Montana Democratic Governor Signs Gun Bill

Well, here goes. We’ll see you in court.

Montana fires a warning shot over states’ rights
By The Associated Press

HELENA - Montana is trying to trigger a battle over gun control - and perhaps make a larger point about what many folks in this ruggedly independent state regard as a meddlesome federal government.

In a bill passed by the Legislature earlier this month, the state is asserting that guns manufactured in Montana and sold in Montana to people who intend to keep their weapons in Montana are exempt from federal gun registration, background check and dealer-licensing rules because no state lines are crossed.

That notion is all but certain to be tested in court.

The immediate effect of the law could be limited, since Montana is home to just a few specialty gun makers, known for high-end hunting rifles and replicas of Old West weapons, and because their out-of-state sales would automatically trigger federal control.

Still, much bigger prey lies in Montana’s sights: a legal showdown over how far the federal government’s regulatory authority extends.

“It’s a gun bill, but it’s another way of demonstrating the sovereignty of the state of Montana,” said Democratic Gov. Brian Schweitzer, who signed the bill.

Carrie DiPirro, a spokeswoman for the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, had no comment on the legislation. But the federal government has generally argued that it has authority under the interstate commerce clause of the U.S. Constitution to regulate guns because they can so easily be transported across state lines.

Guns and states’ rights both play well in Montana, the birthplace of the right-wing Freemen militia and a participant in the Sagebrush Rebellion of the 1970s and '80s, during which Western states clashed with Washington over grazing and mineral extraction on federal land.

Montana’s leading gun rights organization, more hardcore than the National Rifle Association, boasts it has moved 50 bills through the Legislature over the past 25 years. And lawmakers in the Big Sky State have rebelled against federal control of everything from wetland protection to the national Real ID system.

Under the new law, guns intended only for Montana would be stamped “Made in Montana.” The drafters of the law hope to set off a legal battle with a simple Montana-made youth-model single-shot, bolt-action .22 rifle. They plan to find a “squeaky clean” Montanan who wants to send a note to the ATF threatening to build and sell about 20 such rifles without federal dealership licensing.

If the ATF tells them it’s illegal, they will sue and take the case all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, if they can.

Similar measures have also been introduced in Texas and Alaska.

“I think states have got to stand up or else most of their rights are going to be buffaloed by the administration and by Congress,” said Texas state Rep. Leo Berman.

Critics say exempting guns from federal laws anywhere would undermine efforts to stem gun violence everywhere.

“Guns cross state lines and they do so constantly, and this is a Sagebrush Rebellion-type effort to light some sort of fire and get something going that’s pleasing to the gun nuts and that has very little actual sense,” said Peter Hamm, communications director for the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence.

In a 2005 case, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld the enforcement of federal laws against marijuana in California, even if the drug is for medical purposes and is grown and used within the state. The court found that since marijuana produced in California is essentially indistinguishable from pot grown outside the state, the federal government must have the authority to regulate both to enforce national drug laws.

Randy Barnett, the lawyer and constitutional scholar who represented the plaintiff in the California case, said that Montana could argue that its “Made in Montana”-stamped guns are unique and sufficiently segregated as to lie outside federal regulation.

Supporters of the measure say the main purpose is not extending gun freedoms, but curbing what they regard as an oppressive interpretation of the interstate commerce clause and federal overreach into such things as livestock management and education.

“Firearms are inextricably linked to the history and culture of Montana, and I’d like to support that,” said Montana state Rep. Joel Boniek, the bill’s sponsor. “But I want to point out that the issue here is not about firearms. It’s about state rights.”

Copyright © 2009 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Published on Wednesday, April 29, 2009.
Last modified on 4/29/2009 at 1:30 pm

Copyright © The Billings Gazette, a division of Lee Enterprises.

Montana is a state full of win.

I’m very interested to see how this turns out

Congrats to Montana and the other states also declaring (more or less) sovereignty using the 9th and 10th Amendments. These de facto declarations will not disrupt the mass corruption at the Fed Level - much less wake up the braindead public - but any step in the right direction needs to be duly noticed and awarded.

