Mk18 vs bcm/etc with 11.5 barrel and A5 buffer?

I have an 11.5 BCM with A5 buffer, LMT carrier, and green spring, and was just shooting with a buddy that has a 10 inch Daniel Defense, I did wonder when or if the hypothetical benefits of the longer dwell time and buffer would be seen. If the mk18 has a proper port and buffer, what are the measurable differences?

I was thinking for a moment, if asked the only explanation I would be able to provide as a theoretical one

I have both (11.5" BCM w/A5 & a Colt 10.3 Mk18) & honestly, I don’t see any drastic differences. Both are nice shooters.
I’m usually only shooting my reloads & suppressed though. I don’t recall anything major when shooting NATO loads side by side.

Again as stated in the A5 thread, the main benefits are a wider range of operation with ammo, smoother extraction, more consistency in ejection, long parts life ect. Not necessarily something you will notice in your shoulder.

https://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?190748-The-Vltor-A5-System/page5

This.

Yeah, but ‘wider range of function’ means it will work when an mk18 won’t.

Longer parts life means the mk18 will break and the other still running.

Definitely things you will notice

So when do these incidents occur?

I thought you were talking more about the barrel ??

Vs LMT CARRIER

WHICH ?

I initially dismissed the A5 system as “snake oil” until a friend of mine loaned me a setup for my 10.5" SBR. I am running a Sprinco Green spring with an A4 buffer (can’t recall exactly). I never had any issues with function/reliability as the gas port was enlarged to .073ish by Adco and runs like a sewing machine both supressed/unsupressed. Regardless, it was a noticeable difference in terms of recoil after installing the buffer system. It felt softer and more controllable. When comparing it to the LMT M6’s at work, it was widely recognized as “feeling softer” by several people. Anyway I was sold on the idea and bought my own setup.

I also had a 16" BCM Mid-length and installed their “intermediate” buffer tube with an A2 or A3 buffer based on my experience with my SBR. It didn’t feel as drastic as the SBR but when shooting it back to back with another friends regular 16" BCM mid-length; it felt softer. We even asked a couple of random people at the range to shoot both rifles at without explaining the context. After asking which felt softer they all said the BCM with A5 system; both rifles were identical other than that so I don’t think it was a placebo effect or anything.

Anyway, everyone has different opinions but that was my experience!

He wasn’t saying the A5 isn’t something you notice at the shoulder. He was talking about the difference between 10.5 and 11.5 (I believe).

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

You’re not going to see dwell time. The difference will be apparent with function. The 10.5/10.3 seems to be the most difficult to get running. The 11.5 not so much.