Mississippi Sheriffs Lobby Legislature for Radar

I read that once again sheriffs in Mississippi are asking the legislature to allow county cops to run radar. In their wisdom the state has always refused.
Their rationale is that sheriffs would operate speed traps and other enforcement tactics to raise money–not promote safety. Texas has its share of speed traps, and so did Alabama. When I lived there, Governor George Wallace would place billboards warning of them outside of offending towns. I support my home state’s reasoning. Having grown up there, I also agree that the cash poor counties(almost all are poor)would abuse the system in this great land of milk and honey and law and order. Not too many years ago the warden at the state pen while testifying in federal court agreed to improve conditions on death row during the summer. He promised more shade and ice water. About the same time an escaped inmate after hiding among briars, rattle snakes, cotton mouth moccasins, copperheads, coral snakes, meth heads, and mosquitoes, did this. He broke into a house and called the sheriff and offered to surrender if the sheriff wouldn’t kill him.

Speed traps combined with hidden speed limit signs or sudden, impossible to slow down for changes (for example, from 55 to 25, 10 feet past the crest of a hill) are a form of soft corruption, and should be recognized as such.

Michigan recognized this issue way back and came up with a different solution:

  1. By state law, all revenue from speeding tickets goes into a state fund that the local government derives no benefit from. (I believe it’s marked for libraries, state-wide, but I would have to double check.) This way the local government is free to enforce the speed limits when their motive is safety and order, but is prevented from using it as a form of highway robbery.

  2. The State Police and state DOT measure average driver speed limits on all state-owned roads and have a rule of setting limits at the 85th percentile actual travel speed. This results in generally realistic speed limits. Local governments can still set the limits on non-state roads, but the state’s system makes it easy for the public to have a reasonable expectation of speed limits. I don’t know the details but there is a way a driver can challenge an unrealistically low speed limit in court.

  3. Despite all this there have been a handful of communities that still operate speed traps, usually pulling people over for speeding then writing tickets for something that falls outside the restriction in item #1 so the local unit can keep the money. When this happens there is significant pressure from the state government, both ordinary agencies and the MSP, and the locale that’s offending can get some unwanted attention. In one case Detroit Metro Airport started warning the general public that the surrounding govt was running speed traps, with signs in the airport and a PR campaign. The idiocy went on for only a few months and then stopped.

Our system isn’t perfect but it seems to have resulted in safe and reasonable speed limits, relatively good adherence to the speed limits (not strict, but far better than I’ve seen in California, North Carolina, or Ontario; you will almost never find the mass of traffic going 20mph over the limit like you do in those states/province), and an absolute minimum of the soft corruption from speed traps that are set up to snare people who aren’t being a danger (like the hidden speed-limit signs).

Some other guy,

That sounds pretty reasonable. I wish Florida was similar.

Anybody can scratch tickets. I think it is rather BS and there are better uses of LE time and effort than generating revenue.

I did a year as a highway pirate and felt worse about my lot in life than the guy who mops up peep booths. I eventually shifted my efforts and so forth elsewhere but it really is piracy. Some bullshit Sgt or LT bitching over “not enough tickets”. Never. Again.

Buuuut…sometimes I’d play this to get in the mood

//youtu.be/TZrh6eooyrg

Having recently retired, that was one topic I had thoughts of. You ask if enforcement efforts have any real effect on curbing it? In my opinion only if the driver themselves elect to obey it, until humans stop driving cars, there will be people that don’t abide by the rules. When you look at the origins of traffic laws, there were intended to promote safe operation for the motoring public. Have they been abused for revenue, of course. I’m not a roadway or traffic engineer but it seems we do more to inhibit the flow of traffic stateside then we do to promote free flowing traffic patterns.
Bottom line-traffic tickets will be written until the end of time and in my experiences, they will not stop people from violating code unless they want to.
I was always after the big stuff and like it or not, I knew the 46.2 code of Va. very well and it was the biggest tool available to accomplish that.

Oh my God, THIS ^^^^^^^
Right there, Ladies and Gentlemen.

Solid knowledge of Traffic Laws gave you insane amounts of ARS/PC to make some righteous stops. Everything from tagging dope boys to recovering stolen autos to active warrants.

It was almost like cheating and Public Defender/Defense couldn’t do jack nor squat. It’s all there in black and white.
That with a well written report it was like “Hi Judge, Bye Judge”.

But some people just want “stats” so they go after grown adults who dont wear a seatbelt or people cooking at 15 over.

You can get a week’s worth of legit charges AND put a POS in county for a while on one good stop.

See, these guys know they are dirty so they have to be super careful. Susie Q is just late for work. Susie Q is low hanging fruit and will pay online but, what have you accomplished?

Dope boys running red after 2000 know they gotta be careful. You sling them up and you’ve recovered:

-Drugs
-Guns
-Cleared Warrants
-Seized a Vehicle

and you ultimately have made that oft spoken of “difference”.

Is it vastly more dangerous? Yes.
But is it far more fulfilling? Oh Hell Yes.

This used to be a Gentleman’s game.

Yeah buddy! I’ve heard so many times when a narc needed someone stopped and the no load in the squad car would say they can’t find a reason—really:sad:

So what did they do with the nuns and orphans?

