on the end. Tried my BCG in his upper and it ran no problem.
Any thought to why it would not feed. This is the only problem we could find with it???
Thanks.
](http://outdoors.webshots.com/photo/2852830610103182288EZHqhr)[/IMG]
Sounds like a leak under the gas key.
If bolt group A works and Bolt group B doesn’t, I have to guess GAS LEAK.
Check to see if the key bolts are tight and that the key is flush to the carrier. ![]()
Will check that, Thanks!
Out of curiousity what type of buffer are you using? Regular carbine, H, H2, etc…
OP btw the extra steel in the BC is good.
Not sure. My friend is waiting for the site admin to approve his screen name. If i remember there was nothing stamped on the buffer face
What ammo are you running? Make sure to run full load quality ammo, M193 or M855.
Topher
If you search here you will find a couple other threads similar to this. I just had a problem with a heavier M16 chrome bolt from Young Manufacturing. I cycled it for a standard carrier and lost the same problem you reported. Although there seem to be a number of people here that recommend heavier buffers and slowing down the cycling, I am thinking the extra weight adds drag and causes a short stroke.
May be the gas can be improved on but for the time being, my problem was resolved with a lighter carrier. Go figure.
I would never have a gun that could only run on Mil spec ammo. If a gun can’t run on .223 ammo, it’s useless to me.
Mil spec ammo isn’t always available.
We try some wolf and federal both would not work with his bolt, Put my BCG in his upper and it cycled just fine. I even put his BCG in my Bushmaster upper and it would not cycle. I don’t think it had anything to do with the ammo we used. Like someone said, it should run on anything you feed it. We are going to check the gas key.
If I understand correctly you put his bolt carrier group into your upper and it would not cycle? You put your BCG into his and it did cycle. So if that is the case then there is something wrong with your upper. Is the gas tube lined up straight in the upper? Do you excessive burnoff coming from the FSb or gas block area?
Also has the weapon been cleaned? barrel, chamber? ![]()
That sounds like a gas leak in the carrier key or possibly at the gas rings (unlikely).
To test for gas, take a known good mag and load one round. Fire it and the bolt should lock back. Repeat 3 times. If it locks back all 3 times, you have good gas.
If it doesn’t, start at the carrier key and check tightness and staking. You should be able to see any leakage if you look at it with it dirty right after firing provided it isn’t too wet.
If you have a leak, remove the key and depending on its condition either replace it with a new one (if it is not sitting flush with the carrier or has heavy staking) or you may be able to just clean and replace/stake.
Get one of Ned’s tools to stake it properly. Some folks also locktite the screws…doesn’t hurt but not needed IMO if staked correctly.
Also…you could have a broken carrier key screw…which is a whole other topic.
If it was his bolt carrier group then it wouldn’t have worked in his friends weapon. And since he stated that’s what they did it has to be either his upper or possibly the buffer and spring. A defective bolt carrier won’t work in one gun and then not in another. Unless I am missing something with his post.
Correct my Bushmaster BCG work’s fine in my rifle and his M&P.
His M&P BCG does not work in either rifle. 45deg test seems fine in his rifle so we dont think its the gas tube.
He check gas block, but need to check for tightness.
Standard carbine collapsible buffer spring in both.
After reading these tips we did not do the one round in mag to check to see if bolt locks back. It will cycle and strip rounds off manually but not under fire.
Will update after getting a chance to give it a thorugh cleaning and give it a run again.
Cleaning Schmeaning! It should run filthier than and ARFcom wife/girlfriend picture!
I guess I am or was totally confused. Your BCG works in both weapons. His BCG does not. Correct? The gas block is easy to check if it moves or isn’t aligned properly that’s an issue. Do you know how to check the gas rings?
Here it is in a nut shell. With the bolt and carrier assembled, extend the bolt out and stand it on a flat surface with the bolt face down. If the bolt carrier collapses then the rings are worn, if it remains standing they should be good.
Does it look like anyone has dicked with this thing at all?
check for damaged gas ring…replaced my M&P stock 3pc. with one piece McFarland, runs fine.
Yes the Gas ring are fine. I did stand his BCG next to mine with it extended, it did not collapse. The only thing we noticed was the Rifle Length Quad Rail forearm was not lined up with the top of the receiver. It has a low profile gas block which is under the forearm rail. Sounds like we are narrowing this down. He is going to bring me the rifle tonight, Going to give it a real good cleaning, check all the noted suggestion from here and try it again tomorrow t the range.
Again thanks for everyone’s in put and keep them coming.
I would be checking the gas block to see if it is improperly installed and potentially blocking the gas port. I would also look at getting that forearm straight. I wonder if someone maybe dicked with this and knew that it was INOP?
Hey guys,
I’m the “friend with the M4” that we’re talking about here. Let me bring you up to speed so far. I’ve removed the gas key, cleaned it very well, as well as inside the carrier adjacent to where the gas key is. It was real munged up in there, it’s real clean now. I re-torqued and re-staked it.
Iraqgunz- the weapon does not appear to have been messed with. It does look like it’s got alot of rounds through it though, just from the filth not wear. The 10" handguards are Troy MRF units that came with the upper. Last night I got the installation instructions off Troy’s website and properly installed it. It’s good now. After the cleaning that I gave it tonight I’m starting to think that there was so much buildup in there that it wasn’t sealing properly or the gas tube was partially obstructed.
It needs to be test fired at this point to narrow it down any more but I’m hoping this has it solved.