Why 14.5? With you being new to the AR platform why would you want to limit yourself to a pinned muzzle device? Also if you go with a midlength they havent been as forgiving with the 14.5 barrel vs 16.
That being said Daniel Defense and BCM both make great carbine and midlength barrels.
I’d like to keep the length to a minimum, I don’t see much need to change muzzle devices very often. I have access to another AR to make my final discussion on.
I’m not 100% set on the 14.5 vs 16, though I guess I need more proof then the pinned muzzle device.
If all it would be is spending the time tuning I’m not afraid of that either. I don’t mind spending the time to get perfection out of it.
Are the noveske/rainier barrels worth the extra cash?
My SR15 has a lightweight barrel, its accurate enough for me so far. However if you take a class that barrel will get hella hot very fast. Just something to take into consideration.
Barrels of appropriate profile for a fighting carbine do get hot quick, too hot to be touched comfortably with bare hands. Handguards protect the shooter from the barrel although some will get warm, they won’t be near as hot as the barrel & gas block. Many shooters wear gloves in classes to protect their hands form heat as well as blistering during all the shooting.
I like how a lightweight profile feels on an AR, whether it’s carbine length or rifle length. With modern steels (lined or unlined, chrome moly or stainless steel) it will take quite a bit of shooting to wear it out even from the shooting done during a carbine class.
The M4 profile barrels and the government profile barrels have extra material ahead of the gas block. Mass here slows down how the rifle handles and while it helps radiate the heat of the gas block, it would be put to better use moved to the chamber end.
Simple answer is, a lightweight or pencil profile barrel gives the shooter a better handling rifle and will be durable enough for carbine classes