“‘Guns cross state lines and they do so constantly, and this is a Sagebrush Rebellion-type effort to light some sort of fire and get something going that’s pleasing to the gun nuts and that has very little actual sense,’ said Peter Hamm, communications director for the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence.”

Douchebag.

Unfortunately, I have a feeling that this will backfire and the Brady Douchebags will use it against us negatively.

Wickard v. Filburn…

I would not want to be the manufacturer in Montana that gets to test this…nor the first customer…

Cliff note me please! :cool:

as quick and dirty as I can make it…

Dude was growing his own wheat on his own property for his own consumption…

SCOTUS essentially ruled that since, by eating his own wheat, it effected his purchasing of wheat that could come from other states, his wheat was brought under federal purvue by the Interstate Commerce Clause…

or…to apply the ruling to what the folks in Montana are doing…

since someone in Montana may forego a firearm made in, say, Massachusetts to buy a Montana-made gun, the Montana-made gun effects Interstate Commerce and, as such, is subject to federal regulation

again…thats pretty quick and pretty abbreviated, but you get the picture

And now I’m intrigued. Off to read the whole thing. Thanks for the lesson!

Good luck to them. I may soon relocate to Montana;)

HOPEYCHANGEY for the masses! :smiley:

Ya’ know… as ‘bad’ and ‘eeeeeeeeeeevil’ as George Bush was :rolleyes:, I can’t recall any states filing 10th Amendment notices with the feds, much less talking about LEAVING the union. Even Taxachusetts and Commiefornia seemed moderately content.

Funny how none of THESE things were mentioned, about the OBAMANATION’S first hundred days… :rolleyes:

Poster (trio) is 100% correct. The issue has already been decided under FDR. Don’t forget most of the New Deal was struck down by the S.C. but upheld the rights of the gov. to regulate interstate commerce because they said intrastate commerce can affect interstate commerce.

Be very suprised if the S.C. simply decided not to hear the case and lets a lower(i.e.-Democrat) court ruling stand. In th end this could backfire on gun owner rights. The basic premise of the case is one that most people aren’t even aware of.

This being states rights vs. Fed. power. Most people are simply caught up in Dem. vs. Repub. The real issue is states rights vs. Fed. power. Most people don’t even know the real issue of the Civil War(War of Northern Aggression) was about states rights. In other words, the Fed. govs. power to control what states did in regards to rights not specifically granted to the Fed. gov. in the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.

The arguement was about who controlled what the states could or could not do in areas not SPECIFICALLY granted under the B.O.R. and the Constitution. Think about the repercussions in all areas of life if the Fed. gov. had to give real power to the states. This is the fight that is worth fighting. And, notice that some Dems. support states rights and some Repubs. don’t. This is how you really decide which politicians are worth supporting and which ones aren’t.

You recollect in error.

This is my concern.

Specifically, I worry about dicta indicating things like an AWB would be OK.

Please help out my memory…Which states tried to assert their ‘states rights’ under the premise of limited federal government powers?

Go “Big Sky”. I appreciate free men who are willing to stand in the gap.

there was talk of south carolina seceeding from the union under bush.

:mad: Let’s not turn this into ARFcom.

Talk and hearsay are just that…blow hard nonsense!! Montana’s Gov has actually produced paper to substantiate his and his state’s stance.

That said, I don’t believe in state’s dropping out of our union!!! It’s just that the people that make up this country need to wake up and come together again like they did after 2001. I’m afraid that this won’t happen because of petty differences. I do believe that the majority of Americans believe in the freedoms that we enjoy. There are a lot of kooks out there that would like to see America become a type of socialist/communist government. Mostly they are ideologues that can’t or won’t see reality. Unfortunately, they get most of the media’s attention because they make more sensational news!!! Sensational news means more viewers and of course more viewers equals more money which is after all, the name of the game.

Until, all the peoples that think and believe in the same freedoms come together, we will remain at odds and the media will continue to exploit those minor differences.