I don’t get the point of reference but I have ticketed a no joke Nun before and felt pretty shitty about it.

Some people love doing traffic. I do not. I recall getting groused at by a Traffic 3 striper for being tied up in jail and court and not cutting enough “real” tickets.

Bankers hours were nice but its hard to feel all oorah over jamming up people on the way to work or lunch. No matter how polite and nice you are, you’re still costing folks at least half a week’s pay and you still end up being an asshole at the end of the day.
Some dudes scratch 20 in a day and feel like they just shot Hitler and cured cancer.

Not I. But I matriculated to a more palatable slot. Shaved heads, mustaches, and Oakley M frame tanlines are like super triggering for me.

And God forbid you try to make legit hits. Nope, scratch that ticket in 15 mins or less or they’ll wanna 25 with you to piss and moan about numbers and stats and how traffic enforcement is “serious business”.

I recall a particular pissing match about dude wanting to seatbelt ding a heart patient who had open heart surgery and had a note.

“Well he can just brig it to court”

Sure. Fine. Whatever. I was never here. bye.

From the song you posted. They boarded the captive airship to pillage and…

Our grapeshot’s made this bird a wreck,
But a glance below deck
shows a crew of nuns and orphans

Then the song goes to the refrain and ends.

Oh! Yeah…I never paid attention to that part. I just liked the part about being Airship Pirates.

I overshared for nothing but at least I introduced muh wingman to possibly the only half-decent Steampunk rock song ever

Why? If anyone should understand the concept of following the rules it should be her. Of course if we used that as a standard cops would have to ticket a lot of cops. It’s actually kind of funny when that happens.

http://www.sun-sentinel.com/local/broward/fl-jane-watts-broward-sheriff-settlement-20160529-story.html

Not long ago FHP and Miami Dade had a similar “you gave me a ticket” feud going.

This.

The city I use to work for had a drug problem and waves of BMVs, guess what got you a higher score at eval time?

As it turns out the only people that showed up to our city council meetings were the blue hairs that eat dinner at 16:00 and go to bed after Wheel of Fortune. They have no idea what goes on after when the sun goes down. Just got to get them pesky speeders!

Priorities, got to have them.

I didn’t know you lived in Florida :lol:

I have spent more time getting my ass chewed by a superior over not writing enough tickets more times then I care to remember, but last time I checked there is still no “quota”. I normally don’t have an issue getting my ass chewed when I cut people a break. When you stop enough people you know who really should get a cite and who could use a warning instead. I have had my share of boss’ who feel like superman after writing a guy multiple cites, all I do is shake my head and be glad that I don’t have that mentality.

It can be pretty tough when your responsible for overweight fines as well. So far my worst offender was 35K in fines and that was with many many breaks. Now a person that gets that much in fines was also putting others at risk with the crap he was operating on the road. Most fines are from others who are just working, others are intentionally trying to break the law for profit. Its sometimes hard when tasked with traffic enforcement, but it also needs to happen at some level to keep people and infrastructure protected.

But I was fortunate enough to learn from an old timer who when I started told me, every department needs those who write cites they are a necessary part of it all, but you need to understand and realize if that cite is really necessary because it could end up in a domestic, unpaid bills, or food taken off the table

Can confirm, NC’s traffic laws are kind of sucky and the random enforcement does absolute dick to actually improve safety.

These are wise words. It grinds me to no end listening to guys at work bragging over writing BS NOIs.

In my part of Texas the highway patrol gives speeding/seatbelt tickets to other cops–like when in uniform and on the way to work. When I worked for the county, the HW patrol boys would call the sheriff if they clocked a deputy in a marked car exceeding the speed limit. I know of two instances when they pulled over two city cars(one in a nearby town)for speeding, and one of these was driving with lights flashing on the way to answer a burglary call. In this case, the trooper showed up on the scene to give the lecture. If I were a cop, I would not give other cops tickets except in the most unusual circumstances. The troopers must be super indoctrinated to give chicken shit level tickets to other cops. When I worked as a health inspector, I wrote three tickets in three years. If I had it to do over again, I would have written five tickets. Whenever I received the few speeding tickets that I’ve got, I was violating traffic laws and knew it and didn’t complain. I know guys who have been rude to cops when ticketed for speeding, and I lost respect for them for this. Hell. Don’t moan and groan when you already know you’re speeding and then get caught.

I actually liked it.

You were on a roll, that one and Left Eye on the same day.

Will, I totally agree with you contextually.

Howsomeever, I see way too many deputies and troopers speeding without running equipment, which in our state is a violation of the law. If I’m on the turnpike and a trooper whizzes by me at Mach 1 with no lights, he just established my new speed limit. Although the wife fusses about this a bit.

Seriously, in a personal vehicle I’m Mister 8-Over. In a patrol unit I’m Mr. Legal Speed. When I was working for the SO and my patrol speed (legal limit) was impeding traffic I would pull over onto the shoulder and stop for a minute because I understood most folks will drive a couple over the limit.

In my view when you are in uniform you have to represent an exemplary citizen - that is what you are being paid to do.

Man, this is unusual for me. I painted most of the day, and I guess I dozed off in my chair at about 8:00. Woke up at 1:30 ready to roll. Probably fall asleep in Sunday School later this morning.